Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by SCACE
in case of passes, 0% just means that the HB isn't the first option. As long as he is running a route, he is an option, just not the first option.
I still disagree with this... if it were option based then whats the point of the percentages? Why not just list them as #1 option, #2 option, and so on then? With the percentages it means that x% of the time the HB is going to be the #1 target. Just because he is running a route should it entitle him to being an option? I say no (think of him as just a decoy). Whatever happened to the option to throw the ball away before throwing to the HB?
As far as the checkbox...
oh: looks like I used a bad example as to why I feel its not the appropriate solution to the problem (dont get me wrong I am happy there is going to be a solution even if its not the best, but...). It just concerns me that there is a warning label associated with this function and that in order for teams to be able to go 0% they must take some potential unknown risk. Again, why cant 0% just be 0?
imo the advanced ai (when finished) is going to be what everyone is asking for. The ability to specifically set what you want your team to do in certain situations. If you don't want your FB to run, don't set him as the runner on the play. Want the game to go for it on 4th down when you're down by 14 in the 4th, you can set that.
Originally posted by SCACE
in case of passes, 0% just means that the HB isn't the first option. As long as he is running a route, he is an option, just not the first option.
I still disagree with this... if it were option based then whats the point of the percentages? Why not just list them as #1 option, #2 option, and so on then? With the percentages it means that x% of the time the HB is going to be the #1 target. Just because he is running a route should it entitle him to being an option? I say no (think of him as just a decoy). Whatever happened to the option to throw the ball away before throwing to the HB?
As far as the checkbox...
oh: looks like I used a bad example as to why I feel its not the appropriate solution to the problem (dont get me wrong I am happy there is going to be a solution even if its not the best, but...). It just concerns me that there is a warning label associated with this function and that in order for teams to be able to go 0% they must take some potential unknown risk. Again, why cant 0% just be 0?imo the advanced ai (when finished) is going to be what everyone is asking for. The ability to specifically set what you want your team to do in certain situations. If you don't want your FB to run, don't set him as the runner on the play. Want the game to go for it on 4th down when you're down by 14 in the 4th, you can set that.





























