I think I agree with your concept, although the details and classifications may be different. Well said.
Forum > Free for All > When it's all said and done best RB ever
Jerome Neil
offline
offline
Originally posted by DeWittFootball
Originally posted by Jerome Neil
Statistically? Probably.
But I still rate Sayers, Payton, Sanders, Dickerson and Faulk (off the top of my head) alot moreso than I have ever done LaDainian.
A solid argument could be made for Sanders and Payton, but Sayers is based on what could have been, Dickerson eh great but I say a step down from the top few, and idk how you can say Faulk only thing I would think of is receiveing but LT is the only RB to rush for more than 1000 yrds and catch 100 passes in a season so its not like he doesnt have receiving skills.
Once hes done LT will be remembered as the greatest in my mind for a long time to come. Especially if he can get San Diego a SB or two before hes done.
Yeah, LT has pretty much done it all but win the Super Bowl, I doubt it'll be long until the Chargers do though.
Originally posted by Jerome Neil
Statistically? Probably.
But I still rate Sayers, Payton, Sanders, Dickerson and Faulk (off the top of my head) alot moreso than I have ever done LaDainian.
A solid argument could be made for Sanders and Payton, but Sayers is based on what could have been, Dickerson eh great but I say a step down from the top few, and idk how you can say Faulk only thing I would think of is receiveing but LT is the only RB to rush for more than 1000 yrds and catch 100 passes in a season so its not like he doesnt have receiving skills.
Once hes done LT will be remembered as the greatest in my mind for a long time to come. Especially if he can get San Diego a SB or two before hes done.
Yeah, LT has pretty much done it all but win the Super Bowl, I doubt it'll be long until the Chargers do though.
cowbell
offline
offline
Now I may be slightly biased as a San Diego fan but I have to make my plug for LT.
LT's been good for at least 1200 yards rushing and 50 catches in each of his 7 seasons in the NFL. Adrian Peterson had a great year and I have nothing against the kid, but come back to me when he does the same thing for 7 seasons in a row. LT has been the model of consistency and dependability for a franchise that usually had nothing else to lean on.
When he first came into the league, he ran behind the worst O-line in the league and he was the only offensive weapon for the team. Opposing defenses have been gameplanning him (and only him) for his entire career and he has still managed to put up these numbers. He's singlehandedly carried the franchise and pulled the Chargers up from the pits to the top of the league.
Statistically, he might not be the greatest RB of all time, and only time will tell. He definitely has a chance to be, but I'd rather he leave the game on his own terms at the top of his game than pull an Emmitt Smith and stick around for too long just to get the records. I actually highly respect Barry Sanders for leaving at the right time even though he didn't reach that yardage record.
But in terms of what LT has done for his team, he's definitely up there with the greats.
LT's been good for at least 1200 yards rushing and 50 catches in each of his 7 seasons in the NFL. Adrian Peterson had a great year and I have nothing against the kid, but come back to me when he does the same thing for 7 seasons in a row. LT has been the model of consistency and dependability for a franchise that usually had nothing else to lean on.
When he first came into the league, he ran behind the worst O-line in the league and he was the only offensive weapon for the team. Opposing defenses have been gameplanning him (and only him) for his entire career and he has still managed to put up these numbers. He's singlehandedly carried the franchise and pulled the Chargers up from the pits to the top of the league.
Statistically, he might not be the greatest RB of all time, and only time will tell. He definitely has a chance to be, but I'd rather he leave the game on his own terms at the top of his game than pull an Emmitt Smith and stick around for too long just to get the records. I actually highly respect Barry Sanders for leaving at the right time even though he didn't reach that yardage record.
But in terms of what LT has done for his team, he's definitely up there with the greats.
Go Rams-Ocho Cinco
offline
offline
Originally posted by quicksilver
If Adrian Peterson can stay healthy, he has a chance at giving LT a run for his money.
But yes, LT will be the best of all time when his career is over. Nobody is or was more dynamic.
Sanders, Brown, Payton... All greats, but none have everything LT does.
Yes one has and you listed him. Peyton was the most complete back of all time. He stuck with a team that sucks and played with them for all his years in the NFL till they won the Super Bowl. Payton is easily the best ever him, Brown, Cambell, and Sanders. Then it would be Dickerson, Bettis, and Hornung.
