User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
stamango
offline
Link
 
9 Utah Matadors CPU 7-8-0 L3
10 Portland Crushers CPU 7-8-0 W2
11 Phoenix Owls CPU 7-8-0 W2
12 Reno Angels CPU 7-8-0 L5

I failed to see Reno, due to slow load speeds with this site and my need to barbecue for my family.

Utah has the most points for here, that's why they are first.

Hmmm.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 16:56:53
 
madmal
Prez SWO
offline
Link
 
Stamango,

Thanks alot for your help and time.

Glad to see another COWBOY fan!
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 16:58:39
 
stamango
offline
Link
 
Bort and Co. are sound, we are just getting used to the rules here, no prob.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 17:19:19
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stamango
Bort and Co. are sound, we are just getting used to the rules here, no prob.


I don't see what your problem is here. It goes by record vs. all the teams tied with the same record, and only in the case of further ties does it go to most points scored.

Other than Point Differential, which would probably be a better tiebreaker than Points For, what would you suggest the tiebreaker to be after H2H records?
 
stamango
offline
Link
 
Well, since you asked, I will tell you.

I propose Divisions within the Conferences. That way you have a Division champ, and those teams within the Division play each other twice. Alot of US people cannot get with the system you are using now. It is not logical to us, though we are learning it.

So you have less Tie break opportunities, the 3,4,5 way tie ups we are having now.

It is obviously modeled after the NFL, and their would still be problems. But you would not have ANY H2H problems, like you do now. In the NFL, you know who is moving on, or who is ahead.

Also, you would be able to give out Division Championship Trophy's. That would be a big bonus for many GLB players.

Just my 2
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stamango
Well, since you asked, I will tell you.

I propose Divisions within the Conferences. That way you have a Division champ, and those teams within the Division play each other twice. Alot of US people cannot get with the system you are using now. It is not logical to us, though we are learning it.

So you have less Tie break opportunities, the 3,4,5 way tie ups we are having now.

It is obviously modeled after the NFL, and their would still be problems. But you would not have ANY H2H problems, like you do now. In the NFL, you know who is moving on, or who is ahead.

Also, you would be able to give out Division Championship Trophy's. That would be a big bonus for many GLB players.

Just my 2


Yeah, I've seen the division suggestions before, and I don't mind that idea at all. You'll still have tiebreakers for the wildcards though, since 8 teams make it from each conference. So you'd still potentially have tiebreakers, but probably not as many.

I really don't see why the current steup is "hard to understand". It still goes by H2H record among the teams that are tied. That is not hard to figure out. And in case of secondary ties, you go to points for, then if still tied, points against.

But if it wasn't a ton of work, I like the division style -- i have a feeling it isn't at the top of the priority list though, if even on it.
 
stamango
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by stamango

Well, since you asked, I will tell you.

I propose Divisions within the Conferences. That way you have a Division champ, and those teams within the Division play each other twice. Alot of US people cannot get with the system you are using now. It is not logical to us, though we are learning it.

So you have less Tie break opportunities, the 3,4,5 way tie ups we are having now.

It is obviously modeled after the NFL, and their would still be problems. But you would not have ANY H2H problems, like you do now. In the NFL, you know who is moving on, or who is ahead.

Also, you would be able to give out Division Championship Trophy's. That would be a big bonus for many GLB players.

Just my 2


Yeah, I've seen the division suggestions before, and I don't mind that idea at all. You'll still have tiebreakers for the wildcards though, since 8 teams make it from each conference. So you'd still potentially have tiebreakers, but probably not as many.

I really don't see why the current steup is "hard to understand". It still goes by H2H record among the teams that are tied. That is not hard to figure out. And in case of secondary ties, you go to points for, then if still tied, points against.

But if it wasn't a ton of work, I like the division style -- i have a feeling it isn't at the top of the priority list though, if even on it.


I fully understand all that. I apologize for taking up so much time on this forum today.
 
crag79
offline
Link
 
It can't be head to head when its a 2 way tie. Currently I play for Napanee in the Canada A#1 (http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=107&conference_id=214) league and we have a record of 3-4 and are in 9th place. The team ahead of us Niagra is 3-4 also but we beat them during the season (http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=64647).

 
big_n_rich
offline
Link
 
I'm in the same situation in Africa AA1. My understanding is most points gets the top seed and once the 3 way is broken the head to head kicks back in for the other two teams in the tie.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crag79
It can't be head to head when its a 2 way tie. Currently I play for Napanee in the Canada A#1 (http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=107&conference_id=214) league and we have a record of 3-4 and are in 9th place. The team ahead of us Niagra is 3-4 also but we beat them during the season (http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=64647).



I guess I don't understand how to explain it any more clearly. There are 4 teams tied at 3-4 in your league. That means you have to take into account the combined H2H for each team vs. the same 3 opponents that are tied at 3-4.

Niagara Hitmen (1-1, haven't played NS yet)
Napanee Coronas (1-0, haven't played SF or NS yet)
San Francisco Onslaught (0-1, haven't played NS or Napanee yet)
Nova Scotia Clansmen (0-0, haven't played any of the three yet)

Now, given a short season you won't see all these games played, so the SIM will probably be messed up, but in a full season league, everyone will have played everyone and you can properly breakdown each tiebreaker, starting with H2H (if 2 teams, 1 wins, 1 loses; if 3+ teams, you have to take into account the records among common opponents with same record) and only going to points scored if there are ties remaining.

In your case, because everyone won't have common opponents, maybe it goes by points scored, I'm not sure. Good question for the devs, as I don't have the answer how the short season leagues work.

But, for all regular season leagues, tiebreakers...

1. H2H
2. Points scored
3. Points against
 
madmal
Prez SWO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stamango
Well, since you asked, I will tell you.

I propose Divisions within the Conferences. That way you have a Division champ, and those teams within the Division play each other twice. Alot of US people cannot get with the system you are using now. It is not logical to us, though we are learning it.

So you have less Tie break opportunities, the 3,4,5 way tie ups we are having now.

It is obviously modeled after the NFL, and their would still be problems. But you would not have ANY H2H problems, like you do now. In the NFL, you know who is moving on, or who is ahead.

Also, you would be able to give out Division Championship Trophy's. That would be a big bonus for many GLB players.

Just my 2


'GREAT' suggestion. This would make much more sense.
 
tom11784
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stamango
I propose Divisions within the Conferences. That way you have a Division champ, and those teams within the Division play each other twice. Alot of US people cannot get with the system you are using now. It is not logical to us, though we are learning it.


The only thing about that is since these ties are more usually occurring between the 5th and 16th slots it would still be an issue when it came to playoff seeding if they split each conference into 2 (or even 4 in some cases) divisions for wild cards.

I agree it's a good idea, but not because of it helping with tie-breakers.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.