User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP Bonuses for Impact Plays made on the field - a must add
Page:
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Infallable

A "breakout" season is when a player finally improves to the point where he's productive.


We disgaree here. A player could have been 'productive' the previous year/game but 'breaks-out' in terms of far exceeding his previously established level of play. That's how I view it.

Also, how else do you gauge if a player is 'getting better'? By the Plays he makes on the field. That's why XP should be impacted by Big-Playmaking because, as it relates to GBL, XP is the primary means through which users enhance their player's skills and progress that player.
Last edited Apr 12, 2008 19:27:46
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Urrymonster
And thus begins the never ending cycle of marking smart comments. In his initial post he did not demand anything or tell the admins to do anything. If you stopped and read, you would have realised that he was being general and making a suggestion. I do not understand the necessity to 'bite back' or make unneeded comments to people and so I dont really understand why your responded in the manor you did, to him or myself. Have no worries I will now ignore every post you now make based on the example you have shown me. I will judge your petty posts much like you judged the wording on his title.



Hypocrite much?
 
HustonJ
offline
Link
 
So, you agree that you spend XP to get better.

But, you expect that you get better faster when what you have been training to do runs EXACTLY AS SCRIPTED?

When things go the way they were planned, the opportunities to learn GO DOWN.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Urrymonster
An entirely unneeded attitude there, it is a valid point and the title is just his opinion so you are more than capable of ignoring it.



And by the way, don't respond to me again. It's immature. Why don't you just choose to ignore my posts. Are you not capable of ignoring my posts?

The guy who started this thread is doing a great job and it is very disrespectful of us to have some petty argument. Ignore it, man. Just ignore it.
 
warshy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn

And by the way, don't respond to me again. It's immature. Why don't you just choose to ignore my posts. Are you not capable of ignoring my posts?

The guy who started this thread is doing a great job and it is very disrespectful of us to have some petty argument. Ignore it, man. Just ignore it.


are you trying to make yourself sound smart? cause it isn't working
as for the suggestion, i'm liking it, would give some people a reason to play on hard intensity

Last edited Apr 12, 2008 17:38:44
 
enoch101
offline
Link
 
One thought-

I had a cornerback who I was playing soft coverage with who made about 12 tackles in one game. That really was a poor game for him considering he gave up about 12 catches. I adjusted so he covers differently sometimes and now he has few tackles and fewer catches by his receiver. So it would need to be a well thought out formula.
Last edited Apr 12, 2008 17:48:03
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
I don't know so much about "impact" plays and I haven't played GLB enough yet to notice the difference in my own player, but I think the basic premise (which seems to be the intention of the admins) behind his suggestion is true. The game bases its XP far too much on the stamina/# of plays and not enough on stats.

I think stats do provide some kind of basis for higher XP. It's not really about success or failure. It's a sign of skill application and hence skill learning.

If you have more stats then it means that your player applied more of some skills during the play than the other players on the field. He was more involved in the game. He was differentiated.

For example:

1)your player had the vision to sniff out a screen when no one else did

2)your player used his vision, jumping and catching to break up a pass when the other guys only used speed and agility to cover

3)if a team is throwing against a corner so much he has a lot of tackles, it means he is giving up a lot. So the corner is learning more about better coverage.

4)a qb who completes long passes a lot is learning to develop accuracy down the field in game situations whereas a backup qb is not getting that experience.
Last edited Apr 12, 2008 18:08:00
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HustonJ

But, you expect that you get better faster when what you have been training to do runs EXACTLY AS SCRIPTED?


When you measure how often things 'run exactly as scripted' vs. how often they do not...especially in football and specifically impact plays...then yes you should get better faster. Think about it...why are they even called BIG PLAYS and not "Expected Plays" or "Exactly as Scripted Plays"? Because they are not the norm. Players can learn from making those Big Plays and having those successes as much as failures because they study what made that BIG PLAY happen and how they exceeded normal expectations. They then try to duplicate that the next time around. That's why players In GBL should be rewarded for making such plays.

Keeping this to GBL:

--Two RDE's identical in every way (ht/wt, level, attributes, special abilities, training focus and intensity, playing intensity, tactics, equipment, etc.). These two DE's play the same exact amount of snaps during the game. RDE #1 makes 1 tackle and has two offsides penalties called against him. DE #2 makes 5 tackles, 2 tackles for loss, 1 sack, and a forced fumble.

Is it fair that they should come away with the same amount of XP regardless of performance and progress toward their next level-up at the same rate? No way! That's why IMO the devs should strongly consider adding XP Bonus/Penalties to the game.

Last edited Apr 12, 2008 18:19:46
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
I don't know so much about "impact" plays and I haven't played GLB enough yet to notice the difference in my own player, but I think the basic premise (which seems to be the intention of the admins) behind his suggestion is true. The game bases its XP far too much on the stamina/# of plays and not enough on stats.

I think stats do provide some kind of basis for higher XP. It's not really about success or failure. It's a sign of skill application and hence skill learning.

If you have more stats then it means that your player applied more of some skills during the play than the other players on the field. He was more involved in the game. He was differentiated.

For example:

1)your player had the vision to sniff out a screen when no one else did

2)your player used his vision, jumping and catching to break up a pass when the other guys only used speed and agility to cover

3)if a team is throwing against a corner so much he has a lot of tackles, it means he is giving up a lot. So the corner is learning more about better coverage.

4)a qb who completes long passes a lot is learning to develop accuracy down the field in game situations whereas a backup qb is not getting that experience.


THANK YOU!!
 
Infallable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by HustonJ


But, you expect that you get better faster when what you have been training to do runs EXACTLY AS SCRIPTED?


