User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AAA Leagues > South America AAA #2 > South America AAA #2 MVP voting
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kxrnidge
Man, I'd vote for my whole O-Line if possible


BTW Blitter will be happy to here Ben and Jackie made the MVP voting together! Also congrats Carlos!
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 03:26:10
 
Satchmo-n-Dizzy
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Satchmo-n-Dizzy

While I appreciate what Young did on the season, I strongly disagree with his selection as League MVP.

Orlando Pocketz gained 11 fewer yards on 3 fewer carries per game. Had a better YPC average, fewer fumbles, and ZERO fumbles lost on the season. And he split time evenly (21.1 cpg to 20.9 cpg) with the #4 rusher in the league as well.

Add to that the fact that we held Young to 10 yards on 8 carries, and he was fed the ball over and over in blowout wins while Pocketz never registered more than 30 carries in a game, then you'll begin to see why he led the league-- and it had very little to do with VALUE.

The fact is there are too many deserving RBs in Alpha to even consider one that much superior to the rest. I guess you could say the same about the top QBs in Zeta, but my MVP vote would have been split between Baby and Cannon.

I also find it a little humorous that while Santa Cruz is the #1 Rushing team and the #1 Blocking team in the league, not one member of the O-line received a mention. Yes, I am aware that Santa Barbara finished #1 in both categories after posting 790 rushing yards and 369 pancakes against the worst team in South America, but they were trailing the Cheetahs in both stats after both teams had played the same schedule.


Quit bitching Satchmo...it's just a game!


People talk smack and garbage constantly on these boards. I actually present a reasoned argument, and I'm bitching? Get over yourself.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Satchmo-n-Dizzy
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Satchmo-n-Dizzy


While I appreciate what Young did on the season, I strongly disagree with his selection as League MVP.

Orlando Pocketz gained 11 fewer yards on 3 fewer carries per game. Had a better YPC average, fewer fumbles, and ZERO fumbles lost on the season. And he split time evenly (21.1 cpg to 20.9 cpg) with the #4 rusher in the league as well.

Add to that the fact that we held Young to 10 yards on 8 carries, and he was fed the ball over and over in blowout wins while Pocketz never registered more than 30 carries in a game, then you'll begin to see why he led the league-- and it had very little to do with VALUE.

The fact is there are too many deserving RBs in Alpha to even consider one that much superior to the rest. I guess you could say the same about the top QBs in Zeta, but my MVP vote would have been split between Baby and Cannon.

I also find it a little humorous that while Santa Cruz is the #1 Rushing team and the #1 Blocking team in the league, not one member of the O-line received a mention. Yes, I am aware that Santa Barbara finished #1 in both categories after posting 790 rushing yards and 369 pancakes against the worst team in South America, but they were trailing the Cheetahs in both stats after both teams had played the same schedule.


Quit bitching Satchmo...it's just a game!


People talk smack and garbage constantly on these boards. I actually present a reasoned argument, and I'm bitching? Get over yourself.


It's over a MVP award that doesn't even show up in this game...your player lost DEAL WITH IT.
 
Satchmo-n-Dizzy
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32

It's over a MVP award that doesn't even show up in this game...your player lost DEAL WITH IT.


If you could read, you would know that I didn't suggest my player should have won. I said it should have gone to a QB. If you are asking me which RB I would take, Pocketz or Young, it ain't even close. But again, that was not the point of my post.

You puffed up Young's numbers against soft competition and you know it. Baby and Cannon did it game in and game out. And I am fairly confident no one could stuff them the way we did your guy.

The fact is, Alpha probably has 6-8 RBs that are better than the best in Zeta. And Young is not head and shoulders better than any of them.
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Satchmo-n-Dizzy
While I appreciate what Young did on the season, I strongly disagree with his selection as League MVP.

Orlando Pocketz gained 11 fewer yards on 3 fewer carries per game. Had a better YPC average, fewer fumbles, and ZERO fumbles lost on the season. And he split time evenly (21.1 cpg to 20.9 cpg) with the #4 rusher in the league as well.

Add to that the fact that we held Young to 10 yards on 8 carries, and he was fed the ball over and over in blowout wins while Pocketz never registered more than 30 carries in a game, then you'll begin to see why he led the league-- and it had very little to do with VALUE.

The fact is there are too many deserving RBs in Alpha to even consider one that much superior to the rest. I guess you could say the same about the top QBs in Zeta, but my MVP vote would have been split between Baby and Cannon.

I also find it a little humorous that while Santa Cruz is the #1 Rushing team and the #1 Blocking team in the league, not one member of the O-line received a mention. Yes, I am aware that Santa Barbara finished #1 in both categories after posting 790 rushing yards and 369 pancakes against the worst team in South America, but they were trailing the Cheetahs in both stats after both teams had played the same schedule.


