User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djknick
Maybe a bit of realism here will help. In the NFL when there is a new owner things don't necessarily change. Of course with owner input in the game strategy like we have in this game there is the possibility that things can get really screwed up. What I think should happen is that all current player contracts should be reset to end during the next off-season. Those that end earlier can still do so, or not, there shouldn't be that many that end in the middle of the season. The team should be offered to the GM's in the order they are listed on the team profile page, if none of them want it, the team is sold to a new guy. You could easily put a cap on trading for the remainder of the current season so the new owner can't gut the team but can still bring in some of his own players or those of friends. This way there is some new blood but it should reduce gutting. If there is a lag between when the current owner leaves the team and it is assigned to a new one, you could have the cpu run things like concessions and ticket sales for a short period and put a lock on trades until the new owner is in. The gm's could still easily handle the tactics side of the game until things are re-negotiated with the new owner. As for adjusting gutted teams down and such, isn't there already a scheme in place to move lower teams down and better teams up? It seems to me that this problem would take care of itself. If, for instance a team gets gutted, unless they are a winning team toward the end of the season when it happens, they will likely fall in the standings and drop to the next lower level anyway. Just let it happen the way it does now. Sure, there will be some weak teams in some good leagues but these things do happen. New owners, new coaches, those things typically happen in the off-season in the real world or if they do happen during the season it is in the best interest of the team to keep things as they are for the remainder of the season. Just my nickel's worth.


I think people are mostly worried about having to rebuild a team when you take over a sold Pro or AAA level team. It can be hard to get some new talent in to catch up and compete with the big boys who are already there, and getting blown out every week doesn't help your chances in those efforts, or your fun value.

I dunno, maybe it's not really necessary since you have a choice of what level you want when you chose your waiting list spot, but I've seen the idea floated around for a while so I thought I would bring it up along with the problems associated.
 
baseball8819
offline
Link
 
Maybe put in an option on the buy team page for a player to not accept a capped team? A simple check box would make them defer any team with a level limit (or input the highest level limit they'd accept). Just a thought.
 
Blisser
offline
Link
 
Well, this may not be a great answer, but you could always give the owner a time frame in which they could choose whether or not they want to risk reworking the team, or drop down and start from scratch.
 
Nat Belmont
offline
Link
 
Maybe if someone's just leaving the team and keeping all the players/stuff there for the next guy to just pick up where he left off, he could contact admins who could keep the team up there in that scenario, and just move them to the bottom tier in other cases.
 
Link
 
I think that when a team gets sold, the players should be able to accept contracts the same way they do when they are on the Dleague teams. If any of the players leave by signing a new contract then replace their spot with an equal level CPU player. This would at least help the players that get stranded on the team, esp if they signed multi season contracts with that owner.
 
Link
 
wow, this is a tough problem to work out.

I agree with having the option on the waiting list for a "gutted" team. That way, only the bravest or most desperate players will take one, and it will save the guy that wanted a fresh team from getting thrown in the fire.

As far as contracts go, I say when a new owner takes over the team, all existing players get the chance to opt out of the deal. Give a slight bonus of some kind to the players that stay to encourage them to stick it out.

I don't know though, this is a tough one! That's just some stuff floating around my mind about the issue.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
#4. Instead of the sportsmanship penalty, try this idea:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=491193

That way, if they want to move level 20 guys in, they can, they will just have to understand that they won't be able to get a bunch of other good players. Thus, the overall balance would still be had, but they could move in the specific guys they want as long as it isn't too many of them.
 
reasonbass
offline
Link
 
Is #5 currently an option? I didn't think you could sell your team to one of your GM's...I thought you had to sell it back to the website. I have no intention of selling my team any time soon, but it would be nice to know that I could pass it on to one of my GM's if that need should arise rather than scraping the thing.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


I think people are mostly worried about having to rebuild a team when you take over a sold Pro or AAA level team. It can be hard to get some new talent in to catch up and compete with the big boys who are already there, and getting blown out every week doesn't help your chances in those efforts, or your fun value.

I dunno, maybe it's not really necessary since you have a choice of what level you want when you chose your waiting list spot, but I've seen the idea floated around for a while so I thought I would bring it up along with the problems associated.



Bort, as a guy rebuilding a AAA team that was gutted last year you don't know how many times I've wanted to quit because of this very thing. To be competitive in my division I need lvl 18 starters today, really lvl 20+ guys to have a shot at playoffs.

95% of GLB players' agents are front-runners. They want to play on a winning team. There's no additional experience for being in a higher level league right now and the sportsmanship system has so many loopholes it's toothless. There's nothing to stop them from wanting to start on an expansion team where they're 3-4 levels higher than the competition, so as a losing team trying to rebuild in a tough division I'm fighting a losing battle.

