User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
This is the one thing I dont get. Guy said last ranks when Rio and Ridgerunners play whoever wins gets number 1 spot implying right there they both should of been in front of the Monkeys witch implies his rankings arent all the way true. Then he goes and drops Rio all the way down to 5th when we only beat them by 3. They should atleast be 2 or 3 in the rankings.
 
brookjacoby5
offline
Link
 
I did watch the game "rotharek", but like "aharden2" said, there are so many good teams at the top that you can't easily separate them. I gave it my best shot though. I know there are several teams that could argue they are better than a team ahead of them. Last season when another person did the team rankings, I would just post it to my team forum and use it as motivation to encourage them to prove the rankings wrong. Some good old fashioned bulletin board material. I encourage you to do the same for your team if you don't like where you are placed. I can almost guarantee that there is only one team in the whole league right now that is happy with their ranking..... San Juan Ridgerunners. But really the only ranking that matters is the one that ends with the championship trophy.
 
Link
 
I think the Manus Thunder should be number one in these rankings! These rankings suck!
 
Ra4xGambit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brookjacoby5
I did watch the game "rotharek", but like "aharden2" said, there are so many good teams at the top that you can't easily separate them. I gave it my best shot though. I know there are several teams that could argue they are better than a team ahead of them. Last season when another person did the team rankings, I would just post it to my team forum and use it as motivation to encourage them to prove the rankings wrong. Some good old fashioned bulletin board material. I encourage you to do the same for your team if you don't like where you are placed. I can almost guarantee that there is only one team in the whole league right now that is happy with their ranking..... San Juan Ridgerunners. But really the only ranking that matters is the one that ends with the championship trophy.


I am happy with these rankings.
 
Natidawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rabideasterbunny
I think the Manus Thunder should be number one in these rankings! These rankings suck!


That souds like it's in the ballpark!
 
rotharek
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brookjacoby5
I did watch the game "rotharek", but like "aharden2" said, there are so many good teams at the top that you can't easily separate them. I gave it my best shot though. I know there are several teams that could argue they are better than a team ahead of them. Last season when another person did the team rankings, I would just post it to my team forum and use it as motivation to encourage them to prove the rankings wrong. Some good old fashioned bulletin board material. I encourage you to do the same for your team if you don't like where you are placed. I can almost guarantee that there is only one team in the whole league right now that is happy with their ranking..... San Juan Ridgerunners. But really the only ranking that matters is the one that ends with the championship trophy.


Hey bro, it's chill so don't worry about it. I was hoping you'd give some sort of opinion on the outcome of the close game that made you drop our position such a large amount while keeping Ridgerunners at the top. However, I realize you aren't going to give a proper reason and are just going to continue to use the cop out of "I'm biased and there are a ton of good teams!"

I mean, that's fine and I don't give much thought to these rankings besides trying to comprehend the decision process. I'm just a believer that if you're going to publicly post your rankings in a thread you should probably try to be as unbiased as possible and give good explanations to your rankings so you don't look dumb.
 
brookjacoby5
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rotharek
Originally posted by brookjacoby5

I did watch the game "rotharek", but like "aharden2" said, there are so many good teams at the top that you can't easily separate them. I gave it my best shot though. I know there are several teams that could argue they are better than a team ahead of them. Last season when another person did the team rankings, I would just post it to my team forum and use it as motivation to encourage them to prove the rankings wrong. Some good old fashioned bulletin board material. I encourage you to do the same for your team if you don't like where you are placed. I can almost guarantee that there is only one team in the whole league right now that is happy with their ranking..... San Juan Ridgerunners. But really the only ranking that matters is the one that ends with the championship trophy.


Hey bro, it's chill so don't worry about it. I was hoping you'd give some sort of opinion on the outcome of the close game that made you drop our position such a large amount while keeping Ridgerunners at the top. However, I realize you aren't going to give a proper reason and are just going to continue to use the cop out of "I'm biased and there are a ton of good teams!"

I mean, that's fine and I don't give much thought to these rankings besides trying to comprehend the decision process. I'm just a believer that if you're going to publicly post your rankings in a thread you should probably try to be as unbiased as possible and give good explanations to your rankings so you don't look dumb.


