User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Auto adjust - this is getting silly - NOT A BUG
Page:
 
Link
 
We certainly do not have enough information for anyone to call this a bug.


I can tell you that my experience with the game suggests that losses are treated in a similar fashion as gains. Big loss seems to reduce the plays likelihood of being called again more so than a small loss.


We can leave this here a bit longer, but unless we get solid evidence of a bug, we'll have to move on.


Peace,

Fish
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
I do wish it were more quantitative, or a slider system so you could set the thresholds of what is a good play or a bad play. I've seen for instance a QB rollout play go twice in the 1st quarter for 10+ yard gains, then a loss in the 2nd Q, and it never fires again with an aggressive AA setting........ would be nice to see it as a slider, or something.
 
robsalvador
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
I am not sure how many time we should complain about it before it get fixed.

Here is a game where the a run package that had the following (all plays start at 100%, offense is SSM and package only called on 1st and 2nd down) :
1) WI Off tackle called 12 times (only for gains, except two fumble to end the game)
2) WI HB slams called 3 times (only for gains)
3) SI counter weak called 3 times (two gains and a fumble, the fumble came first)
4) SI HB dive called 0 times
5) trips pitch strong called 5 times (3 losses and 2 gains shorter then 2 yards)
AA is set to adjust quickly.

The pitch play was adjusted up once due to the fumble , then adjusted down twice. This does not included adjust down when other plays got adjusted up.

Something is not working, or the information we were given about AA is false. In my calculations for the pitch play
1) start at 20%
2) adjusted up after the fumble : 20% /0.85 = 23%
3) adjusted down after 0.5 yard loss 23% - 15% = 8%
4) adjusted down after another 0.5 yard loss 8% - 15% = 0%





Think you are misunderstanding Borts quote.
The percentages multiply

Loss on play at 20% would yield 20%x(.85)=16.5%

Zero percent chance will never happen, percentage decrease for failure keeps dropping.

So you do have some movement of AA on results but largely still RNG dependent.


Tho i wish it worked as you suggest or at least AA was berfed....add to Suggestion

 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
I thought so. Until a Q&A explicitly said the other way around.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish
We certainly do not have enough information for anyone to call this a bug.

You got very clear evidence. The idea that something need to happen 10 times to be true is not applicable here. Due to two reason
(1) 1+1 =2 is not a statistical fact. It is a bug even if it happen once in a million years (may be insignificant)
(2) Since the nature of the AA is statistical, cases like the OP where it look like a mathematical impossibility are very rare. Many people complain about the AA. I happened to stumble on a case where it can be quantified. Generating a statistical date for this on large scale is near impossible (or just way too much work).

Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish

I can tell you that my experience with the game suggests that losses are treated in a similar fashion as gains. Big loss seems to reduce the plays likelihood of being called again more so than a small loss.


Possible (I pointed it in the OP). Even though -15% for a -6 yard loss run is stupid. So I guess it is not an exact mirror of the plus side.

But in the minimum it is a bug in the sense the explanation we got from Bort is wrong (or badly incomplete). A documentation error is no less a bug then a code bug.

Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish

We can leave this here a bit longer, but unless we get solid evidence of a bug, we'll have to move on.


If admins are going to keep ignoring it, then be honest and close it. Maybe change the forum name to 'Bugs we like Forum' (rant is toward catch no you).
Edited by tragula on Apr 11, 2012 22:14:24
 
climberpete
offline
Link
 
This would be very easy to verify or disprove on the test server, but I would guess the outcome will be the same as when I questioned the RNG and AA.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4781386
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by climberpete
This would be very easy to verify or disprove on the test server, but I would guess the outcome will be the same as when I questioned the RNG and AA.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4781386


Lol Catch answer, you had enough data.

This is a binomial distribution tested many time (70 times per package is fairly large), which mean it behaved as Gaussian. Your packages result were 1 standard deviation off the mean, which roughly mean 30% probability to happen.

However if I understand correctly this happened 10 times so 0.3 ^ 10 = 1/170,000 . This is a very rare event enough to justify further study.

(I did interpolated the data you published about the spread packages to all packages, but that is what I understood happened).
 
robsalvador
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
I thought so. Until a Q&A explicitly said the other way around.


So the first time an incorrect answer was given in q&a, would this be.
Hmmmmmm.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LEoNA_5RACc

 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
According to this Bort quote, a bad result only affects totals by -1 to -5.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4731373&page=6#43634458
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TruthHammer
According to this Bort quote, a bad result only affects totals by -1 to -5.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4731373&page=6#43634458


(1) Pass play
(2) If he talk % in that quote, then it is contradictory to other quotes which discuss numbers more clearly. (February 6, 2011 quote)

I will say it again, this suppose to be a bug forum not Sunday school. The continuous attempt to twist Bort's answer to fit everything does not belong here.