I send out 200 PM's and I'm lucky to get 20 players to respond. Maybe two are interested in my team and might consider signing. It's funny when Jed is saying how hard it is for him to recruit, he has NO CLUE how hard it is for a gutted team in an established division to recruit high level players. If he thinks it's hard for one of the best teams in all of GLB to convince a lvl 20+ player to be a backup it's even harder to convince them to start for my 3-5 team.

And because of that you're seeing rampant gutting that you Admins have no real solution for as of yet. I've seen the same team have 4 different owners in two weeks because the new owner comes in, sees the team is gutted and he has no hope, and he sells the team back as soon as he can. And those of us honestly trying to do it the right way and plodding along are going to be just good enough that we don't get demoted, but not good enough to change our fortunes. I would've quit already if I hadn't made promises to some of my players that I'd stick around through season 4. I spent 2-3 hours a day trying to improve my team through trades or FA and the only luck I ever have is trades. (Another idea may be a big infusion of cash for rebuilding teams recognizing that many of them are only going to be able to acquire players through max-cash type trades.)

At the current rate it will take 5-6 seasons before a gutted Pro team ends up in B or BB. (You know we'll have them soon enough.) I think you need to do one of two things:

1) Develop some sort of power-rankings. Now that you've turned SE Asia, Oceania, and the other vertical leagues into pyramids you can re-shuffled the teams. Maybe give owners an option of potentially being reshuffled or not, but this has to happen for the teams trying to rebuild in Pro and AAA with no hope for the future but who haven't completely been gutted. Only moving down 2 teams doesn't even cover all the gutted teams in some conferences. Gutted Pro teams need to go all the way to the bottom, not to AAA.

2) When a team has been gutted (not just sold, but gutted) you, Thorn, or DD can classify it as such, and those teams automatically move down to the bottom at the end of the season. So you promote and demote the top and bottom two non-gutted teams every season like you're currently planning to do, and on top of that you make additional promotions and demotions based on gutted teams. It may mean 4, 5, or 6 teams from one conference move up a season, but it will keep the bad teams at the lowest levels, and the good teams will move up. I guarantee the #4 team in AA is going to step into AAA and win games.

I love this game and it's a ton of fun, but it's killing me too. I've got owners going inactive because they're sick of losing faster than I can recruit replacements right now. I've traded away every bit of extra depth I have to fill holes, and I don't have enough cash to buy replacements when teams are gutted and there are fire sales. I'm not sure what else to do.

Last edited Jun 28, 2008 21:43:48
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

Thanks all...feel free to add to the ideas and problems list.


Thank God Bort finally acknowledge this!!!!

I've thought about implementation to this and have a few ideas. Here are the responses to Bort's questions:


------------------------------

1. At the end of the season, each team is ranked 1-16 in their conferences. Currently, #1 East and #1 West are promoted. Schedule the remaining game based on how they finish in the conference. #1 East vs #1 West, #2 East vs #2 West. After the game, you will have tangible results to rank the teams 1-32 in the league.


------------------

2. Leaving players stranded for one season is the lesser of two evils. Think about the alternative. Gutting owners cuts/trades most of the talent. If not, the players request the new owner for release. Well that team is now hosed until it is relegated down to an appropriate level. Now, instead of screwing the team for one season, you screw them for many seasons. You also destroy competitive balance.

My idea is to release them all at the end of the season and relegate the team. Allow the current GM to do depth chart, offense and defense. No contract options. If no GM, assign depth chart power to the senior member of the team, OC to the #2 senior member ... etc. That is an easy method to at least get something going on the roster. Do not allow contract options for the remaining players.


----------------


3. This suggestion is good too. The team doesn't have to be cupcake. They can be replaced with similar level CPU's. If the team had a level 24 QB, give the team a level 24 CPU. That way, nobody is screwed stat wise. Then retire all CPU's at the end of the season.


----------------------------

4. Team level cap. Allow only 100 cumulative level's to be added to brand spankin' new teams. Allow level cap to grow for any talent cultivated over level 5. That way, you can bring in a few ringers. Or you can truly build a new team with new players. Either way, you will have balance. The ringer teams will have a few level one players. The truly new teams will have all marginal talent and no level one players. Balance is key.


-------------------------------


5. You must disband the team. This happens in real sports and it would definitely happen more if there were 2000 leagues. This is a harsh reality. Disband the teams, allow the FA's to sign elsewhere.


------------------------------

Thank you thank you thank you thank you thank you Bort!!!!!!!

I will live in this thread until this gets implemented. I have been campaigning for this for about a month!!!! Thank you thank you thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!
Last edited Jun 28, 2008 22:03:36
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sois

1. At the end of the season, each team is ranked 1-16 in their conferences. Currently, #1 East and #1 West are promoted. Schedule the remaining game based on how they finish in the conference. #1 East vs #1 West, #2 East vs #2 West. After the game, you will have tangible results to rank the teams 1-32 in the league.