So what would your rankings be? I challenge you to give an unbiased ranking, that is under scrutiny by the league. I knew I wouldn't make any friends by doing these rankings, but I think the forum for our league just wouldn't be the same without someone doing the ranking. I know some people appreciate that I at least start the discussion with my opinion, perhaps it would be better if I gave a sentence about each team when I rank them, but I don't have that extra time to do after each game. I check out the games, study some film, stats, etc. and adjust my rankings. I do have my own team to game plan, recruit for, etc. You don't have to worry about me doing the ranking next season, it's not worth it anymore, so you only have 1 more ranking full of errors to deal with.
 
rotharek
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brookjacoby5
Originally posted by rotharek

Originally posted by brookjacoby5


I did watch the game "rotharek", but like "aharden2" said, there are so many good teams at the top that you can't easily separate them. I gave it my best shot though. I know there are several teams that could argue they are better than a team ahead of them. Last season when another person did the team rankings, I would just post it to my team forum and use it as motivation to encourage them to prove the rankings wrong. Some good old fashioned bulletin board material. I encourage you to do the same for your team if you don't like where you are placed. I can almost guarantee that there is only one team in the whole league right now that is happy with their ranking..... San Juan Ridgerunners. But really the only ranking that matters is the one that ends with the championship trophy.


Hey bro, it's chill so don't worry about it. I was hoping you'd give some sort of opinion on the outcome of the close game that made you drop our position such a large amount while keeping Ridgerunners at the top. However, I realize you aren't going to give a proper reason and are just going to continue to use the cop out of "I'm biased and there are a ton of good teams!"

I mean, that's fine and I don't give much thought to these rankings besides trying to comprehend the decision process. I'm just a believer that if you're going to publicly post your rankings in a thread you should probably try to be as unbiased as possible and give good explanations to your rankings so you don't look dumb.


So what would your rankings be? I challenge you to give an unbiased ranking, that is under scrutiny by the league. I knew I wouldn't make any friends by doing these rankings, but I think the forum for our league just wouldn't be the same without someone doing the ranking. I know some people appreciate that I at least start the discussion with my opinion, perhaps it would be better if I gave a sentence about each team when I rank them, but I don't have that extra time to do after each game. I check out the games, study some film, stats, etc. and adjust my rankings. I do have my own team to game plan, recruit for, etc. You don't have to worry about me doing the ranking next season, it's not worth it anymore, so you only have 1 more ranking full of errors to deal with.


Dude you openly said you rank with a bias and it's pretty much been agreed on by most people that you do. You're going to receive some criticism for that but I assumed you realized that when you started this and admitted to your bias. If you aren't able to take the criticism then perhaps it would be best that you stopped posting rankings for your sake.

I'm not sure how I would do the rankings but I know that certain teams who proved to be just about evenly matched would be just about together in position and not separated by 5 ranks.

Honestly, your rankings haven't been that bad. They've been close to where I or a lot of other people would put them besides maybe 1 or 2 switches. I was kind of just hoping to get your input on the Ridgerunner/Rio game since it caused you to separate us by so much.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 20:37:27
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
lol
 
aharden2
offline
Link
 
All rankings are either biased or are done without proper knowledge of the subject which they are ranking. To put things in perspective, you are upset/demanding a response from a person who is (a) not being paid, (b) doing this for fun, (c) providing a great forum every two days for discussion, and (d) taking his time to make these rankings and post them here. It's an unofficial ranking on an internet post board. Are we really going to call him out for bias when the teams he's placing up top are not even his team?? You don't have to like them or even respect them, but you also don't have to call the guy out for just trying to create a good community inside our league. I think everyone would welcome some power rankings from the Alpha Conference in the future. There's no reason some of you Alpha guys can't spend some time and create your own rankings every other day. You can even throw in some extra Alpha bias to make up for the sins Brooks has so heartlessly committed against your conference.
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=510433

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=510712

These are unbiased, and I would post them as they are if my team was ranked first or 14th. But they're not power rankings. They're PREDICTIONS.
I'm just sayin'.

I'm ALSO just saying, publicly, AGAIN, that brookjacoby's rankings are valid. Specifically because he acknowledges that they are 1)an opinion and 2)biased. The purpose of these sorts of rankings is to generate debate and pride in one's team/conference. brookjacoby has done that, and then some.
It's really not cool, in my opinion, to attack someone because they actually took the initiative to do something like this. Get over it.
Also, brookjacoby, if you're going to let someone else's OPINION sway you into no longer doing this... man, that just reminds me of the little kid taking his toys and going home because the bully yelled at him. It's cool that you did this and all, but if you're going to post these kinds of controversial opinions then you should really stick around and stand up for them. I like that you've done it this far, and I would really like it if you stuck around and did it again next season.