If Adrian Peterson can stay healthy, he has a chance at giving LT a run for his money.
But yes, LT will be the best of all time when his career is over. Nobody is or was more dynamic.
Sanders, Brown, Payton... All greats, but none have everything LT does.
Yes one has and you listed him. Peyton was the most complete back of all time. He stuck with a team that sucks and played with them for all his years in the NFL till they won the Super Bowl. Payton is easily the best ever him, Brown, Cambell, and Sanders. Then it would be Dickerson, Bettis, and Hornung.
dlinebass5
offline
offline
Well, let's also not focus on stats and records. Greatness comes from too many factors to be determined in numbers. I understand what you're saying about LT, but I also know that the game of football changes through the years. This issue of "greatest runner" is just not comparable.
stat2883
offline
offline
Originally posted by dlinebass5
This issue of "greatest runner" is just not comparable.
even worse is trying to do it for WRs
--at least there the general consensus is Jerry Rice, but after that it gets cloudy real fast. Even Rice may not be a stone cold lock.
This issue of "greatest runner" is just not comparable.
even worse is trying to do it for WRs
--at least there the general consensus is Jerry Rice, but after that it gets cloudy real fast. Even Rice may not be a stone cold lock.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 14:30:35
stat2883
offline
offline
Originally posted by Israel Bennington
Jim Brown is a race-war mongering douche who beats his wife.
Let me know when you become a black man from that era.
I'm not even going to comment on the wife part.
Jim Brown is a race-war mongering douche who beats his wife.
Let me know when you become a black man from that era.
I'm not even going to comment on the wife part.
Israel Bennington
offline
offline
Originally posted by stat2883
I'm not even going to comment on the wife part.
You say that like it's not true.
I'm not even going to comment on the wife part.
You say that like it's not true.
dlinebass5
offline
offline
You seem to have skipped the "black man from that era" part... You know, the part where you got owned.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 15:25:24
Israel Bennington
offline
offline
Originally posted by dlinebass5
You seem to have skipped the "black man from that era" part... You know, the part where you go owned.
I guess being black and living in the 60's is a license to do whatever the hell you want.
You seem to have skipped the "black man from that era" part... You know, the part where you go owned.
I guess being black and living in the 60's is a license to do whatever the hell you want.
stat2883
offline
offline
Originally posted by Israel Bennington
Originally posted by dlinebass5
You seem to have skipped the "black man from that era" part... You know, the part where you go owned.
I guess being black and living in the 60's is a license to do whatever the hell you want.
What I'm saying is that the wife-beating is something that happens a lot across all races and times. I don't agree with it. However, the first part of your statement is just plain stupid. I'm not going to turn this thread into this kind of argument, so let this one die peacefully and get back on topic.
Originally posted by dlinebass5
You seem to have skipped the "black man from that era" part... You know, the part where you go owned.
I guess being black and living in the 60's is a license to do whatever the hell you want.
What I'm saying is that the wife-beating is something that happens a lot across all races and times. I don't agree with it. However, the first part of your statement is just plain stupid. I'm not going to turn this thread into this kind of argument, so let this one die peacefully and get back on topic.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 14:51:20
dlinebass5
offline
offline
No, but being someone who can't sympathize with that person doesn't give you the right to talk down about what you do not know. I believe the afformentioned term "douche" should be returned to sender...
Israel Bennington
offline
offline
Maybe you're right. I retract the "race-war mongering." But Jim Brown is a piece of shit for beating his wife.
stat2883
offline
offline
Originally posted by Israel Bennington
Maybe you're right. I retract the "race-war mongering." But Jim Brown is a piece of shit for beating his wife.
and I won't dispute that...there are a lot of "pieces of shit" in the world. However it is irrelevant to the topic of the thread and needn't be discussed further.
Maybe you're right. I retract the "race-war mongering." But Jim Brown is a piece of shit for beating his wife.
and I won't dispute that...there are a lot of "pieces of shit" in the world. However it is irrelevant to the topic of the thread and needn't be discussed further.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 14:58:07
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























