Originally posted by TaySC
Originally posted by Time Trial
His speed is 128.08, agility 99.22 (no first step)
His blockers are:
TE - speed 141.84, agility 85.84 (no FS)
HB - speed 139.19, agility 86.19 (5 FS)
FB - speed 135.98, agility 85.98 (no FS)
LT - speed 83.54, agility 78.54 (7 FS)
For his speed to be slower he sure does seem to get in front of both blockers very quickly tbh.
The problem with trying to evaluate a play like this and call it a "bug" is that we need to be able to test and replicate it. With a mere one example I do not see that as being at all possible frankly.
FWIW, Scouting the last 10 or so games for that play, the few times it was called, the initial movements of QB, HB and FB look almost exactly the same. It looks like its the various angles that puts the QB out ahead for a tick or two.
And that was consistent with a couple other teams checked, so possibly as intended?
But compared to the Goalline Formation version of the QB Roll Out, there is a big difference in how the initial move is scripted :
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1873223&pbp_id=5217363 (I didn't see a play with the exact same personnel though, but this delay was consistent with varied personnel in play.)
As its a new play/formation, might be worth looking into that aspect further, if its causing/contributng to consistent issues, and we get enough replays of it, could go under Admin Review rather than Suggestions, maybe?
As for the QB/Headless Chicken/Romo-ness of the OP play, I didn't see the same behaviour in any other attempt (almost certainly because the same D didnt come up in the games I scouted), so I'd agree with Tay, it would be hard to test if not consistent.