User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > 3rd Timeout not called when on offense and score tied - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TaySC
Guys, the Bug Mods are here to help you. They can only do that if you give them what they ask for to accurately evaluate the situation.



PM sent. Waiting for anyone who can tell me how access to my AI will help answer the question of WHY WASN'T THE 3RD TIMEOUT CALLED.

I'm not interested in whether or not a field goal was kicked. That's not the subject of this thread. Stay on topic please!
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
It's not about basic AI and it's not a bug. It sounds like the advanced AI was set up based on the old timeout logic.

Sim Major Changelog (affects following day)

Nov 11, 2010
- New timeout logic based on user suggestion, and updated hurry/slow down logic to go with it

Nov 17, 2010
- Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal


Part of this change was to save your last timeout when on offense, until the last 30 seconds or so. It's been this way for several seasons now as you can see by the date. No real team in their right mind would call their last offensive timeout with 40+ seconds left in a tie game.

Basically what you want to do is set your AI to kick the FG with less than 40 seconds left, and the sim will automatically run the time down to 1 before calling your last timeout. (Unless of course you want to keep running plays to try to get closer or score a TD instead.)


FYI, I have the logic at 40 seconds and then at 30 seconds as a backup. But that has NOTHING to do with my question. I want to know WHY WASN'T THE 3RD TIMEOUT CALLED. Your answer is off-topic!
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
thanks for this input Trevjo. This seems to be working as intended. Seems as though the sim is saving the last timeout for 1 second and a game winning FG. It's kinda rough that that happened but this is a change that was requested enough for Bort to add it, so I'm afraid you need to fix your AI



WHAT? Please read the sim changes again. Nothing about waiting till the last second to "call a timeout". It says the team lines up and let's the clock run down before snapping the ball and kicking the field goal. Very different. I've seen the 3rd timeout called in many similar situations since this sim change Trevjo cited so that's not correct at all.
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Androth
There are a couple quirks to get this to call correctly, but basically what Trevjo said is correct.

NOT LIKELY A BUG


Unbelievable. Please show me in the sim change logic Trevjo cited where it says the 3rd timeout will be held until the last second. Answer: it doesn't. C'mon guys! Seriously this is basic reading skills!
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jay Gold
You didn't perhaps happen to have the "Call basic tactics run/pass plays (do not kick field goals or punt) when there is no match to my inputs. Use with caution!" box checked...did you? Just curious.


No. Asked and answered already.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sly
FYI, I have the logic at 40 seconds and then at 30 seconds as a backup. But that has NOTHING to do with my question. I want to know WHY WASN'T THE 3RD TIMEOUT CALLED. Your answer is off-topic!


Actually, he did answer your question.

1.) Bort has changed the sim so that when the score difference is 3 or less, the sim holds onto your final timeout for your game-winning FG attempt.

2.) Your AI is set so that it will only kick a FG when you have 0 timeouts remaining.

Therefore, because of #2, every time the sim calls a new offensive play for your team, it skips over your FG output since you have 1 timeout remaining, and calls a normal play instead.

And since your AI is calling a normal play, the AI refuses to call your 3rd timeout because it's holding onto it for whenever your AI finally calls for a FG -- which can never happen because your FG output only activates when you have 0 timeouts, and you still have 1 timeout.

Your question has been answered. And now it's been answered again.

You need to fix your AI so that it can call a FG on any down with under 30 seconds remaining and ANY number of timeouts remaining.
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jay Gold
As for the 3rd timeout situation....game wouldn't call a timeout after your 3rd down play. Pass was incomplete.

Which leads to the question of what you have your FG parameters set to. If you did happen to have 50 yards as your FG parameter, that would be why no FG was kicked.


THANK YOU for at least recognizing what the topic of this thread is! However, while you answered why a timeout wasn't called after that specific play, the question remains as to why a timeout wasn't called after my 2nd down play, or the 4 plays before that?

Please don't get off-topic with FG logic, etc. Enough people are confused by that already. Stick with the question of WHY WASN'T THE 3RD TIMEOUT CALLED?
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Actually, he did answer your question.

1.) Bort has changed the sim so that when the score difference is 3 or less, the sim holds onto your final timeout for your game-winning FG attempt.


Can you show me any evidence of that in the sim change information because so far no one has shown any evidence of that.
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sly
PM sent. Waiting for anyone who can tell me how access to my AI will help answer the question of WHY WASN'T THE 3RD TIMEOUT CALLED.