When you measure how often things 'run exactly as scripted' vs. how often they do not...especially in football and specifically impact plays...then yes you should get better faster. Think about it...why are they even called BIG PLAYS and not "Expected Plays" or "Exactly as Scripted Plays"? Because they are not the norm. Players can learn from making those Big Plays and having those successes as much as failures because they study what made that BIG PLAY happen and how they exceeded normal expectations. They then try to duplicate that the next time around. That's why players In GBL should be rewarded for making such plays.

Keeping this to GBL:

--Two RDE's identical in every way (ht/wt, level, attributes, special abilities, training focus and intensity, playing intensity, tactics, equipment, etc.). These two DE's play the same exact amount of snaps during the game. RDE #1 makes 1 tackle and has two offsides penalties called against him. DE #2 makes 5 tackles, 2 tackles for loss, 1 sack, and a forced fumble.

Is it fair that they should come away with the same amount of XP regardless of performance and progress toward their next level-up at the same rate? No way! That's why IMO the devs should strongly consider adding XP Bonus/Penalties to the game.



But the guy who isn't producing as much has a greater chance to improve, which is what experience and level ups are for.
 
HustonJ
offline
Link
 
You've never studied tactics and strategy, have you?

You don't spend much time covering how a traditional set of choices applied in a traditional way succeeded.

You DO spend time looking at how they failed.

You DO spend time looking at on-the-fly adaptations that enabled success when things were failing.

When a young man is learning a skill, he makes more progress when he is struggling than he does when things seem obvious to him.

I understand this is not how you want to perceive reality, but, so what?
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HustonJ
You've never studied tactics and strategy, have you?

You don't spend much time covering how a traditional set of choices applied in a traditional way succeeded.

You DO spend time looking at how they failed.

You DO spend time looking at on-the-fly adaptations that enabled success when things were failing.

When a young man is learning a skill, he makes more progress when he is struggling than he does when things seem obvious to him.

I understand this is not how you want to perceive reality, but, so what?
Yes, it is true that failure leads to a greater amount of learning. But this learning component is already included in the GLB system.

Weaker/failing players already have a bonus in GLB: Lower level players gain more experience per play and per day than higher level players. Level 1 players get to 1000 faster than Level 2 players and Level 2 players get to 1000 faster than Level 3 players and so on.

However, it is also true that in sports success doing something is reinforced everytime it is done well. For example, Michael Jordan makes clutch shots because his muscle memory has been making clutch shots his whole life. His body is learning with every success how to replicate that success.

Take a football example. Ryan Leaf and Peyton Manning entered the league together and basically started out equally. We all know the result of this.. Peyton's success only led to more success, Leaf's failures did not lead to a "catching up". This component is not included in GLB.

Since skill improvement in GLB can only come from XP, GLB needs to create somekind of bonus for players that perform well. It doesn't even have to be a big bonus, there just has to be a bonus.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 03:07:44
 
HustonJ
offline
Link
 
Ever think that the difference between Ryan Leaf and Peyton Manning, in GLB terms, could be reduced to repeated boosting versus no boosting?

Situations can be explained in multiple ways.

Responsible game design requires trying to establish mechanics that are reasonably easy to understand, that provide an even foundation for the players to advance from, and that can be implemented in fairly straight-forward methods.

Boosting is an example of a game component that does NOT fit these rules. It does, however, provide the players incentive to fund the very existence of the game. Makes for a good reason to consider breaking basic game design rules.

Bort (and DD) have to look at these recommendations and decide which ones are CLEARLY supported by the player base, which ones appear to match the basics of game design, which ones will be simple enough for Bort to add to the system fairly quickly, and then which ones they just actually like.

This recommendation qualifies on list point 3 easily.

Those arguing against you are doing so in order to prevent the inaccurate appearance of a clean consensus on list point 1.

Anyone behind the power curve will be pushed further and further behind by this kind of rule, so I believe the idea violates list point 2.

I don't expect to change the mind of those who want to get richer.

I expect to present a balanced case when Bort or DD get around to checking this thread discussing the idea.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
Originally posted by HustonJ

You've never studied tactics and strategy, have you?

You don't spend much time covering how a traditional set of choices applied in a traditional way succeeded.

You DO spend time looking at how they failed.

You DO spend time looking at on-the-fly adaptations that enabled success when things were failing.

When a young man is learning a skill, he makes more progress when he is struggling than he does when things seem obvious to him.

I understand this is not how you want to perceive reality, but, so what?


Yes, it is true that failure leads to a greater amount of learning. But this learning component is already included in the GLB system.

Weaker/failing players already have a bonus in GLB: Lower level players gain more experience per play and per day than higher level players. Level 1 players get to 1000 faster than Level 2 players and Level 2 players get to 1000 faster than Level 3 players and so on.

However, it is also true that in sports success doing something is reinforced everytime it is done well. For example, Michael Jordan makes clutch shots because his muscle memory has been making clutch shots his whole life. His body is learning with every success how to replicate that success.

Take a football example. Ryan Leaf and Peyton Manning entered the league together and basically started out equally. We all know the result of this.. Peyton's success only led to more success, Leaf's failures did not lead to a "catching up". This component is not included in GLB.

Since skill improvement in GLB can only come from XP, GLB needs to create somekind of bonus for players that perform well. It doesn't even have to be a big bonus, there just has to be a bonus.


Great points kinglehr!

Originally posted by HustonJ

I expect to present a balanced case when Bort or DD get around to checking this thread discussing the idea.


I'm looking forward to Bort's and DD's input as well. It'd indicate that they might at least be somewhat intrigued by this concept - as well as the XP Penalty System( http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=64091 ) - as possible additions to GBL.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 12:57:47
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Peyton's successes? Like the 28 INTs he threw his first year?

You made a point, but it was the one counter to your own
Peyton learned from his mistakes, Leaf didn't (and got injured a ton more and was a jerk about it...)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.