User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
EagleScream
offline
Link
 
Greetings,

A number of us have seen the Canada A situation and felt that if they were to come to Canada AA they would have to improve dramatically to compete. That said, Kensington and Slack Jawed had to do that when they were promoted from AA to AAA last season so I feel they should be competitive but if they need an additional year does not matter to me, give it (the right not to be promoted this season) to them if they really want it, why not

Cheers, Eagle Scream
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 08:46:44
 
jasta07
offline
Link
 
I'm in a Canadian A team that would get promoted and I feel like we only just found our feet in the playoffs.

I think getting promoted now would just sweep the rug out from under us again. We need more time to fill some of our gaps and bolster our depth a bit.
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 08:49:26
 
jokerpac32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleScream
Greetings,

A number of us have seen the Canada A situation and felt that if they were to come to Canada AA they would have to improve dramatically to compete. That said, Kensington and Slack Jawed had to do that when they were promoted from AA to AAA last season so I feel they should be competitive but if they need an additional year does not matter to me, give it (the right not to be promoted this season) to them if they really want it, why not

Cheers, Eagle Scream


Class post right here. This site needs more players like this one!

 
zook28
offline
Link
 
I think when you make an exception, for whatever reason, it opens the door for a variety of issues down the road. With that being said...

Some of the teams have been very active in signing higher level talent in hopes of dominating the A league the next season, why not promote those teams...the one's who are equipped for the AA level and for the future? In some cases this means the champion of the A league would not be promoted, but who would want to stockpile talent that is much higher then the league average to win a A league championship?

Taking a look at some of the teams in A, I feel they would be competitive in the AA. Not challenge for the championship but that's not realistic at all. At least in Canada AA#4 teams like the Snails and Heat started off worse then some of the A teams and they've been working to improve their squads. Hit the FA market, change your squads...that's what the AA squads had to do when we started out.
 
Matrims
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1858
0-16 team that will get demoted.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3665
Champion of A#8

So now the winner will become the loser and the loser will become the winner. There is something very wrong with that picture.
 
puckvega
offline
Link
 
I can't speak for the other A teams but as DC of the A#4 champs I think promotion is fine. Will we need to make some tough choices and bring in some higher level talent? Yes, but we would need to do that anyway. Will we be competitive with the average teams in AA? No. It will be a challenge but we should be able to put up a good fight to keep from being relegated back down.

Personally it is a challenge I am looking forward to so hopefully they promote us.
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 09:58:16
 
DaveTN
offline
Link
 
A major part of the problem is this is now day 40 and Bort is still seeking opinions on this issue. If Bort had made a decision, right or wrong, and posted it a long time ago then teams would have had a decent amount of time to adjust accordingly.
 
jokerpac32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Matrims
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1858
0-16 team that will get demoted.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3665
Champion of A#8

So now the winner will become the loser and the loser will become the winner. There is something very wrong with that picture.


and the sad thing is the 0-16 AA team has a better team on paper.
 
jokerpac32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaveTN
A major part of the problem is this is now day 40 and Bort is still seeking opinions on this issue. If Bort had made a decision, right or wrong, and posted it a long time ago then teams would have had a decent amount of time to adjust accordingly.


Exactly the point I've been making on several forums. I would of loved the promotion to AA, but with no warning, I'm 1005 against it.
 
DaveTN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jokerpac32

Exactly the point I've been making on several forums. I would of loved the promotion to AA, but with no warning, I'm 1005 against it.


I know it, and we both completely agree on this issue that should be a non issue now on day 40.

Bort - Day 40 is too late for debate. No promotion is possible at this time because you did not make a decision sooner.

 
Link
 
First point of arguement, this thread was created for Canada AA players and owners, not all the A players and owners.

Second point, the top A teams that won championships should be able to compete come next season. I have seen some that have 7,500,000 plus to spend on stadium construction, which alot of AA teams could only dream of. With that kind of financial basis, they will be able to bring in some better players and at very least avoid the bottom two. In Canada AA#1 we had teams taken over midseason, they completely rebuilt and made the playoffs. AT the point they were taken, they were in 14yth out of 16. Tehjre is no reason a promoted team couldn't build a very competitive team. As levels get higher, the gap becomes less noticeable and more relies on gameplanning.
 
jimmy1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jokerpac32
As a GM for a team in Canada A that would get promoted I personally am against it. Personally I wouldn't of cared either way a few days ago, but with this being day 40. NO WAY! I've spoken to several FA's in the higher levels, like 18-22 as spoken above. And all said until we know if we'll be A or AA, no thanks. And have committed with other teams. This has completely hurt my chances at signing any of these players. And I'm sure other A owners and GM's have felt this as well.

Plus take the following under consideration.

1) We were level capped at 13.
2) Our chemistry grace period was less than half it normally is.
3) We only got our teams for 8 games.
4) AA's have been a free go since jump.

I'm sure I could go on and on, but all in all regardless of fair or unfair, I don't think it mattered, but when the teams don't know until at the gun, it hurts. Plus no one has actually come forward, that I've seen and said for sure the level cap was being lifted. I'm guessing that it will be, but until an actually official decision is said, it's all assumption.

So to sum this all up, I'd feel bad for the AA team's that got whacked this year. But the sad thing is no matter how bad those AA teams were against AA teams, chances are 95% or more of those whacked teams are better than the A teams that would be promoted.

And use the Canada A #4 champions. They have great starters, they might be able to compete in AA. But pull back the skirt and you'll see very weak depth, and they would kill them in AA. But upgrading can fix that, sure. But that takes me back to the teams not knowing until the last second, and players worried about XP hits.

So yah all teams, owners, players should get a full season with no restrictions before being promoted.



totally agree
 
fixxxer101
offline
Link
 
It isnt the fact that the cap was to small in my eyes, it the combo of the cap and only being able to play half a season. The players we got weren't able to level up. That is 8 more games of XP our guys are missing.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaveTN
Originally posted by jokerpac32


Exactly the point I've been making on several forums. I would of loved the promotion to AA, but with no warning, I'm 1005 against it.


I know it, and we both completely agree on this issue that should be a non issue now on day 40.

Bort - Day 40 is too late for debate. No promotion is possible at this time because you did not make a decision sooner.



Um...promotion has always been the plan. Why would you assume were were obviously going to make an exception to something that has been the rule for every other league every year?

If that is your argument, then we should go ahead with promotions, not suddenly change the plan and skip them.
 
Elway
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by DaveTN

Originally posted by jokerpac32



Exactly the point I've been making on several forums. I would of loved the promotion to AA, but with no warning, I'm 1005 against it.


I know it, and we both completely agree on this issue that should be a non issue now on day 40.

Bort - Day 40 is too late for debate. No promotion is possible at this time because you did not make a decision sooner.



Um...promotion has always been the plan. Why would you assume were were obviously going to make an exception to something that has been the rule for every other league every year?

If that is your argument, then we should go ahead with promotions, not suddenly change the plan and skip them.


+1
When I got the new team in Canada A I assumed promotion relegation would apply.

I think this is another case where Bort is trying to be too nice. You can't drop this in his lap.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.