User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > hey this cost us a tourney game and support told me to post it here - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Here is my teams Blocking FB showing the same behaviour : http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1953548&pbp_id=6685996 btw



I mean a 72 blocking Fb on a screen up 140 points vs 4 different dots receiving pass's from 2 different QB lvl 11 inside the other team 23 yard line with the game on the line mid-drive going for the tie seems to me to be a hell of a difference. not to mention that your talking about my WR on the last ball that finished with the HIGHEST eng of any of them.. I mean if we were down 30 than fine moral if they were RED eng bars than fine its eng but Neither of those were factors.. and really to just blame Builds is makes no since to me.. are my WR/RB some how built like your 72 blocking FB? I mean fine 1 Wr build but 3 and a RB and than the QB's builds also? really?...Rev
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:32:17
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IdRatherFlyFish
Rev -- we've pointed out the reasons this is not a bug. I'm sorry that you don't agree. I'm not sure what else I can do


Give me a reason for what happened that's not 4 different Receiving dots and 2 Diff QB's builds made players with a 5 yard cushion or more stand still for tick after tick...Rev
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:31:04
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rever
OK I just wanna make sure that I understand what ur saying After 19 games and 9/10's of this game with out any "Falls", on 6 consecutive pass catch's to 4 Different Receivers from 2 different Positions (3 WR and 1 RB) they all "fell" in 2 different drives over the last 2+ min of a Semi-finals Tournament game? Was the other team throwing Banana peels? I mean OK fine in the 1st drive a few falls than they go sit on the bench for the other teams drive, Inc what 3 Time outs and a False start penalty than after resting they come back onto the field and "Fall" 3 more times after resting? I mean if after 3 Time outs and a False start penalty you haven't gained enough energy to not go Jelly legs for another 3 straight catch's than what do you need to do?...Rev

We also have just played another mostly boosted team where my WR ended with less eng than the game in question and funny no Falls?????

Just for the record I have EQ going on my other comp and I have my Mag out with his Air pet


Just so you know Rever, my rookie dots have been falling for most of, if not all of, the season. I'm not sure why you just noticed it today, because I guarantee if I look at your past games I'd find some falls.

You may not like it...I don't like a LOT of things about the way the sim is written for the higher levels and frequently breaks down into unrealistic outcomes at lower levels. But it's been happening this way for a while and, in the bigger picture, isn't one of the more serious problems with low level dotball.
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjsexkitten82
Just so you know Rever, my rookie dots have been falling for most of, if not all of, the season. I'm not sure why you just noticed it today, because I guarantee if I look at your past games I'd find some falls.

You may not like it...I don't like a LOT of things about the way the sim is written for the higher levels and frequently breaks down into unrealistic outcomes at lower levels. But it's been happening this way for a while and, in the bigger picture, isn't one of the more serious problems with low level dotball.


Well to my 55 paying dots plus tourney cost and time put in to have it taken away like that is BS and I didn't just notice it I had a tag into support and they just told me to post it here today... plz feel free to show me games where my guys with 6 yards of open field just stand still for a @lest 2 ticks and as many as 5 on other plays multiple times in a game mid drive for 6 Consecutive catch's spanning 2 drives
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:37:31
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:36:58
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
We started this drive on our 41.5 yard line and drove to the opponents 23.5 inc a 9 yard pass the play b4 and if u see that last play he kind of juggles the ball and than mid drive something changes and my guys can't stand even after making the 1st down after 3rd and 1 than 6 consecutive "Falls" from 4 different dots. come on? sure 1 guy falls or 1 QB throws a bad ball but 4 different dots and 2 different QB's and they all "fall"?...Rev
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:44:00
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Both teams had 9 drops.

The score was tied when your defense gave up a TD with 4 minutes left in the game.

Not really seeing how you think this is what cost you the game.
 
Rever
offline
Link
 
I'll just cut and past that one from earlier..Rev

Originally posted by All American Dude
Both teams had 9 drops.

The score was tied when your defense gave up a TD with 4 minutes left in the game.

Not really seeing how you think this is what cost you the game.



