User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > I have some possibly relevant info about "Playoff Game ENG Bug".... by Vanilla Thunder
Page:
 
Link
 
I wonder if your game would sim the same if it was run again or not? It terms of the weird ENG settings...

 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
I wonder if your game would sim the same if it was run again or not? It terms of the weird ENG settings...



I'm sure it wouldn't. If Bort ran a test game on his server (which I'm sure he already has) the game would likely sim as intended.

Basically, the end result is that something (or someone) caused the tactics to change to oddly extreme numbers. If Bort says it would be set to a null value and not 1, then I respect that.

I also know, whether or not anyone believes me, that neither my GMs, nor myself obviously, did this. If we agree to assume the above are true, we're left with the fact that someone hacked an account of either myself or the GMs (and given the issue we had earlier in the year, that's possible).

It's a shame that there wasn't already some IP tracking in place, but as I understand it there will be now. It's a game in development and in some small way, I'm proud to have helped push it forward. As I said in the other thread, I am still displeased with the fact that these things weren't already in the game, but at 4 months old, it's a little hard to be critical.

In the end, all the passwords were changed (as they'd been earlier in the year) and now, with IPs logged, if someone tries this again, we should be able to pinpoint it.

Don't all thank me at once fellas
 
RandomBeast
offline
Link
 
Good summation. And knowing the community from which you and your teammates originate, I believe you, fwiw.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
Good summation. And knowing the community from which you and your teammates originate, I believe you, fwiw.


I appriciate that, and I'd like to point out that while I may've had words with a person or two based on a perceived "lack of character", there were a handful of people who's opinions I value coming to our aid, and for that I'm grateful.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
Good summation. And knowing the community from which you and your teammates originate, I believe you, fwiw.


I read most of that thread and I have to agree. I for one am happy that measures are put into place to help such events in the future, but its got to be frustrating that it took a team ending a season to make it happen. You guys certainly seem respectable, though I'm by no means a CPL expert. Hopefully your guys don't get too upset over this and take comfort in the fact that it helped further the game, come back next season and win
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Sigmaforce
Originally posted by RandomBeast

Good summation. And knowing the community from which you and your teammates originate, I believe you, fwiw.


I read most of that thread and I have to agree. I for one am happy that measures are put into place to help such events in the future, but its got to be frustrating that it took a team ending a season to make it happen. You guys certainly seem respectable, though I'm by no means a CPL expert. Hopefully your guys don't get too upset over this and take comfort in the fact that it helped further the game, come back next season and win


It's tough to take, that's for sure, but at some point you have to salvage whatever good you personally think you can take.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

I wonder if your game would sim the same if it was run again or not? It terms of the weird ENG settings...



I'm sure it wouldn't. If Bort ran a test game on his server (which I'm sure he already has) the game would likely sim as intended.

Basically, the end result is that something (or someone) caused the tactics to change to oddly extreme numbers. If Bort says it would be set to a null value and not 1, then I respect that.

I also know, whether or not anyone believes me, that neither my GMs, nor myself obviously, did this. If we agree to assume the above are true, we're left with the fact that someone hacked an account of either myself or the GMs (and given the issue we had earlier in the year, that's possible).

It's a shame that there wasn't already some IP tracking in place, but as I understand it there will be now. It's a game in development and in some small way, I'm proud to have helped push it forward. As I said in the other thread, I am still displeased with the fact that these things weren't already in the game, but at 4 months old, it's a little hard to be critical.

In the end, all the passwords were changed (as they'd been earlier in the year) and now, with IPs logged, if someone tries this again, we should be able to pinpoint it.

Don't all thank me at once fellas



I don't think IP tracking solves anything. So what if Bort knew that the changes didn't come from your computer. Now what? Run it again? If that is the case, then I would go over someone else's house to make my changes for the playoffs, then if we lose, I say "hey Bort - someone hacked into my account and changed the settings". Right?

Unless you have a PM from someone sayng, "I just hacked your account" and they can match IP settings to that person, then I would give up on the hacked account thing.

You seem to be taking the approach that if you didn't intentionally do it that someone else must have.

I am a betting man, and when all is said and done, I would bet almost anything that this was a simple MISTAKE/ACCIDENT. Not your fault.

I'm sure half of the reason for writing to Bort about ths is to re-gain the trust of your team, but it sounds like they still have full trust in you and realize that this was just a random bug caused by something weird that you had no control over. It could have happened to anyone.

I hope you guys continue to the play the game and come back strong next year. You certainly have the inside track for top seed (if you want it).

Let me also be clear that even if this is a little glitch, that Bort is not to be blamed either. He has a wonderful game that works 99.9% of the time. He could test it for 50 years and still run into unexplained things happening. There is no way that he can test for things like people refreshing at the instant that numbers are being pulled by the computer. There is no way that he can test for every little scenario that might have occured.

All he can do is look into it and try his best to make sure it doesn't happen again, and he has already shown the willingness to drop overthing else and look into this.

