I've seen this happen a few more times. The same play comes up twice, one second apart, with different replay links. Sometimes the extra replay is for a punt or kickoff play, sometimes it's something else.
A few examples:
WR Posts 3 Salt Lake City Mormons 2 Man Under Nickel Medford Ducks 3 10 2 3:31 -6 N RDE Dread End sacked QB Curt Everett for a 6 yard loss!
http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/17787/127718WR Posts 3 Salt Lake City Mormons 2 Man Under Nickel Medford Ducks 3 10 2 3:30 -6 N RDE Dread End sacked QB Curt Everett for a 6 yard loss!
http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/17787/127743Slot Deep Cross 3 Erie Swarm 2 Man Under Nickel Salt Lake City Mormons 3 10 1 13:14 0 N QB Scott Summers threw a pass to WR2 Frank Dennis, who was unable to secure the ball due to nearby defense.
http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/17842/143602Slot Deep Cross 3 Erie Swarm 2 Man Under Nickel Salt Lake City Mormons 3 10 1 13:13 0 N QB Scott Summers threw a pass to WR2 Frank Dennis, who was unable to secure the ball due to nearby defense.
http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/17842/143624Slot Deep Cross 3 Erie Swarm 2 Man Under Robber Nickel Salt Lake City Mormons 2 5 1 6:16 0 N QB Flutie Flakes threw a pass to WR2 Bull Crap, who dropped the ball!
http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/17842/143902Slot Deep Cross 3 Erie Swarm 2 Man Under Robber Nickel Salt Lake City Mormons 2 5 1 6:15 0 N QB Flutie Flakes threw a pass to WR2 Bull Crap, who dropped the ball!
http://glb2.warriorgeneral.com/game/replay/17842/143914