User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > D-League teams not filling with CPUs properly
Page:
 
Lurchy
offline
Link
 
+1

The problem isn't just that players aren't filling positions. What happens in certain cases such as mine is that my starting MLB ends up playing DT or NT the entire season because GLB has a game position algorithm that overrides the roster position algorithm.

Check out "Romin Pullanski" at MLB:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=9057

Now see his game replays at DT/NT:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_replays.pl?player_id=2275984&game_id=1745663

This would not happen if the rosters filled properly.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
+1

I could have sworn that the suggestion in the OP describes exactly how the D-leagues worked up until the Auto Offer option was implemented. Either that, or it was the change in the way CPUs are signed that broke it.
 
ig
offline
Link
 
Lurchy is right on target as well.

If I create a player at a particular position, I'd like them to play there in their D-League games.

Example: I have a D-League TE that played two S23 preseason games at G/OT despite only being on the depth chart at TE. In those 2 games he committed at least 9 false starts in EACH game. He also played in the D-League in S22 and didn't commit a single penalty while lining up at TE.

I had to create two G and put them on the same D-League team as my TE just to get my TE back to his assigned position.
 
xhail2skinsx
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I have QBs that don't get one snap at QB; they just play Special Teams the whole game
 
ig
offline
Link
 
QB is just ridiculous in the D-Leagues right now.

I did a quick query of just Rookie-Soph D League #1 as I assume all leagues are similar. There are currently 102 QBs in D-League #1 (i.e., 16% of all the players in the league). Of those QBs, 44 are human and a whopping 58 are CPUs. So, despite there being enough human QBs for each team to have one--and almost enough remaining for half of the teams to have a second--the roster logic still thinks there should be almost an additional 2 CPU QBs per team.

The number of QBs makes even less sense considering only one QB can play at a time. Yet other positions such as G, OT, WR, DT, DE, LB, and CB commonly (if not always) use two players simultaneously. There are more CPU QBs than total players at any one of those positions. In fact, the only position to have more total players than CPU QBs is at the HB which is similarly broken (but not to the same degree).

Here's how the player numbers look for D-League #1:

QB = 102 players (44 human, 58 CPU)
HB = 65 players (33, 32)
FB = 31 players (8, 23)
C = 33 players (13, 20)
G = 35 players (10, 25)
OT = 33 players (10, 23)
TE = 32 players (7, 25)
WR = 39 players (21, 18)

DT = 36 players (15, 21)
DE = 35 players (17, 18)
LB = 36 players (16, 20
CB = 34 players (8, 26)
SS = 32 players (7, 25)
FS = 32 players (3, 29)

K = 32 players (9, 23)
P = 32 players (6, 26)


Summary:
- Each D-League team could have 1 or 2 human QBs, yet there are more CPU QBs in the D-Leagues than total players for each position except HB.
 
xhail2skinsx
offline
Link
 
I applaud you ig
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Pwned IRL
Originally posted by Myd

So..what exactly is the suggestion?


D-League rosters do not fill themselves up, or even pay attention to how many players at each position they have.

This to me doesn't represent the game of football very well..

+1 to this suggestion.


+1, I like it.
 
PING72
offline
Link
 
+1....it's stupid that they don't already do this.
 
Jaxon Voom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ig
QB is just ridiculous in the D-Leagues right now.

I did a quick query of just Rookie-Soph D League #1 as I assume all leagues are similar. There are currently 102 QBs in D-League #1 (i.e., 16% of all the players in the league). Of those QBs, 44 are human and a whopping 58 are CPUs. So, despite there being enough human QBs for each team to have one--and almost enough remaining for half of the teams to have a second--the roster logic still thinks there should be almost an additional 2 CPU QBs per team.

The number of QBs makes even less sense considering only one QB can play at a time. Yet other positions such as G, OT, WR, DT, DE, LB, and CB commonly (if not always) use two players simultaneously. There are more CPU QBs than total players at any one of those positions. In fact, the only position to have more total players than CPU QBs is at the HB which is similarly broken (but not to the same degree).

Here's how the player numbers look for D-League #1:

QB = 102 players (44 human, 58 CPU)
HB = 65 players (33, 32)
FB = 31 players (8, 23)
C = 33 players (13, 20)
G = 35 players (10, 25)
OT = 33 players (10, 23)
TE = 32 players (7, 25)
WR = 39 players (21, 18)

DT = 36 players (15, 21)
DE = 35 players (17, 18)
LB = 36 players (16, 20
CB = 34 players (8, 26)
SS = 32 players (7, 25)
FS = 32 players (3, 29)

K = 32 players (9, 23)
P = 32 players (6, 26)


Summary:
- Each D-League team could have 1 or 2 human QBs, yet there are more CPU QBs in the D-Leagues than total players for each position except HB.


All this.

I find it utterly ridiculous that with GLB being flooded with QB's already, that the d-league feels the need to flood each team with 2-4 CPU QB's when there's a human dot already there. Same for other positions. Is it really that hard to fill teams with CPU's in the positions that that team needs?

Just another common sense fail from GLB.
 
Ralt
offline
Link
 
My QB has 3 other CPU QBs on the team, only 2 WR and no O line to speak of.
I know he only needs 1 play to get max XP, but it would be nice to be able to see him play with a full roster to see what stuff really does.
How else do you try different builds or changes if the player is never in his position to test it?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ralt
My QB has 3 other CPU QBs on the team, only 2 WR and no O line to speak of.
I know he only needs 1 play to get max XP, but it would be nice to be able to see him play with a full roster to see what stuff really does.
How else do you try different builds or changes if the player is never in his position to test it?


Exactly, also some players are always playing out of position.

For example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1733880&pbp_id=2326735

LBs playing on the D-Line and DBs playing at LB (and this happens on every play. The game just picks the players in the order from the roster page and fills the positions in order without any regard for their actual position. Useless if you want to see how your dot is progressing.

How can a team only have 20 players? And then 3 of them are QBs?
 
Jaxon Voom
offline
Link
 
Also notice this D-league QB. Not one snap at QB in favor of the CPU...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_replays.pl?player_id=2456719&game_id=1734226
 
AlaskanRaven
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PING72
+1....it's stupid that they don't already do this.


 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Since they made 1 play enough for max XP +1.


Before this I would have given it a thumbs down.
 
Chris465 DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AlaskanRaven
Originally posted by PING72

+1....it's stupid that they don't already do this.




 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.