I'm not sure what you mean here. Are you suggesting adding another game to the schedule, or replacing the interconference game? It's very likely to not be possible to schedule #1 vs #1, etc for the interconference game because it needs to even out home games. If both #1 teams have had 8 home games, and they match up, somebody in the conference loses out on tickets/concessions, and somebody gets 9 home games.

Originally posted by sois

3. This suggestion is good too. The team doesn't have to be cupcake. They can be replaced with similar level CPU's. If the team had a level 24 QB, give the team a level 24 CPU. That way, nobody is screwed stat wise. Then retire all CPU's at the end of the season.


Of course they would be created at similar levels for the league, just like they are now. However, what I meant was that the team is likely to get slaughtered no matter what the level of CPU's, I fear. The CPU can't game plan like a human can, the CPU players don't specialize like humans can, etc. Unless they are all 10 levels higher or something I don't think they'll be able to compete and will contribute to blowout wins. I'm just not sure if that's better or worse than stranding the players on the team because the owner just gave up. Probably better, but it doesn't help league balance, and I guess it could possibly be used to throw some games at the end of a season?
 
iv82much
offline
Link
 
First suggestion. If an ownership changes, any player on the team that had more than a one year contract would automatically be reduced to a 1 year. (salary would have to be changed too).


When a person, such as myself, decides to buy a team, there could be a question page thing.

On your new team, which of your own players do you plan on joining with this team?
You could use this information to decide which league lvl would be best for this new owner with his/her players that they want on that team.

I bought a team, 400 something on waiting list. I would like to get most of my current players on to my new team next season if I have the team by then. My dad also has 4 players that he'd want to put on to my team. Maybe there could be more questions.

Do you have any family or friends that have current players they would want to join your team with. then you'd have to input their players names. Could use all the player information to decide where to put a new owner.

I like the new owner option to accept a gutted team. That would take care of a lot of unhappy new owners that had to wait a long time to get a new team that turned out to be a gutted piece of crap in a higher league.
Last edited Jun 29, 2008 00:36:33
 
iv82much
offline
Link
 
I also think that having more than just 2 teams per conference move up or down would be a good idea. There is a HUGE amount of inbalance in the leagues right now.

Owners that are going into the next season could also have an option of... Would you like to be moved (up or down depending on situation) if the oppertunity arises.

Every conference doesn't have to have the exact same amount of teams move, but, every league lvl within the same conference would have to have the same amount of team movement to keep the leagues even.

The owner option of if they would like to move up or down could dictate how many teams are actually moved.


Obviously team record would have to be taken into account for if a team is eligible to move or not. Can't have a team with a losing record be moved up, or team with a winning record moved down.


If current new owners are unhappy with a gutted team they just recieved. There could be a ...

[ ] Team gutted option
These teams would have to looked at by a GLB worker to decide how far down the gutted team should be moved down in the offseason.
 
ntemans
offline
Link
 
How about contracts are automaticlly changed to end of season, this way players can still be on the team and the new owner doesnt have to hunt for new players? At the End of the season the new owner has the option of resigning or look for more players, same for players.

Gutted teams, I am not sure about.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

I'm not sure what you mean here. Are you suggesting adding another game to the schedule, or replacing the interconference game? It's very likely to not be possible to schedule #1 vs #1, etc for the interconference game because it needs to even out home games. If both #1 teams have had 8 home games, and they match up, somebody in the conference loses out on tickets/concessions, and somebody gets 9 home games.


Very true. Scrap that idea. Is it possible to have the playoffs determine who gets promoted after the conference champions? Replace the scrimmages with consolation brackets. Most yahoo.com fantasy leagues have this option so you can clearly determine the final rank of the playoff teams. From there, you could see which #2 conference team finished higher. Possible?

Originally posted by Bort

Of course they would be created at similar levels for the league, just like they are now. However, what I meant was that the team is likely to get slaughtered no matter what the level of CPU's, I fear. The CPU can't game plan like a human can, the CPU players don't specialize like humans can, etc. Unless they are all 10 levels higher or something I don't think they'll be able to compete and will contribute to blowout wins. I'm just not sure if that's better or worse than stranding the players on the team because the owner just gave up. Probably better, but it doesn't help league balance, and I guess it could possibly be used to throw some games at the end of a season?


They wouldn't get killed 255-0 would they? I'm sure they would at least provide enough of challenge to simulate a cupcake opponent rather than a totally overmatched, rebuilding team. You definitely wouldn't see any threads complaining about a 42-17 win over a CPU.
Last edited Jun 29, 2008 01:18:12
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.