User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkgojackets
Originally posted by Derekross

Well that sucks for punters who are building for power and distance instead of coffin corner kicks.


why? It records the exact value that the punter provides. Booting it into the endzone from the 40 doesnt help much.


What about the value of hang time not allowing the returner to return it far? What about punting it in the corner not allowing the returner to return it far? How is a 40 yard punt that is returned for a touchdown better than a 50 yard punt that ends up a touchback? Net average is the exact value. This formula is far inferior.
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
Yes, because a punter has the same amount of control over his kick getting returned for a touchdown as he does kicking it into the endzone. Well reasoned.
 
Derekross
offline
Link
 
It doesn't matter dkgojackets. A 40 yard punt is a 40 yard punt. If some cat kicks the ball 100 yards but its a touchback, it shouldn't be an 80 yard punt, or 20 for that reason.

If my punter kicks the ball 40 yards yet its a touchback, it should give me 40 yards to my average, not 20. Simply because it says

13:51 4th & 8 OPP 40 Punt by Explosive Foot, 40.5 yds (touchback) - Give my 40 yards to my average, not 20.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkgojackets
Yes, because a punter has the same amount of control over his kick getting returned for a touchdown as he does kicking it into the endzone. Well reasoned.


In real life punters do have control over where they punt it and how high they punt it. Therefore, they do have control over how far it is returned and whether it is a touchback (on average, more hang time=less distance returned and closer to out of bounds marker=less distance returned)
Last edited Jul 6, 2008 17:47:28
 
StinkyP1nky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dkgojackets
Yes, because a punter has the same amount of control over his kick getting returned for a touchdown as he does kicking it into the endzone. Well reasoned.



You're entirely wrong in this thread. In the real life game that we're simulating here, "Punting Average" does not deduct for touchbacks. Period. End of story. Its already a known bug and due to be fixed, so stop arguing a point that you've already lost.
 
Derekross
offline
Link
 
Winner ^
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.