i think this is a good idea, this is still in beta testing so they should at least try this, (maybe make a seperate site to test this stuff?)
Forum > Suggestions > Controlling a Player's Weight (Diet)
kretchfoop
offline
offline
Originally posted by vrock627
i think this is a good idea, this is still in beta testing so they should at least try this, (maybe make a seperate site to test this stuff?)
That is basically how they decide the future of the game. They run some tests with the existing data and see if any new implementations can be pushed live without pissing everyone off.
i think this is a good idea, this is still in beta testing so they should at least try this, (maybe make a seperate site to test this stuff?)
That is basically how they decide the future of the game. They run some tests with the existing data and see if any new implementations can be pushed live without pissing everyone off.
bigtony2tone
offline
offline
I have been thinking about this issue since I started playing GLB. My thoughts are as follows:
There should be an advanced training, just like advanced tactics. The advanced training would be lose, maintain, or gain weight. Your training intensity would affect your weight program; relaxed would gain you minimal weight per day, intense would be "max". There would HAVE to be a max/min weight for each position. For example: An O-lineman would have a min of 270 and a max of 350. Also you could only gain/lose 10 lbs per season. Losing weight would increase (slightly) the daily training amount of speed, whereas strength would decrease. Gaining weight would do the opposite. I would make it even more dynamic, but any more would probably be too unrealistic for this game.
There should be an advanced training, just like advanced tactics. The advanced training would be lose, maintain, or gain weight. Your training intensity would affect your weight program; relaxed would gain you minimal weight per day, intense would be "max". There would HAVE to be a max/min weight for each position. For example: An O-lineman would have a min of 270 and a max of 350. Also you could only gain/lose 10 lbs per season. Losing weight would increase (slightly) the daily training amount of speed, whereas strength would decrease. Gaining weight would do the opposite. I would make it even more dynamic, but any more would probably be too unrealistic for this game.
Last edited Jul 10, 2008 02:59:16
wr50l
offline
offline
Height and weight need to be used in the game. It would give us more to ponder, for example if you get a 280 pound defensive tackle you can't build him like a 340 pound nose tackle and expect success; less cookie cutter builds.
Similarly, it would make owning a team more of a challenge. Getting the right players to fit your scheme, as opposed to just getting a guy with a "good" build.
Similarly, it would make owning a team more of a challenge. Getting the right players to fit your scheme, as opposed to just getting a guy with a "good" build.
kretchfoop
offline
offline
Originally posted by wr50l
Height and weight need to be used in the game. It would give us more to ponder, for example if you get a 280 pound defensive tackle you can't build him like a 340 pound nose tackle and expect success; less cookie cutter builds.
Similarly, it would make owning a team more of a challenge. Getting the right players to fit your scheme, as opposed to just getting a guy with a "good" build.
Exactly. We all have heard that size plays a small role in performance, but have no idea how much. That's all fine and good, but it seems that you reroll to get what you want and never think about it again. This would allow more customization of player builds and allow teams to search for faster or stronger players to fill out their teams.
Height and weight need to be used in the game. It would give us more to ponder, for example if you get a 280 pound defensive tackle you can't build him like a 340 pound nose tackle and expect success; less cookie cutter builds.
Similarly, it would make owning a team more of a challenge. Getting the right players to fit your scheme, as opposed to just getting a guy with a "good" build.
Exactly. We all have heard that size plays a small role in performance, but have no idea how much. That's all fine and good, but it seems that you reroll to get what you want and never think about it again. This would allow more customization of player builds and allow teams to search for faster or stronger players to fill out their teams.
kevbk6222
offline
offline
it would provide more depth in the game
teams would recruit the type of player that would fit in their system, weather that be a quick team or a very strong team.
teams would recruit the type of player that would fit in their system, weather that be a quick team or a very strong team.
kretchfoop
offline
offline
Originally posted by kevbk6222
it would provide more depth in the game
teams would recruit the type of player that would fit in their system, weather that be a quick team or a very strong team.
+1...just trying to keep this going...wonder why I haven't heard from the forum police yet.
Larry?
Scace?
Checkmate? (Aside from the already appreciated comedic relief)
I am sure there are some major issues with this, seeing as how it drastically alters the future of the game.
it would provide more depth in the game
teams would recruit the type of player that would fit in their system, weather that be a quick team or a very strong team.
+1...just trying to keep this going...wonder why I haven't heard from the forum police yet.
Larry?
Scace?
Checkmate? (Aside from the already appreciated comedic relief)
I am sure there are some major issues with this, seeing as how it drastically alters the future of the game.
Last edited Jul 10, 2008 10:27:32
Stokes36
offline
offline
I completely agree with this
+1
Weight should definitely be something that affects the game, AND we should be able to gain more weight on our players, or lose it
+1
Weight should definitely be something that affects the game, AND we should be able to gain more weight on our players, or lose it
kretchfoop
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Seems like a waste of time.
Really? This is an MMORPG. Adding depth to player creation and development is a waste of time? Thanks for your input, but I disagree.
I would agree if you said:
-"there are more pressing issues right now"
-"this would be too massive an overhall of the existing system to be feasible"
-"I choose not to elaborate, but I am against this idea"
Again, size matters in football. Genetics play the majority of the role, but diets are very important to professional athletes. It just seems to be a pretty big issue that was skipped over.
Seems like a waste of time.
Really? This is an MMORPG. Adding depth to player creation and development is a waste of time? Thanks for your input, but I disagree.
I would agree if you said:
-"there are more pressing issues right now"
-"this would be too massive an overhall of the existing system to be feasible"
-"I choose not to elaborate, but I am against this idea"
Again, size matters in football. Genetics play the majority of the role, but diets are very important to professional athletes. It just seems to be a pretty big issue that was skipped over.
wr50l
offline
offline
kretch, although I agree with the premise of weight being a huge part of the game, I'm not sure if I like your idea entirely. I would much rather see the option to cut or gain weight as more of an add-on, importantly as something that is available in the offseason only. As opposed to your radical reform of training.
bigtony2tone
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtony2tone
I have been thinking about this issue since I started playing GLB. My thoughts are as follows:
There should be an advanced training, just like advanced tactics. The advanced training would be lose, maintain, or gain weight. Your training intensity would affect your weight program; relaxed would gain you minimal weight per day, intense would be "max". There would HAVE to be a max/min weight for each position. For example: An O-lineman would have a min of 270 and a max of 350. Also you could only gain/lose 10 lbs per season. Losing weight would increase (slightly) the daily training amount of speed, whereas strength would decrease. Gaining weight would do the opposite. I would make it even more dynamic, but any more would probably be too unrealistic for this game.
+1
I have been thinking about this issue since I started playing GLB. My thoughts are as follows:
There should be an advanced training, just like advanced tactics. The advanced training would be lose, maintain, or gain weight. Your training intensity would affect your weight program; relaxed would gain you minimal weight per day, intense would be "max". There would HAVE to be a max/min weight for each position. For example: An O-lineman would have a min of 270 and a max of 350. Also you could only gain/lose 10 lbs per season. Losing weight would increase (slightly) the daily training amount of speed, whereas strength would decrease. Gaining weight would do the opposite. I would make it even more dynamic, but any more would probably be too unrealistic for this game.
+1
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