Sorry you don't like my picks. No one was active enough to make a pick for MVP was Reven. I took into account the YPC, fumbles, number of carries, yards, TD's, and what that player meant to the team. I still think Young should be the MVP this season. Orlando Pocketz might have gotten it if he didn't split time. I dont think MJD or Fred Taylor will be winning any MVP awards splitting time, bt I still think they are great RB's. It was tough picking an all out MVP over bcause Baby did almost pass for 5000 yards, but I still think 2000+ yards and 32 TD's is the most impressive player this season. I'm not mad you dont like my pick, it actually makes me happy someone took time to look, get pissed, and post something
 
Satchmo-n-Dizzy
Moderator
offline
Link
 
I'm not pissed at your pick. I simply disagree with it. And for the umpteenth time, I'm not suggesting Pocketz should have been the MVP.

I checked in after the games to register my vote, as I thought we were directed to do, and the winners were already posted. For that reason, I voiced my opinion.

And, for the record, McDougle would not have been my choice for ST MVP. I am very happy with his season, but there are a couple of returnmen in this league that are far more impressive to me.
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Satchmo-n-Dizzy
I'm not pissed at your pick. I simply disagree with it. And for the umpteenth time, I'm not suggesting Pocketz should have been the MVP.

I checked in after the games to register my vote, as I thought we were directed to do, and the winners were already posted. For that reason, I voiced my opinion.

And, for the record, McDougle would not have been my choice for ST MVP. I am very happy with his season, but there are a couple of returnmen in this league that are far more impressive to me.


But kickers put up way more points than a KR/PR. Yea the KR/PR gets you good field position, but I think its better for your team if your team gets inside the 40 yard line 50 times, and your kicker can make it 48 of those times, he is an MVP in my mind.
 
Satchmo-n-Dizzy
Moderator
offline
Link
 
I think if you had to gameplan against the likes of Skeeter Skates and William Michaels, you might view it differently. I've never needed to use up my starters to stop a FG.
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Satchmo-n-Dizzy
I think if you had to gameplan against the likes of Skeeter Skates and William Michaels, you might view it differently. I've never needed to use up my starters to stop a FG.


Skeeter Skates is a great return man, but he didn't have any KR TD's this season.
 
Satchmo-n-Dizzy
Moderator
offline
Link
 
He didn't have one last year either... until the playoffs.

He's still the fastest player I've ever scouted, and the best returnman in all of GLB.
 
kxrnidge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Satchmo-n-Dizzy
While I appreciate what Young did on the season, I strongly disagree with his selection as League MVP.

Orlando Pocketz gained 11 fewer yards on 3 fewer carries per game. Had a better YPC average, fewer fumbles, and ZERO fumbles lost on the season. And he split time evenly (21.1 cpg to 20.9 cpg) with the #4 rusher in the league as well.

Add to that the fact that we held Young to 10 yards on 8 carries, and he was fed the ball over and over in blowout wins while Pocketz never registered more than 30 carries in a game, then you'll begin to see why he led the league-- and it had very little to do with VALUE.

The fact is there are too many deserving RBs in Alpha to even consider one that much superior to the rest. I guess you could say the same about the top QBs in Zeta, but my MVP vote would have been split between Baby and Cannon.

I also find it a little humorous that while Santa Cruz is the #1 Rushing team and the #1 Blocking team in the league, not one member of the O-line received a mention. Yes, I am aware that Santa Barbara finished #1 in both categories after posting 790 rushing yards and 369 pancakes against the worst team in South America, but they were trailing the Cheetahs in both stats after both teams had played the same schedule.


8 carries against you guys was due to the fact that when a team is down, they tend to pass more. The same goes when you are winning, you don't need to pass as much, just run the ball and grind the clock out. I will concede that you stopped my guy on the 8 carries I got in our earlier matchup, but I also shared carries with another great RB, who tallied 16 touchdowns as well on the season.

I look forward to hopefully getting to play you guys in the Alpha championship game haha, should be a good one, barring any upsets >.>
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 11:54:51
 
kxrnidge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by kxrnidge

Man, I'd vote for my whole O-Line if possible


BTW Blitter will be happy to here Ben and Jackie made the MVP voting together! Also congrats Carlos!


Thanks, and yeah Ben and Jackie rock too. Pancake man is great as well, he just makes more holes than paincakes
 
JashSq
offline
Link
 
I'm going to follow satchmo's lead and say I strongly disagree with Celis Horn as DMVP or CBMVP. I don't understand how someone wins DMVP when he's let up 6 touchdowns this season and on 2 separate occasions, letting up 2 tds in a game. Correct me if I'm wrong but isn't the most important stat for a CB not to let up tds. No offense to Horn because 18 pics is good but he can thank Ryder Dean for those pics. Dean has played better than any CB this year.

We tried this with ballots last year and it didn't work out because too many people cheated on their voting. These things are just going to be like the pro bowl voting in the NFL until Bort puts some sort of coding in the game that will determine who the best players really are. Go ahead and flame me all you want but facts are facts and 6 tds allowed isn't deserving of DMVP.
 
sssmmike
offline
Link
 
Hey Jash, how many TD's did Reed give up?
 
JashSq
offline
Link
 
0 tds and 4 games where I didn't allow a single catch.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.