I'm not interested in whether or not a field goal was kicked. That's not the subject of this thread. Stay on topic please!


Not sure what you are attempting to accomplish here as numerous people have answered this question AND shown you the change log where it says it would "Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal."

Really, you are right about one thing..... at this stage no one needs access to your Al and this topic should be closed.



 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TaySC
Not sure what you are attempting to accomplish here as numerous people have answered this question AND shown you the change log where it says it would "Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal."

Really, you are right about one thing..... at this stage no one needs access to your Al and this topic should be closed.



Does no one else here see a difference between these statements?

"Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal."

"Don't call a 3rd timeout until 1 second is on the clock when games are within 3 points."

Because, believe me, the first statement doesn't even address the topic of time outs, so there's a HUGE difference.
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
OK Sly, you have had your vent session.

I am locking this down, but will get someone else to take a look at it and give more feedback, but the venting in this thread and debating here is done.

 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Reviewing this now per TaySCs PM, will post my thoughts.
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Reviewing this now per TaySCs PM, will post my thoughts.


For starters, there are many items in the changelog that are not real specific as to exactly what was done by Bort.

Originally posted by
Nov 18, 2010
- Require at least 15 seconds left to be able to auto run clock down to 1 on game winning FG attempt

Nov 17, 2010
- Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal
- Adjust 4th quarter timeout logic for use of 3rd timeout to use more freely when trailing

Nov 16, 2010
- Update timeout logic to make sure neither team calls 4th quarter timeouts while winning

Nov 15, 2010
- Double time remaining cutoffs for timeout logic

Nov 11, 2010
- New timeout logic based on user suggestion, and updated hurry/slow down logic to go with it


Several of those are not real specific tbqh..

the ONLY thing that makes me think the OP may have a point is that I know of another game recently where a team was down by 2 and called all 3 timeouts prior to letting the clock run down.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1758962


NOW, there may be a difference in how Bort has it set up in a TIE game as is the case in the OP's scenario versus in a game where a team is down by 2 (the case in the game I just linked).

I honestly don't know the answer to that and either Catch22 or Bort may have to intervene to tell us exactly how the timeouts are set up.

 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sly
Does no one else here see a difference between these statements?

"Allow clock to run down to 1 second or as much as possible when attempting to kick the game winning field goal."

"Don't call a 3rd timeout until 1 second is on the clock when games are within 3 points."

Because, believe me, the first statement doesn't even address the topic of time outs, so there's a HUGE difference.


Firslty, I see what your saying here and you are correct, that sentance relates to how much time is run off the clock between plays when kicking a game winning field goal. Not Time Outs.
However nobody was using the second line, thats reductio ad absurdum and doesn help to address the potential issue.



As for not using the remaining Time Out, there is a disconnect between the in built end game logic, and how your AI was set up.

Unfortunately in this case it lead to the last Time Out not being used, but the reason is evident, the end game scenario lead to you simply not needing it.

0:41 1st & 10 OPP 40 Antone $mith rush [missed diving tackle: Lamar Vernon] to the left (6 yd gain) [tackle: Jimmy McNulty II Jr.] Replay
0:21 2nd & 4 OPP 34.5 Super Horse rush up the middle (1 yd gain) [tackle: Omar Little II Jr.] Replay
0:06 3rd & 3 OPP 33.5 Juan Chiles pass to Happy Action Fun Time up the left side [deflected by Jimmy McNulty II Jr.] (incomplete) Replay
0:02 4th & 3 OPP 33.5 Viking Thunder pass to Shrimper Harsh up the left side, caught[forced fumble: Jimmy McNulty II Jr.], fumbled , recovered by Bolt _ [TD] (83 yd return)


There was no reason to call a time out at the end of the 1st down play, in a tied game inside FG range. Better to let the clock wind down.

There was no reason to use the Time Out after the 2nd down play. Using the full play clock would allow the FG attempt to be made at 0:06, the Time Out would not decrease this remaining time in any way, and there was no reason to try to get more plays.

There was no reason to use the Time Out at the end of the 3rd down play as it was a stopped clock anyway. If it had been a moving clock, it would have taken the Time Out now.

So I agree that this is Not A Bug.

OP has already identified and fixed his AI issue for end game apparently, so recommend closing and moving thread.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
The issue was with the user's AI (ball placement settings for end game FG input). This is not a bug - you can close as such.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.