Originally posted by Sirwin
101: Graphics show something that looks impossible, like a catch out of bounds, the ball not being near someone when they catch it, the ball carrier stop short but given the first down and vice versa, punts that are or are not touchbacks or that have or have not gone out of bounds. In these and similar situations, the PBP text description is consider the accurate depiction of the events while the visual replay is considered approximate.
Awesome play nonetheless.
while I understand that you would need more than one example of the incident to declare it a bug, I think dismissing it as just a visual occurrence is premature. I have seen the "approximate" visual errors in the past and understand that can be the case. This dot was several yards past the line of scrimmage on that throw and I haven't seen a visual error that big.
This exact play is either an illegal forward pass, or a fumble (if determined the ball went parallel or backwards). No way it is a visual error, but understand more examples would be needed to classify it as a bug.
101: Graphics show something that looks impossible, like a catch out of bounds, the ball not being near someone when they catch it, the ball carrier stop short but given the first down and vice versa, punts that are or are not touchbacks or that have or have not gone out of bounds. In these and similar situations, the PBP text description is consider the accurate depiction of the events while the visual replay is considered approximate.
Awesome play nonetheless.
while I understand that you would need more than one example of the incident to declare it a bug, I think dismissing it as just a visual occurrence is premature. I have seen the "approximate" visual errors in the past and understand that can be the case. This dot was several yards past the line of scrimmage on that throw and I haven't seen a visual error that big.
This exact play is either an illegal forward pass, or a fumble (if determined the ball went parallel or backwards). No way it is a visual error, but understand more examples would be needed to classify it as a bug.






























