User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VikesRule
Originally posted by slashxtreme

The sideline isn't really the sideline, it's just the end of the viewable screen area of the sim.. if it's an INT then it's an INT stop whining


Then why is it called "out of bounds"?

He ran out of bounds after making the INT.. Are you telling me this doesn't happen in real life in either the pros or in college..

It happens to everyone it's not a slanted bug.. it's not an unfair bug that is causing certain teams to lose..
 
etchedchaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slashxtreme
Originally posted by VikesRule

Originally posted by slashxtreme


The sideline isn't really the sideline, it's just the end of the viewable screen area of the sim.. if it's an INT then it's an INT stop whining


Then why is it called "out of bounds"?

He ran out of bounds after making the INT.. Are you telling me this doesn't happen in real life in either the pros or in college..

It happens to everyone it's not a slanted bug.. it's not an unfair bug that is causing certain teams to lose..


You obviously did not bother to look into my own tie with that play. I was on the team that got that INT, and so I'm not whining about losing or any such crap. I'm merely posting what i believe to be a bug, and I've been dismissed for multiple reasons, because I believe there's a bug. Why are people so quick to dismiss bugs and attribute it to whining or misinterpreting? I'm not whining nor am I trying to demean the game, surely beta's require the pointing out of bugs to improve the game? thats what I'm doing.

As it stands, saying the dots are pointless is ignorance, the dots are a visual representation, they get their path's and end result from the simmed play, thus if a CB goes out of bounds and then has an interception then surely that is based on the result within a certain margin. Simply dismissing it by saying 'he touched his feet' or 'the sideline isn't the sideline its just the end of the viewing screen,' is hopeless excuses from people not wanting to see that this could be a bug.

Which begs the question, why are bug posts always dismissed, or have a hoarde of GLb defenders trying diligently to demean any bug posts, because it ruins their idea of GLb. GLB is not perfect, it is not even a full release - its a beta, we as beta-testers have to spot bugs and notify the powers that be of them, trying to them make excuses for quirky behaviour does not help Bort and it does not do the game any good. If its a visual representation problem, then its still a bug, just saying 'its only dots' means nothing, we want accuracy by pointing out problems it helps Bort fix them, if its a sim problem then its the same thing. Quit bashing bug posts and those that post them and open your eyes, we're not trying to hinder the game we're trying to help improve it.
 
HouseT
offline
Link
 
Really, there's no reason to get all morally upbeat about it.

I think the thing here is that the visual display issue has been acknowledged and that the powers that be are aware of the situation. No one's really making excuses when they "the dots aren't an exact representation." That's exactly what we/they have been told by the designers of the game.

I don't think most people here were trying to get on your case about it. They're probably just a little jaded since I'm sure they've seen a good handful of threads mentioning this "bug" already. Not to make excuses, since you should try to be civil with people regardless...

Anywho, I just wanted to make sure that you realized that everyone's not ganging up on you. The dot thing is just how it works now, and I'm sure it's on a list of things to work on at some point (but most likely not a huge priority).
 
etchedchaos
offline
Link
 
House, I was a little annoyed at slashxtreme he accused me of whining and I'm not a whiner, in fact the play in question helped the team i was on so if anything I've nothing to whine about. The dots thing is fine, i just think maybe this was a sim bug too, a rare one but one all the same. I've never seen or heard of someone getting a INT out of bounds as it seemed to be and as such I figured there might have been more to it. We won't know until either Bort says something or it happens again.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
This has been said but I think the dot was off, I think he did what NFL CBs do and caught the ball in bounds on the line and went out so he might have dragged his feet. This could be a bug but I think it is just the dot is slightly off or the out of bounds is slightly past the field of view in the replay.
 
blaslo
offline
Link
 
see, I don't think the simulation is saying the interception was out of bounds. I think it is just being misread.it's saying there was an interception, the player was not tackled but went out of bounds following the interception. What everybody seems to be saying is that the dots don't match up directly with what is actually simulated, so while the dots seem to show the cornerback going out of bounds before the interception, what actually happened is the simulation had the cornerback making the interception first, and then going out of bounds to stop the play, the dots just got a little mixed up on this particular replay
 
etchedchaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blaslo
see, I don't think the simulation is saying the interception was out of bounds. I think it is just being misread.it's saying there was an interception, the player was not tackled but went out of bounds following the interception. What everybody seems to be saying is that the dots don't match up directly with what is actually simulated, so while the dots seem to show the cornerback going out of bounds before the interception, what actually happened is the simulation had the cornerback making the interception first, and then going out of bounds to stop the play, the dots just got a little mixed up on this particular replay


Thats too many assumptions in my honest opinion, its assuming that the dots are major exagerations of the exact play but from my own recollections of the sim its generally accurate yardwise, and as such the fact he went that far out of bounds is a worrisome thing. I'd love to equate it to a misrepresentation by the dots, but those dots have a basis within the sim, if the sim messes up somewhere then the dots mess up.

Alot of re-sims have been done from funky things and the dots whilst only representations still represented those funky things and then it was re-simmed (this is before Bort adjusted how you watch games in play by play). So we have to believe that whilst the dots aren't exact representations and have been known to do quirky things they do tend to follow the general basis of the play within a reasonable amount of accuracy. For example a 4 yard rush up the middle is via representation a 4 yard rush up the middle by the dots, that doesn't change. I think if the actual sim was bug-free in this play then he never leaves the bounds and the INT is caught in view, if the dots are slightly off then i could see him just being slightly out of bounds mid-catch - but in this case he leaves bounds long before the pass arrives and when he catches it he is completely out of sight. Whether its a dot thing or a sim thing, that is far too much of an exaggeration for me to personally equate it to a faulty representation.

Remember guys the dots do what they do based on the result of the actual sim, if CB's are constantly going out of bounds then maybe its not just the dots, maybe there's a sim problem too, we have to consider this. We also have to think that with the sim, Bort has incorporated limits and rules, if those rules go askew somewhere or a limit goes wrong, the dots will follow likewise.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.