User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
po
offline
Link
 
alright you want to know the problem with your team?

you dont have a DT or a MLB and you know why thats important?

Originally posted by
This page is currently a "test" version to allow you to play with settings, and will not directly affect the play calling in sims. Please check the announcements forum for updates when the final updates are finished.


So you may put it as a 3-4 but it hasnt been implemented yet. Probably wont be til later today or during the overnight switch.
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187

Do you know anything about football?

The 4-3 is the base for any basic run formation, it puts 7 men in the box.

The 3-4 is the base defense for a basic pass play. EXCEPT, strictly speaking, the 3-4 is not great. We have the option to play formations like 3-3-5, 3-2-6, and 3-1-7. That would give you dramatic increase in pass defense.

There ABSOLUTELY should be a difference between the two, and there is. Learn the basics.



Learn the basics? What are you, 12?

The 3-4 defense can play as a 3-4, or as a 5-2 depending on how you use your Will and Sam backers. As far as liability in the run, you should probably check the top NFL and college teams before you open your shithole; there are just as many dominant teams that run the 3-4 as run the 4-3.

The OLB in a 3-4 are more athletic than a 4-3 end; they can play the run, rush the passer, and drop into coverage; the 3-4 also has a wider variety of blitz packages than the 4-3.

And you can run the same nickle and dime packages with the 4-3 that you can with the 3-4; your point here is irrelevant.

And thanks for actually discussing the topic at hand; this was about THIS game; NOT the real world (how many NFL teams run to the right 80% of the time?)

This is about the game penalizing the run defense with the 3-4. If your "point" was correct, then we would see an increase in the pass defense in the 3-4, WHICH WE DON'T.



 
po
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel
Originally posted by Checkmate187


Do you know anything about football?

The 4-3 is the base for any basic run formation, it puts 7 men in the box.

The 3-4 is the base defense for a basic pass play. EXCEPT, strictly speaking, the 3-4 is not great. We have the option to play formations like 3-3-5, 3-2-6, and 3-1-7. That would give you dramatic increase in pass defense.

There ABSOLUTELY should be a difference between the two, and there is. Learn the basics.



Learn the basics? What are you, 12?

The 3-4 defense can play as a 3-4, or as a 5-2 depending on how you use your Will and Sam backers. As far as liability in the run, you should probably check the top NFL and college teams before you open your shithole; there are just as many dominant teams that run the 3-4 as run the 4-3.

The OLB in a 3-4 are more athletic than a 4-3 end; they can play the run, rush the passer, and drop into coverage; the 3-4 also has a wider variety of blitz packages than the 4-3.

And you can run the same nickle and dime packages with the 4-3 that you can with the 3-4; your point here is irrelevant.

And thanks for actually discussing the topic at hand; this was about THIS game; NOT the real world (how many NFL teams run to the right 80% of the time?)

This is about the game penalizing the run defense with the 3-4. If your "point" was correct, then we would see an increase in the pass defense in the 3-4, WHICH WE DON'T.





The game didnt penalize you.

The 3-4 hasnt been implemented yet.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel

This is about the game penalizing the run defense with the 3-4. If your "point" was correct, then we would see an increase in the pass defense in the 3-4, WHICH WE DON'T.


We haven't seen the 3-4 in the game yet, dumbass.

 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by stahu miguel


This is about the game penalizing the run defense with the 3-4. If your "point" was correct, then we would see an increase in the pass defense in the 3-4, WHICH WE DON'T.


We haven't seen the 3-4 in the game yet, dumbass.



And as usual, you've missed the point entirely. But thanks for trolling.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel


And as usual, you've missed the point entirely. But thanks for trolling.


Fine. Your original point was that your bars were showing 21 when in 3-4 and 36 in 4-3.

1 - You lose a defensive front lineman who are typically built as rush defense and replaced by a LB who is typically more well rounded, so the score will drop

2 - Your team has no one listed in the DC for DT

After that, you started complaining about an aspect of the game we haven't seen yet.

 
drkbgrk
offline
Link
 
did you remove player from the mlb position? how bout the dt position?

my guess? the bar doesn't calculate properly for teams with gaps in their depth chart. is has nothing to do with how well the 3-4 defends the run in the nfl, ncaa, glb, or mls.
 
