User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > sack fumble bug. no credit for the sack
Page:
 
ChromeDome
offline
Link
 
If a QB fumbles when contact is made it is still a sack. That's why Jason Taylor always got those padded stats as he was great at getting to the QB, forcing the fumble and running it back. It didn't matter if the QB was on his butt or not. Progress is considered stopped for the QB so it's a sack.
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by PYLrulz

Originally posted by ptompkins


umm.. a sack is when you hit the QB and he doesn't fumble.. Looks liked you got the forced fumble stat which I think is better then a sack.


I thought if a QB fumbles, that counts toward a sack?


Not if the opposing team recovers the fumble, I think. It's a technicality I know. I had a NFL rule book once.


Nope. A sack is credited no matter who recovers the fumble.
 
arps
offline
Link
 
I thought to get a sack the QB has to be ruled down. If he fumbles he is not down regardless of who recovers it is not a sack.
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by arps
I thought to get a sack the QB has to be ruled down. If he fumbles he is not down regardless of who recovers it is not a sack.


Incorrect. Trust me, I watch football, I know how they do stats. If a guy comes around the edge and swipes at the football, knocking it away from the QB, he gets credited for a sack and a forced fumble, regardless of whether the QB even falls down. Heck, you don't technically even have to touch the QB to get credit for a sack if he fumbles it because of you.

There have even been instances where a QB scrambled out of bounds on a play when he was trying to pass and lost yardage and they credit the closest defender with a sack. That does not happen often but I have seen it done.
 
vexxet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VikesRule
Originally posted by arps

I thought to get a sack the QB has to be ruled down. If he fumbles he is not down regardless of who recovers it is not a sack.


Incorrect. Trust me, I watch football, I know how they do stats. If a guy comes around the edge and swipes at the football, knocking it away from the QB, he gets credited for a sack and a forced fumble, regardless of whether the QB even falls down. Heck, you don't technically even have to touch the QB to get credit for a sack if he fumbles it because of you.

There have even been instances where a QB scrambled out of bounds on a play when he was trying to pass and lost yardage and they credit the closest defender with a sack. That does not happen often but I have seen it done.


bumpity bump

 
PYLrulz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VikesRule
Originally posted by caponesgun

Originally posted by PYLrulz


Originally posted by ptompkins



umm.. a sack is when you hit the QB and he doesn't fumble.. Looks liked you got the forced fumble stat which I think is better then a sack.


I thought if a QB fumbles, that counts toward a sack?


Not if the opposing team recovers the fumble, I think. It's a technicality I know. I had a NFL rule book once.


Nope. A sack is credited no matter who recovers the fumble.


Looks like a lot are saying that. If that is the case, thats what I thought.
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
It happened in our game too. DE came around and got the sack and fumble but only credited for fumble. No sack.. ;(
 
vexxet
offline
Link
 
bump
 
stephiphany
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vexxet
bump


Wow, you really need that sack bad, don't you.

Two things.. #1, in the NFL, it's a sack everytime.. but they still don't officially call it a sack..they let the Elias Sports Bureau decide..

#2.. this isn't the NFL.. if the game admins decided it wasn't going to be a sack, then it's not going to be a sack.

Maybe it should be a sack, I don't know.. but I'd lose the righteous indignation and chronic bumps.
 
Jayweezy09
offline
Link
 
Look at it this way. Technically, you didn't tackle the QB at all (since the ball has to come out before he's tackled). And a sack is a tackle made on the QB that's making an attempt to throw the ball.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
There's a reason the term "sack-strip" was coined. If you sack the QB -and- cause him to fumble, you really should get credit for both.

This is a game for stat junkies, right? Only makes sense to give the junkies their fix when they've earned it.
 
vexxet
offline
Link
 
1) uh actually its a bug thats not fixed and im helping out the admins to getting it fixed.

2) you have no idea what you are talking about. you are speaking in ifs and making yourself look dumb. unless you are an programmer of this game you should hush up.

3) if you dont like the topic why dont you refrain from clicking on it. people who voice their opinions and are wrong in this topic dont come back to respond for a reason. they are wrong.

Originally posted by stephiphany
Originally posted by vexxet

bump


Wow, you really need that sack bad, don't you.

Two things.. #1, in the NFL, it's a sack everytime.. but they still don't officially call it a sack..they let the Elias Sports Bureau decide..

#2.. this isn't the NFL.. if the game admins decided it wasn't going to be a sack, then it's not going to be a sack.

Maybe it should be a sack, I don't know.. but I'd lose the righteous indignation and chronic bumps.


 
vexxet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jayweezy09
Look at it this way. Technically, you didn't tackle the QB at all (since the ball has to come out before he's tackled). And a sack is a tackle made on the QB that's making an attempt to throw the ball.


lol. is that what happened there? so when my DE touched the QB during a passing play (linemen are pass blocking and every receiver is covered downfield while the QB is scanning it) and the ball came out it wasnt a sack was it? wait thats the definition of sack-fumble? oh yeah, thanks for the opportunity to bump this without using a chronic "bump"

we need more people responding to this that have no football knowledge please.
 
justnzane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vexxet
Originally posted by Jayweezy09

Look at it this way. Technically, you didn't tackle the QB at all (since the ball has to come out before he's tackled). And a sack is a tackle made on the QB that's making an attempt to throw the ball.


lol. is that what happened there? so when my DE touched the QB during a passing play (linemen are pass blocking and every receiver is covered downfield while the QB is scanning it) and the ball came out it wasnt a sack was it? wait thats the definition of sack-fumble? oh yeah, thanks for the opportunity to bump this without using a chronic "bump"

we need more people responding to this that have no football knowledge please.

lol you are correct sir bumpity bump bump

 
DiMo28
offline
Link
 
Perhaps the programmers didn't realize it, but yes, it's a sack if you cause the QB to fumble on a pass play. I would like to see this corrected in the game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.