Invidious was defined within the code. Dictionary definitions are irrelevant when the drafters choose to act as their own lexicographers. Read it again.
Forum > Suggestions > Hometown Hockey team / United Way partnership
awesome
offline
offline
Here, because I know you don't have decent reading comprehension:
"Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership."
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
"Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership."
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by awesome
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
awesome
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
It doesn't mater one iota whether *you* see anything in that statement that would be trouble. You have absolutely no say in a disciplinary hearing. I am telling you that this is how this rule is construed. Like it or not, that is not my problem. Call your state Supreme Court if you want it changed.
Originally posted by awesome
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
It doesn't mater one iota whether *you* see anything in that statement that would be trouble. You have absolutely no say in a disciplinary hearing. I am telling you that this is how this rule is construed. Like it or not, that is not my problem. Call your state Supreme Court if you want it changed.
awesome
offline
offline
By the way, you also don't have a say in whether it will be changed, but it can't hurt to try.
The judiciary is self-regulating.
The judiciary is self-regulating.
Checkmate187
offline
offline
First (and hopefully last) time I get really personal on this site.....
awesome, I would pay real money if you would shut up.
awesome, I would pay real money if you would shut up.
keedon
offline
offline
Originally posted by Checkmate187
First (and hopefully last) time I get really personal on this site.....
awesome, I would pay real money if you would shut up.
I'd pay money for them to continue...
First (and hopefully last) time I get really personal on this site.....
awesome, I would pay real money if you would shut up.
I'd pay money for them to continue...
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
It doesn't mater one iota whether *you* see anything in that statement that would be trouble. You have absolutely no say in a disciplinary hearing. I am telling you that this is how this rule is construed. Like it or not, that is not my problem. Call your state Supreme Court if you want it changed.
First, let's both please keep this out of the new thread on cheerleaders, and both stay out of it entirely. I will if you will.
Second, the statement keeps going into membership and how the organization selects members. It really looks like if an organization doesn't discriminate against protected groups in selecting members (which GLB couldn't if it wanted to) and doesn't harass members of protected groups to make them leave, they are free and clear.
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
It doesn't mater one iota whether *you* see anything in that statement that would be trouble. You have absolutely no say in a disciplinary hearing. I am telling you that this is how this rule is construed. Like it or not, that is not my problem. Call your state Supreme Court if you want it changed.
First, let's both please keep this out of the new thread on cheerleaders, and both stay out of it entirely. I will if you will.
Second, the statement keeps going into membership and how the organization selects members. It really looks like if an organization doesn't discriminate against protected groups in selecting members (which GLB couldn't if it wanted to) and doesn't harass members of protected groups to make them leave, they are free and clear.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by somecut8
Originally posted by Checkmate187
First (and hopefully last) time I get really personal on this site.....
awesome, I would pay real money if you would shut up.
I'd pay money for them to continue...
I'm glad that at least someone's getting some entertainment value from this....
Originally posted by Checkmate187
First (and hopefully last) time I get really personal on this site.....
awesome, I would pay real money if you would shut up.
I'd pay money for them to continue...
I'm glad that at least someone's getting some entertainment value from this....
keedon
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by somecut8
Originally posted by Checkmate187
First (and hopefully last) time I get really personal on this site.....
awesome, I would pay real money if you would shut up.
I'd pay money for them to continue...
I'm glad that at least someone's getting some entertainment value from this....
Hard to find intellectual conversation on the internet nowadays so a change of scenery is always good.
Originally posted by somecut8
Originally posted by Checkmate187
First (and hopefully last) time I get really personal on this site.....
awesome, I would pay real money if you would shut up.
I'd pay money for them to continue...
I'm glad that at least someone's getting some entertainment value from this....
Hard to find intellectual conversation on the internet nowadays so a change of scenery is always good.
awesome
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
It doesn't mater one iota whether *you* see anything in that statement that would be trouble. You have absolutely no say in a disciplinary hearing. I am telling you that this is how this rule is construed. Like it or not, that is not my problem. Call your state Supreme Court if you want it changed.
First, let's both please keep this out of the new thread on cheerleaders, and both stay out of it entirely. I will if you will.
Second, the statement keeps going into membership and how the organization selects members. It really looks like if an organization doesn't discriminate against protected groups in selecting members (which GLB couldn't if it wanted to) and doesn't harass members of protected groups to make them leave, they are free and clear.
I'm not saying that these rules are black and white. What I AM saying is that because of the extreme difficulty in becoming a lawyer and especially a judge, these people would not RISK it because there is gray area here.
The impression of impropriety is ENOUGH for disciplinary action.
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
It doesn't mater one iota whether *you* see anything in that statement that would be trouble. You have absolutely no say in a disciplinary hearing. I am telling you that this is how this rule is construed. Like it or not, that is not my problem. Call your state Supreme Court if you want it changed.
First, let's both please keep this out of the new thread on cheerleaders, and both stay out of it entirely. I will if you will.
Second, the statement keeps going into membership and how the organization selects members. It really looks like if an organization doesn't discriminate against protected groups in selecting members (which GLB couldn't if it wanted to) and doesn't harass members of protected groups to make them leave, they are free and clear.
I'm not saying that these rules are black and white. What I AM saying is that because of the extreme difficulty in becoming a lawyer and especially a judge, these people would not RISK it because there is gray area here.
