User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Automatically Adjust In-Game Strategy...
Page:
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by SCACE

in case of passes, 0% just means that the HB isn't the first option. As long as he is running a route, he is an option, just not the first option.

I still disagree with this... if it were option based then whats the point of the percentages? Why not just list them as #1 option, #2 option, and so on then? With the percentages it means that x% of the time the HB is going to be the #1 target. Just because he is running a route should it entitle him to being an option? I say no (think of him as just a decoy). Whatever happened to the option to throw the ball away before throwing to the HB?

As far as the checkbox... oh: looks like I used a bad example as to why I feel its not the appropriate solution to the problem (dont get me wrong I am happy there is going to be a solution even if its not the best, but...). It just concerns me that there is a warning label associated with this function and that in order for teams to be able to go 0% they must take some potential unknown risk. Again, why cant 0% just be 0?


imo the advanced ai (when finished) is going to be what everyone is asking for. The ability to specifically set what you want your team to do in certain situations. If you don't want your FB to run, don't set him as the runner on the play. Want the game to go for it on 4th down when you're down by 14 in the 4th, you can set that.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by SCACE

in case of passes, 0% just means that the HB isn't the first option. As long as he is running a route, he is an option, just not the first option.

I still disagree with this... if it were option based then whats the point of the percentages? Why not just list them as #1 option, #2 option, and so on then? With the percentages it means that x% of the time the HB is going to be the #1 target. Just because he is running a route should it entitle him to being an option? I say no (think of him as just a decoy). Whatever happened to the option to throw the ball away before throwing to the HB?

As far as the checkbox... oh: looks like I used a bad example as to why I feel its not the appropriate solution to the problem (dont get me wrong I am happy there is going to be a solution even if its not the best, but...). It just concerns me that there is a warning label associated with this function and that in order for teams to be able to go 0% they must take some potential unknown risk. Again, why cant 0% just be 0?


The only reason the warning is there is for teams that don't set their advanced tactics for every possible scenario. Basically, it says that if it doesn't find the input in your tactics, it will revert back to the normal AI controls for that play. And, if you don't have the proper punt or kick FG settings in there, it could cause you not to punt when you should, or not to kick a FG when you should.

Basically, you should only have that box checked when you are sure you've covered off everything with your tactics.

As for the 0% on passes, I don't understand what you don't get about the HB not being the #1 option, but still being an option. Until the SIM allows for the QB to throw passes away or eat the ball for a sack, it is doing the best thing it can, throwing to the receiver who is most open.
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
For those who keep defending these % inadequacies as checking down, or the QB passing under pressure. Here are some examples of the 'bug' as I see it.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=9397427 <--QB not under pressure, preffered long option is available, TE open.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=9397427 <--same again.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=9398990 <--TE and WR are open.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=9399681 <--Right side WR, WIDE open!

I realise that 0% will not always equate to zero passes, but for it to end up on 49% of passes is not acceptable.

Keep defending it all you like, but the sim does not do what it is told. And this is a bug. It doesn't even do what it says it will do, automatically adjust away from things that are not working to things that will work. Clearly the pass to the HB does not work, yet it keeps doing it.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Some people just plain do not understand the system.

The pass settings are not "throw for this yardage to these people", they're "run these kinds of plays". If you set it to 0% short passes, that doesn't mean you'll never throw a pass for less than 5 yards - it means you'll not run a play designed to throw the ball for less than 5 yards. You may still end up throwing it short if all your longer receivers are covered, or if the QB just plain doesn't see an open receiver on a longer route.
Last edited Jul 4, 2008 22:53:52
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Some people just plain do not understand the system.

The pass settings are not "throw for this yardage to these people", they're "run these kinds of plays". If you set it to 0% short passes, that doesn't mean you'll never throw a pass for less than 5 yards - it means you'll not run a play designed to throw the ball for less than 5 yards. You may still end up throwing it short if all your longer receivers are covered.


Mate, the point is my longer options are not covered. did you even look at the few examples I posted? The sim is also supposed to stop doing things that don't work, yet it keeps doing these plays that are not working.

All you seemingly have to do is not defend short, and let the QB throw to the guys that you want them to.
Last edited Jul 4, 2008 22:55:53
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Your QB's vision is very low. I wouldn't be surprised if he can't see the TE in the first two examples over the O and D lines.

In the third example, neither the TE nor the WR was open at the time of the pass.

Same with the fourth example.
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Your QB's vision is very low. I wouldn't be surprised if he can't see the TE in the first two examples over the O and D lines.

In the third example, neither the TE nor the WR was open at the time of the pass.

Same with the fourth example.

Maybe.

I've said my piece. What I'm going to do now is try and make the other teams get stuck in the same spot we are. The only problem is that we are fighting off the back foot coming off a rebuild.

I'll be interested to see the results of some 'testing' in our next match.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
The dump-offs suck right now. Eventually, they'll have to get the HB to go farther away from everyone else (more toward the sideline), so if he's ignored or can break the first tackle he can get some yardage, and is far enough from pass rushers the pass shouldn't get picked off by them.

As of now, I'd love to see it more possible to throw the ball away. As someone said, it's a much better option. Even trying to force the ball to a well-covered WR or TE has better prospects: The chance of an interception is about the same, and the chance of gaining some real yards is higher (even if he's so well covered there's only about a 20% chance to complete it).

But anyway, that's not deviating from strategy. If you set 0% of passes to the HB, then 0% of passes will be designed to go to the HB. QB's still think (because they only know what the AI tells them) that dumping it off is better than throwing the ball away or trying to force it to a blanketed WR or TE, so if they see no one open....
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.