Robbiesol
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel
Rushing defense is listed as 21 when setting defense up as a 3-4, while setting up as a 4-3 lists rushing defense as a 36.

I wouldn't expect too many teams to use the 3-4 if this isn't fixed.


Here is your definitive answer:

The Matchup screen places a ton of emphasis on three positions when determining your rush defense rating. NT, DT, MLB

When you made the switch to 3-4, you effectively took out the DT and MLB positions from the rush defense rating. What the matchup screen hasn't been updated with is taking into consideration the LILB and RILB spot in place of the DT and MLB. I'm assuming that will eventually be replaced.

I'm also assuming that you will be using the new Defensive AI, and by your post I'm guessing you made the 3-4 your base defense. That being said there are still some formations (Nickel, Dime, Your own defensive schemes) that will switch you to a 4 man front. I suggest you go ahead and set those posiitions on your depth chart now in anticipation, with your LILB filling into your MLB depth chart position with your RILB backing him up (or vice versa). Then place your backup NT (or equivilant) into your DT spot.

The defensive AI will still play the 3-4 as your base defense (because you set it that way) and will only implement the 4 man front when dictated by your settigs (which you have now set the starters for).

And most importantly, the matchup screen will not correctly showcase your "real" rush defense rating.
Last edited Jul 28, 2008 21:52:00
 
king1058
offline
Link
 
The 3-4 can stop the run. The Pittsburgh Steelers who ran the defense before anyone else really has only allowed 2 100 yard rushers in the last 3 seasons. The 3-4 can stuff the run.
 
king1058
offline
Link
 
By the way 4-3 and 3-4 they both equal 7 men in the box.
 
king1058
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JoeFlacco05
Originally posted by stahu miguel

Rushing defense is listed as 21 when setting defense up as a 3-4, while setting up as a 4-3 lists rushing defense as a 36.

I wouldn't expect too many teams to use the 3-4 if this isn't fixed.


qft


I don't think this is the real joeflacco05 because he didn't sign.
 
DrunkenCowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by king1058
The 3-4 can stop the run. The Pittsburgh Steelers who ran the defense before anyone else really has only allowed 2 100 yard rushers in the last 3 seasons. The 3-4 can stuff the run.


That's a lie.

Bud Wilkenson created the defense in the 40s while he was coaching OU...
 
lazloth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
Originally posted by king1058

The 3-4 can stop the run. The Pittsburgh Steelers who ran the defense before anyone else really has only allowed 2 100 yard rushers in the last 3 seasons. The 3-4 can stuff the run.


That's a lie.

Bud Wilkenson created the defense in the 40s while he was coaching OU...


He didn't say created, he said ran it. Pittsburgh did create the Tampa-2 though!
 
DrunkenCowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lazloth
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy

Originally posted by king1058


The 3-4 can stop the run. The Pittsburgh Steelers who ran the defense before anyone else really has only allowed 2 100 yard rushers in the last 3 seasons. The 3-4 can stuff the run.


That's a lie.

Bud Wilkenson created the defense in the 40s while he was coaching OU...


He didn't say created, he said ran it. Pittsburgh did create the Tampa-2 though!


It doesn't matter.

Bud ran it even before LeBeau..
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by stahu miguel

Lots of comedians here apparently.

If the starters don't change, then there should be no difference between the 4-3 and the 3-4.

And the match up settings do represent a reflection on the quality of your starters; try removing your backups or changing them around and look at the difference.

I was simply pointing out that there should be no difference between the defenses; or if there is some sort of reduction in run defense, then there should be a dramatic increase in pass defense in using the 3-4 (which is stupid).



Do you know anything about football?

The 4-3 is the base for any basic run formation, it puts 7 men in the box.

The 3-4 is the base defense for a basic pass play. EXCEPT, strictly speaking, the 3-4 is not great. We have the option to play formations like 3-3-5, 3-2-6, and 3-1-7. That would give you dramatic increase in pass defense.

There ABSOLUTELY should be a difference between the two, and there is. Learn the basics.



On one hand you make sense when you say there is a difference, but then you lose all credibility when you say a 4-3 is a base rush defense, and 3-4 is a base pass defense.. They're both base defenses period. Very few teams switch from 4-3 to 3-4 on passing. Quite the opposite.. they usually lose a LB or Two to go to dime or nickel defense, not ADD one.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.