Originally posted by Rever
How can you say that players not moving starting Mid drive on the Opp 23 yard line didn't cost us? we already had 36 yards just that drive and what exactly was going to stop us this time? I mean what cost us "Morale" mid drive? The 36 yards we already had or the 9 yard reception that we had the play b4? Maybe it was picking up the 1st down on 3rd and 1?There was nothing but Open field to tackle us not exactly "shut down" cov


Not to mention even after the 1st drive we started the 2nd drive in their territory again in our last 1 after making them punt from inside the 20


Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:49:01
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:48:14
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:46:27
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:46:02
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 21:45:36
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 

TIME OUT


Rever, your initial bug report has been reviewed and answered, this is NOT A BUG, the behaviour shown in the replays is working as intended, and it is build dependant.

It has happened to your team previously this season, and it has happened to almost every one else too.

I have explained that dots can fall down while making the catch at any point in a game, there is no point in talking about energy or morale or even how open they are.

Energy and morale will only make it more likely to happen, not cause it, and being wide open has no effect.

It is unfortunate that it happened several times in a row to your team in an important match, but it is not a bug.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Now I'm going to re-open this thread, as Rever seems to want help to stop this happening as often, so if people want to help with that great.

But if this turns into a flame/complaint thread it will be locked and moved, Bugs is not the place for that.
 
Bucknasty42
offline
Link
 
Here is what I don't understand, and maybe this happens, but I don't believe so and can never remember seeing it. If players are going to fall down catching the ball, then the defense should be falling down as well. When defenders change direction to pursue a ball carrier or break on a pass, or when defenders chase a player they are just as likely to fall down...yet you don't see that happening. Don't the defenders of the same level have similar morale, confidence, agility, stamina, etc????

This shouldn't only be a penalty to the offense. The only time I have heard of this happening on D is when a player gets an INT, and the only reason it is happening is because a change was made to the game to prevent the amount of pick 6's. Using that logic, players shouldn't be falling down on offense to prevent TDs. That seems very counter productive.

Maybe making a change on plays when a player would normally fall down he instead gets off balance and doesn't proceed as quickly. Stumbling and gaining a couple yards is better than not moving at all for 4 or 5 seconds.
 
Redass Ranch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


as Rever seems to want help to stop this happening as often, so if people want to help with that great

1. the behaviour shown in the replays is working as intended, and it is build dependant.
2. dots can fall down while making the catch at any point in a game



if the intent is to help Rever...

1. what is the solution or what needs fixing on the build, instead of the "working as intened" or "fix ur builds"
2. why do dots fall down while making catches? and why don't they fall down before making catches?

 
spindoctor02
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Redass Ranch


if the intent is to help Rever...


then this thread belongs in FAQ or Suggestions (if a suggestion comes from the discussion).

 
Rever
offline
Link
 
I guess I'm gonna try one more time to sum this up from my eyes because I feel like you guys have locked in on the falling down as the bug and that is not what I'm saying what so ever. What I'm saying is that Mid-drive after a 9 yard Reception our WR/RB never worked right again, there are way to many variables between the 4 receivers and the 2 QB's for no one to be able to stand after making the catch, on none of the plays does it say "Jumping or Diving" catch attempted all 6 were just normal catches that all fall down so something happened from 2:31 on that effected our entire team not just 1 guy or even 2 but 6 with my highest eng WR falling down twice...there was never a play after 2:31 till the end of the game where my WR/RB caught a ball and reacted normally so how can you say they were working right? After each "fall" the statistical probability of it happening again goes up exponentially until by the 6 consecutive "fall" the probability must of been astronomical and with-out any play ever working correctly who's to say we weren't caught in some kind of infinite Loop? to just say Builds is a joke to me and a cop out... Rev
Edited by Rever on Mar 19, 2012 23:49:13
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Redass Ranch
if the intent is to help Rever...

1. what is the solution or what needs fixing on the build, instead of the "working as intened" or "fix ur builds"
2. why do dots fall down while making catches? and why don't they fall down before making catches?



The falling down thing was a poor solution to pulling back the overpowered low level passing buff from a few seasons ago, tbh.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.