User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defender speed still dependent on ball-carrier's speed - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
pm pabst or db
Edited by Mike Rogers on Jun 2, 2011 22:54:09 (NMI)
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Triathlon Dude
There is an easy way to fix this....


Is there an easy way to rig that Grease monkey Script, to track two people's speed at one time???????

If that could happen then we can match the dips and see if the players are slowing down together


That doesnt help at all to fix it.

Its evident that the defender is reacting to the ball carrier, and that he is having to slow/repath as the ball carriers speed/path alters.
That is expected behaviour and its logical.

The question is if the defenders pursuit is logical or if one specific issue is causing a genuine Bug.

What we really need replays where a ball carrier is NOT MOVING during/after a missed tackle, and the defender in pursuit comes to a full stop too. That would be an issue that needs fixing.

Now this replay: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1703156&pbp_id=7110547 is evidence that Defenders will close in to stationary ball carriers who have shrunk whilst making a catch attempt.

The one strom linked : http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1703303&pbp_id=7396287 is a very similar situation, but the FS is further away on the other side of the field, and has to pass/see through traffic, which might explain his slower speed.

But its obviously not a case of a bug in ALL pursuits of none moving targets.
Now we need to know if its specific to all broken tackles, or just Spin Moves.

If we could prove its only spin moves, that might result it a better fix that corrects the issue without effecting the rest of the sim balance.


-Marked NMI-
Edited by Mike Rogers on Jun 2, 2011 22:56:34
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Its evident that the defender is reacting to the ball carrier, and that he is having to slow/repath as the ball carriers speed/path alters.
That is expected behaviour and its logical.


-Marked NMI-


Why is this expected behavior.........A defensive player should never slow down, if they think that the offensive player is going to be tackled. They should always assume that the play will result in a missed tackle, and not slow down.


Just because an offensive player slows down does not mean the defensive player should slow down. if that is the case, as it seems here, then that would be a bug.
 
Link
 
Here's another example of speed being affected by the RB on the curve.
Watch the potential for speed by the LOLB right off the bat.
Then watch how he stumbles for the last 5 seconds of the replay and makes no pursuit.
(presumably, according to some hypotheses in this thread, because of the recalculations)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1664128&pbp_id=7759562
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
I posted this a while back about dots stopping while a tackle was being made/missed and I believe rage and I went on for 2 pages about it only to be labeled NMI


I've been a part of these discussions before.
I thought it was fixed, but it's still happening, so irregardless of hte previous results, it's still an issue.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
What we really need replays where a ball carrier is NOT MOVING during/after a missed tackle, and the defender in pursuit comes to a full stop too. That would be an issue that needs fixing.


I think a big part of it is about when players are on a curve, not just when there's a missed tackle, as I indicated in my most recent replay above.... and in this post here:Originally posted by stromstarhammer
The reason this is a problem is that players are constantly slowing down... let's say "recalculating" on pitches as well.
It's anytime the ball-carrier is on a curve.
Those interactions are less noticeable than the one in the OP, but it is still problematic.


Edited by stromstarhammer on Jun 3, 2011 14:36:09
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
I suppose that if you think a defender should always be charging in a bee-line towards the ballcarrier, then i can see why folks might think this is a bug.

I don't think that is either realistic, nor in many cases desirable.


A defender at long range (which comprises the majority of these examples) needs to maintain safe pathing as a tackler of last resort.

We may know that a ball carrier is extremely unlikely to make a sweeping cutbak, and that thier hesitation on the field is the result of a missed tackle, and especially of the spin mechanic, but the Dot does not (and in my mind should not) know this. They see a dot suddenly altering velocity and direction so they stutter step and slow down to make sure they remain on a valid path towards their goal.

That's as it should be in my opinion.


We can't expect dots to make a bee-line for the ballcarrier at maximum speed without hesitating for any change in the carrier's path...that's just crazy and unrealistic in my book.


If a tackler is very near the ballcarrier (within 4 yards perhaps) and the change in vector is small, then you can make a case for the tackler to keep flying in.


If a change needs to made (and I don't really think it does) then I would suggest that when a dot slows to a near stop, a long range defender should plot in intercept course that assumes some sort of flat rate movement towards a position some pre-determined distance ahead of the carrier...5 yards ahead of the carrier for every 10 yards displacement in the horizontal plane between defender and carrier for instance.

I suspect that folks would dislike these results more than they dislike the current results, however.

Edited by tautology on Jun 3, 2011 15:17:51
Edited by tautology on Jun 3, 2011 15:17:36
Edited by tautology on Jun 3, 2011 15:16:39
Edited by tautology on Jun 3, 2011 15:16:25
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
Here's another example of speed being affected by the RB on the curve.
Watch the potential for speed by the LOLB right off the bat.
Then watch how he stumbles for the last 5 seconds of the replay and makes no pursuit.
(presumably, according to some hypotheses in this thread, because of the recalculations)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1664128&pbp_id=7759562


This appears to be something different, and it is not a case of speed-matching the ball carrier.

I do see this sort of thing every once in awhile...it does seem like the defender gets stuck in some sort of different speed mode and I have no idea why. Might be having a hard time finding a path through the traffic?

Edited by tautology on Jun 3, 2011 15:20:56
 
gbororats
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 

Originally posted by stromstarhammer
Here's another example of speed being affected by the RB on the curve.
Watch the potential for speed by the LOLB right off the bat.
Then watch how he stumbles for the last 5 seconds of the replay and makes no pursuit.
(presumably, according to some hypotheses in this thread, because of the recalculations)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1664128&pbp_id=7759562


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4565794 already filed....
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
I suppose that if you think a defender should always be charging in a bee-line towards the ballcarrier, then i can see why folks might think this is a bug.


Part of the problem is that often times the defense DOES bee-line towards the ballcarrier, ignoring everything between them (i.e. CB3 in this replace: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1664128&pbp_id=7762913 )
 
Link
 
Originally posted by gbororats
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4565794 already filed....

nice find
 
pabst
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Triathlon Dude
There is an easy way to fix this....


Is there an easy way to rig that Grease monkey Script, to track two people's speed at one time???????

If that could happen then we can match the dips and see if the players are slowing down together


Don't see how it helps, but on line 74'ish of my copy, comment this line out: ctx.clearRect(0,0,canvasX,canvasY)
 
gbororats
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1663046&pbp_id=8245956

more LOS slow down, not sure this is the proper thread, but it doesnt seem to be getting fixed in the other one either

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1663046&pbp_id=8245956
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Nothing active here in over 2 months. Closing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.