User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Let's Talk Top Player Threats
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Tommyd
well, the one who has the most tackles, sacks, interceptions isnt always the biggest threat.




 
WestSideR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by WestSideR

My player carries knives onto the field, I think hes the top threat. Defiantly!!

Seriously, this is a good idea, but its not needed.


Define "needed."


Its not necessary. Its useless.. Clear enough?

But I would rather not explain because youll just keep arguing without a point.
Last edited Jul 24, 2008 14:47:54
 
psych119
offline
Link
 
Good idea. Seeing what can be a real top threat instead of a ton of o-line men would be nice.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
No matter what happens people will argue it's wrong. I guess a lot of people really care who's put as a top player threat, but I just don't. Honestly, I kind of like the fact that O-linemen can get some love in the current system. Also, I'd prefer 4 team captains picked by the owner.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WestSideR

Its not necessary. Its useless.. Clear enough?

But I would rather not explain because youll just keep arguing without a point.


Its useless? As you called, I disagree.

If you also argue that the current top threats is useless (as I feel it is), then okay. The way I look at it, it would be a quick fix. It would spread the "love" around and give your team more of an identity. We all have at least 3 linemen in the top player threats. No one pays much attention to them anymore. This new system might bring life back to the top player threats.

I was on a new team and it had a backup OG as a top player threat over all players on a very good defense. That is not right.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
I'm sure he meant that the current system is also useless which I agree. I find it's very easy to scout a team for their strengths very quickly with just their roster.
Last edited Jul 24, 2008 15:20:06
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kira
I'm sure he meant that the current system is also useless which I agree. I find it's very easy to scout a team for their strengths very quickly with just their roster.


I agree. It is useless. I guess the argument here is, get rid of it or change it.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Seconded.
 
have2laugh
offline
Link
 
I love the idea. Although Id suggest that a simple way to give a true picture is to assign 1 or 2 "key stats" to each position (pancakes for linemen, catches+yards for WR) and then show the top threats as the 4 players who exceed the positional average in their position by the most, the maths are simple and shouldnt be too complicated to work in.

The only problem with this that I can see is that QBs, Ks and Ps will almost always end up in the top threats, so they should probably be exempt as its fairly obvious who the top threat is at those positons, also FS's and SS's would probably need to be lumped in with the CBs
Last edited Jul 24, 2008 16:34:40
 
Tommyd
offline
Link
 
o stop complaining, its a good idea to show who the actual biggest threats are on both sides of the ball
 
lc512
offline
Link
 
Why not take their overall scouting bar (the real number, not after it's rounded up to 3), then compare it to the average number for starters at that position in the league. The guys with the highest value above average are the top 4 player threats. Great builds will be rewarded.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lc512
Why not take their overall scouting bar (the real number, not after it's rounded up to 3), then compare it to the average number for starters at that position in the league. The guys with the highest value above average are the top 4 player threats. Great builds will be rewarded.


That's a decent idea, but just because a player has no SAs and low mental attributes and therefore a high overall bar doesn't nessicarily mean they have the best builds.
 
WestSideR
offline
Link
 
I am for it, all im saying is its not necessary. Do research, look at their roster? Common sense???????
 
ThunderLips
offline
Link
 
not that it's that big of a deal it's just kind of annoying that every good teams top threats are all olinemen. How about keep the exact same system just balance it out a little more so linemen don't dominate top threats. Make more attributes count for their blocking skill bar and that will solve that issue.

 
vorenus73
offline
Link
 
very good idea with the MNF model. Yeah it is cool when my guard is the #1 threat on the team, but come on...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.