There are three options
1. My calculations are wrong (so far nobody showed them to be wrong)
2. There is a sim problem
3. There is a Q&A problem

Whether it is 2 or 3 it is a bug and should be acknowledged by admin (and if possible fixed).
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Continuing to insult the Bugs mods will only result in your thread being locked. We are here to help. You seem to have a scientific mind. Think of it as submitting your work to a peer reviewed journal. While all of our goals are the betterment of the game, we have to bring some level of cynicism to each thread to make sure your methodology upholds your conclusions.

Let's go back to Bort's 2/26 quote...

Originally posted by Bort
Answer "very quickly" is 5 times faster than "Very Slowly." Very slowly will adjust an output by between -3 to 3 depending on what happened (meaning "very quickly" will do from -15 to 15). For runs, a gain of 6 or more is a great gain, more than 3-6 is a good gain, 0-3 is neutral, and a loss is negative. For a pass, a 15 yd gain is considered really good, 6 yds is good, a loss is bad, and the rest is neutral. If the play was a turnover or a score, that's an additional + or -.

When Bort says "If the play was a turnover or a score, that's an additional + or -." Is he saying that's in addition to the +/- 15% or in addition to lesser adjustments from the results he had just listed, thereby bringing the total possible adjustment to +/- 15? In a vacuum, the quote is ambiguous at best. Taken with the quote from 9/26/2011 that I linked in my last post, I'm leaning toward the latter.

I understand that you are trying to prove a statistical impossibility, not a statistical improbability, the downfall of similar past threads that lacked sufficient data. But I don't know that you are using the right formulas, and I haven't seen anything so far to eliminate that ambiguity.

Edited by TruthHammer on Apr 13, 2012 09:03:09
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Saying that you are not doing the job you volunteered to do, is not insulting you. If I wanted to insult you I would call you stupid or something like that.

As I said, it is very possible that this is not a sim bug but just a case of wrong or badly worded Q&A answer.

I repeat again, bug mods should not waste their time trying to find okward ways to read Bort quote. Bort is not the Holy Pope he can make a mistake and he can correct it.

If you think that the Q&A is perfectly clear, and my interpretation is obviously wrong then say "no bug". I just think that 99 out of 100 people will read it exactly the way I do.

But if you think it is a bad worded Q&A answer, then use your power to get admins to acknowledged it. Fixing a Q&A answer is much easier then fixing a sim bug.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
- An ambiguous Q&A answer is not a bug.
- In this case, pointing out that your interpretation of the ambiguous answer may not be correct IS my job.
- Only by the most forgiving reader could your reference to this forum and the moderators in it as a "Sunday School" with Bort as the "Holy Pope" not be construed as an insult. At the very least, it's baiting.
- Assuming that 99% of people would read it the same was as you displays an arrogance that belies your earlier attempts at establishing mathematical fact.
- If the first of the two possible interpretations to his answer that I gave is true, there is a bonus adjustment for the fumble above 15% and you have understated the bonus in the 2nd step of your algorithm. Further, since he never stated the size of the additional adjustment, you cannot know how far you are off.
- If the second of the two possible interpretations to his answer that I gave is true, then you have overstated the penalty in the following steps of your algorithm.
- Either way, your algorithm completely ignores this statement and therefore cannot be accurate: "If the play was a turnover or a score, that's an additional + or -."

 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TruthHammer

- Only by the most forgiving reader could your reference to this forum and the moderators in it as a "Sunday School" with Bort as the "Holy Pope" not be construed as an insult. At the very least, it's baiting.


It was never intended to be an insult, so please accept my apology.

- I agree that mbiguous Q&A answer is not a bug. Do you agree that a wrong Q&A is a bug ?
- Do you honestly think Bort quote is ambiguous ? or are you trying to push it to be one ?

I agree that if we allow large adjustment from the fumble this may be resolved. The play that got fumbled had a maximal value of 35% when the fumble happened (started at 20% and got one positive adjustment from 4 yards gain). Lets assume the adjustment down was -40%

1) pitch start at 20%
2) adjusted up form the fumble : 20% + 40%/4 = 30%
3) adjusted down after 0.5 yard loss 30% - 15% = 15%
4) adjusted down after another 0.5 yard loss 15% - 15% = 0%
Same result. To remind you the play was called for a 3rd loss and still got called.

There was 3 straight adjustment down. So even if the adjustment of the fumble been -100% my calculation still hold (20 + 100/4 - 3*15 = 0).

____

I can add, many options for things that can explain this
- The adjustment to 100% include the play that was adjusted, so nothing can be adjusted to 0 (there is a Bort quote that say otherwise)
- Small loss give smaller adjustment (already been suggested)
- There is a minimum 1% that a play cannot drop below.
- The adjustment use rolls and the -15% values are just the mean (why not guess this too).

However, if you agree that,
- the example in the OP is puzzling.
- my interpretation of Bort quote is reasonable (not unique but reasonable)
- my calculation are reasonable (or correct).
isn't it more constructive just asking Bort or Catch ?

If this is a Q&A answer issue, then fixing it is 15 minutes work and benefit everyone.
If this is an indication of a sim problem, then it is even more important to solve it since people are complaining about the $ of plays in packages for a long while now.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.