User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #1 > ~~~~COMPLETE ALL-LEAGUE BALLOT~~~
Page:
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BigMike497
Mike Acton is my Player.
He is leading the league in passing yards.
Yet he is not on the ballot...


But I understand. Just because I am leading the league in passing yards doesn't make me the best QB in the league. You have to look at the entire stat. Interceptions, Completion Percentage, QB Rating, etc... To be the best QB in the league, you have to have the entire package, just not one thing. Could I have been on the ballot for shit and giggles, sure why not. But there is NO WAY I deserve to win the Best QB. For me it was between Marvin Gardens and Steve Young.. Not going to give my pick away, but I knew before looking at the ballot that I was not going to pick myself as the best QB. Can not say the same about the TE and CB though.


I very much appreciate your candor and understanding. And I agree... I cannot say
the same thing about your CB or TE. They absolutely DO belong on the list. And I
hope you understand I wouldn't have called the issue out if I hadn't been. Your guys
made great strides over this past season.

And allow me to clarify something else... The players are NOT listed in the order I
think they belong. The list is sorted alphabetically. For those of you that aren't
familiar with that term, that means I listed the guys in alphabetical order based on
their first names. So a guy named "AL" would be listed before a guy named "BEN,"
because "A" comes before "B" in the English alphabet.
Last edited Jul 16, 2008 09:09:15
 
conanfan
offline
Link
 
before I forget:

Just picking my votes took an hour or two, you put in a lot of hours choosing these canidates--Thanks a bunch for taking the time to do this!
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by conanfan
before I forget:

Just picking my votes took an hour or two, you put in a lot of hours choosing these candidates--Thanks a bunch for taking the time to do this!


Guys that are appreciative make it worth while. It takes a long time because I want it to be good.
 
Link
 
Yeah this definitely takes a long time to do. Thanks man. Many appreciate the effort!
Last edited Jul 16, 2008 16:10:26
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Jmac,

I was looking at your criteria for the TEs. Well, if you are using that criteria, why didn't you have our best WR on the team get on the list. He is up there for TDs as well: Aftu Lakutan

YOu had a guy who didn't even have 1000 yards on that list.
Catch Max 117 receptions 982yds 8.4 yds/rec 4 TDs http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=90056&playoffs=0
-------------------vs-----------------------------------
Aftu lakutan 88 receptions 1059 yds 12yd avg 13 TDs http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=73535&playoffs=0

There is even a guy who only had one TD on that list. But i don't want to rain on their parade, because they come from teams that either weren't in the playoffs, or just made the playoffs.

I truly think that you missed Aftu in your rankings because you were using RECEPTIONS to sort the stats. No biggie, I just think you need some help next year with your scouting.

--Dan
Last edited Jul 16, 2008 16:12:58
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
Jmac,

I was looking at your criteria for the TEs. Well, if you are using that criteria, why didn't you have our best WR on the team get on the list. He is up there for TDs as well: Aftu Lakutan

YOu had a guy who didn't even have 1000 yards on that list.
Catch Max 117 receptions 982yds 8.4 yds/rec 4 TDs http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=90056&playoffs=0
-------------------vs-----------------------------------
Aftu lakutan 88 receptions 1059 yds 12yd avg 13 TDs http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=73535&playoffs=0

There is even a guy who only had one TD on that list. But i don't want to rain on their parade, because they come from teams that either weren't in the playoffs, or just made the playoffs.

I truly think that you missed Aftu in your rankings because you were using RECEPTIONS to sort the stats. No biggie, I just think you need some help next year with your scouting.

--Dan


Doesn't matter.... because we all know that Tyrone Dynamite is the best WR ever to exist in this game. Tell me one other conference to where he lead the league in Receptions, Yards, TD's, and Drops... no one can touch him!
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
yeah, but there will be 4 total WRs chosen for 1st and second team. And no one can touch him in drops. And how does a WR with only 1 TD get on the list?
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jmac0585
Originally posted by BigMike497

Mike Acton is my Player.
He is leading the league in passing yards.
Yet he is not on the ballot...


But I understand. Just because I am leading the league in passing yards doesn't make me the best QB in the league. You have to look at the entire stat. Interceptions, Completion Percentage, QB Rating, etc... To be the best QB in the league, you have to have the entire package, just not one thing. Could I have been on the ballot for shit and giggles, sure why not. But there is NO WAY I deserve to win the Best QB. For me it was between Marvin Gardens and Steve Young.. Not going to give my pick away, but I knew before looking at the ballot that I was not going to pick myself as the best QB. Can not say the same about the TE and CB though.


I very much appreciate your candor and understanding. And I agree... I cannot say
the same thing about your CB or TE. They absolutely DO belong on the list. And I
hope you understand I wouldn't have called the issue out if I hadn't been. Your guys
made great strides over this past season.

And allow me to clarify something else... The players are NOT listed in the order I
think they belong. The list is sorted alphabetically. For those of you that aren't
familiar with that term, that means I listed the guys in alphabetical order based on
their first names. So a guy named "AL" would be listed before a guy named "BEN,"
because "A" comes before "B" in the English alphabet.



Again, your criteria is flawed. You have a WR on the list with only one TD, but he has over 1000 yards receiving. By that criteria, Mike Acton should be on the QB list. I just see some inconsistency with your reasoning thats all.

 
HuskerAztec
offline
Link
 
It really pisses you off that a few of your guys were left off the list. Man let it go or make you own list.

Spend the rest of the night coming up with your own list and shut the fuck up about Jmac's list.