All that having been said, much respect to both of you for being an active part of this league's forums.
 
rotharek
offline
Link
 
I don't think I'm being a jerk by just asking for his opinion on the game. I didn't think it'd be that big a deal but it ended up escalating to an argument that kind of went nowhere. Much like he has a right to publicly post his opinion on the rankings (biased or unbiased), I think I have a right to have a discussion about his choices for the rankings. I thought that was kind of the whole point of these ranking threads.
 
tyrant91101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bacchuspoet
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=510433

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=510712

These are unbiased, and I would post them as they are if my team was ranked first or 14th. But they're not power rankings. They're PREDICTIONS.
I'm just sayin'.

I'm ALSO just saying, publicly, AGAIN, that brookjacoby's rankings are valid. Specifically because he acknowledges that they are 1)an opinion and 2)biased. The purpose of these sorts of rankings is to generate debate and pride in one's team/conference. brookjacoby has done that, and then some.
It's really not cool, in my opinion, to attack someone because they actually took the initiative to do something like this. Get over it.
Also, brookjacoby, if you're going to let someone else's OPINION sway you into no longer doing this... man, that just reminds me of the little kid taking his toys and going home because the bully yelled at him. It's cool that you did this and all, but if you're going to post these kinds of controversial opinions then you should really stick around and stand up for them. I like that you've done it this far, and I would really like it if you stuck around and did it again next season.

All that having been said, much respect to both of you for being an active part of this league's forums.


Actually they are biased because the person who made it took specific importances to different things. Maybe more importance was put to points scored versus the seperate comparisons of rushing defense versus rushing game and same thing for passing and etc.

Besides, that is just a calculation and not a "power ranking" per say. All it does is follow a pattern while power rankings take into effect consistency, skill and talent and etc.
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
I say they are unbiased because, in the context of this thread so far, biased has been defined as giving unfair consideration to one conference over another. The predictions, if they're biased, certainly aren't biased towards one team or one conference over another.

But you're right, they are just a calculation.
 
Korak
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brookjacoby5
Originally posted by rotharek

Originally posted by brookjacoby5


I did watch the game "rotharek", but like "aharden2" said, there are so many good teams at the top that you can't easily separate them. I gave it my best shot though. I know there are several teams that could argue they are better than a team ahead of them. Last season when another person did the team rankings, I would just post it to my team forum and use it as motivation to encourage them to prove the rankings wrong. Some good old fashioned bulletin board material. I encourage you to do the same for your team if you don't like where you are placed. I can almost guarantee that there is only one team in the whole league right now that is happy with their ranking..... San Juan Ridgerunners. But really the only ranking that matters is the one that ends with the championship trophy.


Hey bro, it's chill so don't worry about it. I was hoping you'd give some sort of opinion on the outcome of the close game that made you drop our position such a large amount while keeping Ridgerunners at the top. However, I realize you aren't going to give a proper reason and are just going to continue to use the cop out of "I'm biased and there are a ton of good teams!"

I mean, that's fine and I don't give much thought to these rankings besides trying to comprehend the decision process. I'm just a believer that if you're going to publicly post your rankings in a thread you should probably try to be as unbiased as possible and give good explanations to your rankings so you don't look dumb.


So what would your rankings be? I challenge you to give an unbiased ranking, that is under scrutiny by the league. I knew I wouldn't make any friends by doing these rankings, but I think the forum for our league just wouldn't be the same without someone doing the ranking. I know some people appreciate that I at least start the discussion with my opinion, perhaps it would be better if I gave a sentence about each team when I rank them, but I don't have that extra time to do after each game. I check out the games, study some film, stats, etc. and adjust my rankings. I do have my own team to game plan, recruit for, etc. You don't have to worry about me doing the ranking next season, it's not worth it anymore, so you only have 1 more ranking full of errors to deal with.


Hey, I fully support anyone who stands up and gives the opinion on the rankings. I enjoy seeing what others think and the discourse that come from these rankings. I would hate to see someone not do a ranking because of a difference in opinion. I will go on record a say we should be ranked behind Belo according to my records due to our loss to them last season and the fact they have everyone returning. I would also argue that since we are the only undefeated team we deserve the #1 spot. So the question becomes what body of work do I use to rank my team Last year or this season?

My opinion is that looking at the teams here for the last 3 seasons and the teams added my overall rankings would be

1.) Belo Horizonte Miners
2.) San Juan Ridgerunners
3.) Krazy Monkeys
4.) Rio revolution
5.) Brazil Cubs
6.) Cuiabá Arsenal
7.) Cleveland DawgPound
8.) Manus Thunder
9.) Peru Deacons
10.)San Cristobal 49'ers

This is regardless of records and based on each teams quality of work over a long period of time.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.