If the same thing happened to my team.... that happened to Brown Trout, I would feel the same way.

I suggest that Bort allow your 2 teams to play again just for fun and see what would have happened....just so you know your hard work went to something. The hardest part about this happening....is to not know what would have happened....and at least that part can be fixed. (even if it doesn't count for anything).




 
Link
 
Originally posted by
I don't think IP tracking solves anything. So what if Bort knew that the changes didn't come from your computer. Now what? Run it again? If that is the case, then I would go over someone else's house to make my changes for the playoffs, then if we lose, I say "hey Bort - someone hacked into my account and changed the settings". Right?

Unless you have a PM from someone sayng, "I just hacked your account" and they can match IP settings to that person, then I would give up on the hacked account thing.


The problem with the slippery slope argument here is that what happend is pretty easy to spot. QB=99/0 Everyone else=1/0 aren't exactly "messing with tactics", it's pretty obviously someone messing with us. Cases where a seperate IP has messed with things should be pretty easy to spot. Keep in mind also that the gains even if Bort were to grant anyone a reset simply for asking for it, are pretty minimal over time. Teams that try and abuse that would get flaged pretty quick. If you throw in the common sense needed to dictate the possibility of a re-sim in the first place, the only thing this is going to cause is a lot of baseless petitions (deleted PMs imo).

As always, it's a question of motive. Why would anyone sink the team only to argue for a reset of a game they'd have won going away?

Originally posted by
I am a betting man, and when all is said and done, I would bet almost anything that this was a simple MISTAKE/ACCIDENT. Not your fault.


Would be my guess as well, but given the event earlier in the season, I'm not as sure as I was yesterday. Doesn't really matter at this point though.

Originally posted by
If the same thing happened to my team.... that happened to Brown Trout, I would feel the same way.

I suggest that Bort allow your 2 teams to play again just for fun and see what would have happened....just so you know your hard work went to something. The hardest part about this happening....is to not know what would have happened....and at least that part can be fixed. (even if it doesn't count for anything).


No real point here. The questions of character have already been answered, and the game would just take time away from things that are much more important. We beat them in the regular season unboosted when they'd boosted, the outcome would likely be the same now that we've boosted.

The point was to find out what happend, and we couldn't. According to Bort, that's been adressed, so no other team should have a similar situation. Problem solved imo, let's just hope it works.
 
Link
 
END OF THREAD I guess.
Last edited Jul 17, 2008 04:45:22
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
END OF THREAD I guess.


Yep, I should think so.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
IP monitoring could be semi-useful, if say it matches up with another random (or not so random) person who uses GLB. Sure there's plenty of ways around this with proxies and stuff, but it gives another avenue to explore -- questioning the guy who it matches -- if this happens again. Worth doing in my opinion.

In any event. Its certainly refreshing to see a real mature group of players accepting this as an issue, and not spamming the boards about it like so many other playoff teams who don't have legitimate claims. Something certainly happened here, whether it be a bug or some tampering. A lesser team surely would've made a big public fuss about this, but I'm glad to see some people have more class and respect Bort's apology and commitment to making sure GLB is better prepared to handle a situation like this in the future. I think we're done here indeed.
 
Commander
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sigmaforce
IP monitoring could be semi-useful, if say it matches up with another random (or not so random) person who uses GLB. Sure there's plenty of ways around this with proxies and stuff, but it gives another avenue to explore -- questioning the guy who it matches -- if this happens again. Worth doing in my opinion.


yeah, this is why we needed the IP-check. if it matched another user, bingo: problem solved.

what makes me very angry is that we now know that there are people in our league who are willing to go this far, and it just pisses me off.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Commander
what makes me very angry is that we now know that there are people in our league who are willing to go this far, and it just pisses me off.


Not this again. If you have some facts with respect to this I'm sure Bort would be happy to know; otherwise it's rather silly to baselessly accuse your leaguemates after screaming all last night any time somebody implicated your own GMs.

And this thread was going so well too.
 
Commander
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
Originally posted by Commander

what makes me very angry is that we now know that there are people in our league who are willing to go this far, and it just pisses me off.


Not this again. If you have some facts with respect to this I'm sure Bort would be happy to know; otherwise it's rather silly to baselessly accuse your leaguemates after screaming all last night any time somebody implicated your own GMs.

And this thread was going so well too.


please don't start this again. the matter is being taken care of privately. if you want to play your game of "prove it" then take it somewhere else.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Ugh, you so asked for it by calling out your league like that.

Here's a thought for you: stop accusing people of things without having any proof whatsoever to back up your claim, and maybe, juuuust maybe, people will stop calling you on your unfounded accusations.

Another, slightly more complex thought: Remember how angry you get when somebody says one of your GMs is a lying scumbag who fucked you all over? Well, think of that feeling every time you decide to point the "lying scumbag who fucked you all over" finger at anybody else, and quit doing it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.