Last edited Jul 16, 2008 17:39:18
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
I was just talking about his criteria being flawed. He said one thing in reguards to TEs, and QBs (all around, not just yards), but he did not go by that when WRs came into the picture. It seems like he just sorted for receptions then took the top guys.

And I put links to players which took me almost 2 hours...and that was just zeta conference. So i did help him out a bit. Maybe you can stop cursing and contribute yourself Husker. There, what are you gonna do now, call me more names or are YOU gonna step up and add links for YOUR conference's players.

And you really can't make me "shut the fuck up." Honestly, do you think that anythiny you say will make me afraid. Really, this is a forum.

--Dan
 
tlarkin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jmac0585

Seriously? "Far outstrips" Is a pushing it. He had what 15 more catches? You were CLOSE in almost every other category?
All three of my scouts (Me, Myself and I) looked at all the numbers for EVERY TE. I felt his TE warranted the spot more than yours. I am also looking forward to your incredibly unbiased and remarkable accurate nominee list. Make sure that your tight end doesn't get listed against:
TE - Paraguay West Torrents - Ben Acton
TE - Valencia Crocodiles - Justin Pierce
TE - Cochabamba Samurai - Man Dude
Because your TE might be allowed to hold anyone of these guys' playbook during meetings... if he's lucky.
I made more than one choice available in every position, at least four choices for single positions. There are some positions where this was completely unnecessary, but for the sake of fairness, I added a few names that probably won't get votes.
Call Doc Brown, fire up the flux capacitor in the DeLorean and go back two weeks, and have your TE catch about 7 more balls. Then you can be on the list. And get two votes from teammates, as one of the other three I listed get 99% of the rest.



My post was mostly tongue in cheek. Really if you stack my TE up against that guy I compared him to, I think I deserved to be on the list more than he did. You didn't, and that's your call. Its your list, you can do whatever you want with it.

As I said in my post, the rest of the guys I looked at (the 3 Dan linked to) all had far better seasons than I did. But that's not the point. I didn't think I deserved to win it, just that I should have been on that list rather than that "J Dub" character. I mean, come on, he doesn't even have a real name.

Mac Nessa
Rec___Yards___Y/G___Y/Rec____TotYAC___AvgYAC__TD____Drops__Pancakes
47 ___477.5___29.8___10.2_____169.5______3.6_____2______3_____19
J Dub
63____497_____31.1___7.9______122______1.9_____2______5_____14

And just for my own giggles, I went and added up our targets per game too.

Mac Nessa: 2 5 11 18 27 32 34 39 45 52 52 57 63 68 76 81
J Dub____:5 11 16 27 32 37 39 48 57 61 66 72 79 86 90 94

So Mac Nessa Catch % is 58% and J Dub's is 67%. So he wins that one along with receptions. That stat would be a nice one to have in general for receivers actually.



Last edited Jul 16, 2008 18:23:50
 
orcinus
offline
Link
 
Girls, girls ... settle down.

You're BOTH pretty.
 
tlarkin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by orcinus
Girls, girls ... settle down.

You're BOTH pretty.


Phew. That's all I wanted really. Thanks orcinus.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
Jmac,

I was looking at your criteria for the TEs. Well, if you are using that criteria, why didn't you have our best WR on the team get on the list. He is up there for TDs as well: Aftu Lakutan

YOu had a guy who didn't even have 1000 yards on that list.
Catch Max 117 receptions 982yds 8.4 yds/rec 4 TDs http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=90056&playoffs=0
-------------------vs-----------------------------------
Aftu lakutan 88 receptions 1059 yds 12yd avg 13 TDs http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=73535&playoffs=0

There is even a guy who only had one TD on that list. But i don't want to rain on their parade, because they come from teams that either weren't in the playoffs, or just made the playoffs.

I truly think that you missed Aftu in your rankings because you were using RECEPTIONS to sort the stats. No biggie, I just think you need some help next year with your scouting.

--Dan


No, I didn't just use receptions. I didn't sort by one stat and list the receivers, the QBs, the HBs... I left a HB off that had over 1,000 yards rushing and had more yards per carry than almost anyone else with a significant number of carries and had quite a few TDs. But, I didn't want to hear about it from a guy that had 300 more yards.
I do see the point with TDs, but... 29 rec >> 77 yards.

PS. I am not going to justify anymore omissions or commissions. If you aren't happy
with the candidates, be a real American and don't vote! When the issue rolls around
next year, I am coming back to this thread and a few individuals will be pressed
into service. They can spend their weekend sifting through names that have no
business being on any list that doesn't have "CUT" at the top, only to be griped at
for their hard work.
Originally posted by orcinus
Girls, girls ... settle down.

You're BOTH pretty.


I know that already, my mommy tells me every day.
Last edited Jul 16, 2008 19:14:25
 
HuskerAztec
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
I was just talking about his criteria being flawed. He said one thing in reguards to TEs, and QBs (all around, not just yards), but he did not go by that when WRs came into the picture. It seems like he just sorted for receptions then took the top guys.

And I put links to players which took me almost 2 hours...and that was just zeta conference. So i did help him out a bit. Maybe you can stop cursing and contribute yourself Husker. There, what are you gonna do now, call me more names or are YOU gonna step up and add links for YOUR conference's players.

And you really can't make me "shut the fuck up." Honestly, do you think that anythiny you say will make me afraid. Really, this is a forum.

--Dan


Dude your such a tool.

I think he did a fine JOB so why do I need to second guess him. Your right I can't make you shut the fuck up, and to be honest I don't care to and never hinted that I was going to try.

Fuck fuck fuck.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.