The impression of impropriety is ENOUGH for disciplinary action.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
It doesn't mater one iota whether *you* see anything in that statement that would be trouble. You have absolutely no say in a disciplinary hearing. I am telling you that this is how this rule is construed. Like it or not, that is not my problem. Call your state Supreme Court if you want it changed.
First, let's both please keep this out of the new thread on cheerleaders, and both stay out of it entirely. I will if you will.
Second, the statement keeps going into membership and how the organization selects members. It really looks like if an organization doesn't discriminate against protected groups in selecting members (which GLB couldn't if it wanted to) and doesn't harass members of protected groups to make them leave, they are free and clear.
I'm not saying that these rules are black and white. What I AM saying is that because of the extreme difficulty in becoming a lawyer and especially a judge, these people would not RISK it because there is gray area here.
The impression of impropriety is ENOUGH for disciplinary action.
I disagree that there's any gray area, but am willing to end our discussion on it agreeing to disagree.
I really did read what you posted thoroughly, and even if trying to be completely neutral and impartial in interpreting it, I couldn't find any basis for interpreting it against one who participates in the site with cheerleader characters.
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by awesome
Whether an organization practices invidious discrimination is often a complex question to which judges should be sensitive. The answer cannot be determined from a mere examination of an organization’s current membership rolls but rather depends on how the organization selects members and other relevant factors, such as that the organization is dedicated to the preservation of religious, ethnic or cultural values of legitimate common interest to its members, or that it is in fact and effect an intimate, purely private organization whose membership limitations could not be constitutionally prohibited. Absent such factors, an organization is generally said to discriminate invidiously if it arbitrarily excludes from membership on the basis of race, religion, sex or national origin persons who would otherwise be admitted to membership.
This is another one of those TERMS OF ART.
By the way, the other thread was locked by request of one of the supporters of playable cheerleaders, who's ready to give up the fight.
I decided a while back that it would never happen, but I still hate the principle you seem to be supporting.
I don't see anything in that statement that would be of trouble if there were playable cheerleaders.
It basically has to either discriminate or back discrimination. You're interpreting that as broadly as one could conceivably interpret it. I hope you aren't, actually, a judge, as I wouldn't want you making important decisions.
I hope I finished this in time before this thread is locked.
It doesn't mater one iota whether *you* see anything in that statement that would be trouble. You have absolutely no say in a disciplinary hearing. I am telling you that this is how this rule is construed. Like it or not, that is not my problem. Call your state Supreme Court if you want it changed.
First, let's both please keep this out of the new thread on cheerleaders, and both stay out of it entirely. I will if you will.
Second, the statement keeps going into membership and how the organization selects members. It really looks like if an organization doesn't discriminate against protected groups in selecting members (which GLB couldn't if it wanted to) and doesn't harass members of protected groups to make them leave, they are free and clear.
I'm not saying that these rules are black and white. What I AM saying is that because of the extreme difficulty in becoming a lawyer and especially a judge, these people would not RISK it because there is gray area here.
The impression of impropriety is ENOUGH for disciplinary action.
I disagree that there's any gray area, but am willing to end our discussion on it agreeing to disagree.
I really did read what you posted thoroughly, and even if trying to be completely neutral and impartial in interpreting it, I couldn't find any basis for interpreting it against one who participates in the site with cheerleader characters.
awesome
offline
offline
"I really did read what you posted thoroughly, and even if trying to be completely neutral and impartial in interpreting it, I couldn't find any basis for interpreting it against one who participates in the site with cheerleader characters."
Well, again, it is infuriating that you cannot even follow a simple conversation. That rule was posted in RESPONSE to your examples of judges who were members of fraternities.
In response to the current topic:
"A. A judge shall respect and comply with the law* and shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary.
Commentary:
Public confidence in the judiciary is eroded by irresponsible or improper conduct by judges. A judge must avoid all impropriety and appearance of impropriety. A judge must expect to be the subject of constant public scrutiny. A judge must therefore accept restrictions on the judge’s conduct that might be viewed as burdensome by the ordinary citizen and should do so freely and willingly. Examples are the restrictions on judicial speech imposed by Sections 3(B)(9) and (10) that are indispensable to the maintenance of the integrity, impartiality, and independence of the judiciary.
The prohibition against behaving with impropriety or the appearance of impropriety applies to both the professional and personal conduct of a judge. Because it is not practicable to list all prohibited acts, the proscription is necessarily cast in general terms that extend to conduct by judges that is harmful although not specifically mentioned in the Code. Actual improprieties under this standard include violations of law, court rules or other specific provisions of this Code. The test for appearance of impropriety is whether the conduct would create in reasonable minds a perception that the judge’s ability to carry out judicial responsibilities with integrity, impartiality and competence is impaired. See also Commentary under Section 2C."
Well, again, it is infuriating that you cannot even follow a simple conversation. That rule was posted in RESPONSE to your examples of judges who were members of fraternities.
In response to the current topic:
"A. A judge shall respect and comply with the law* and shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary.
Commentary:
Public confidence in the judiciary is eroded by irresponsible or improper conduct by judges. A judge must avoid all impropriety and appearance of impropriety. A judge must expect to be the subject of constant public scrutiny. A judge must therefore accept restrictions on the judge’s conduct that might be viewed as burdensome by the ordinary citizen and should do so freely and willingly. Examples are the restrictions on judicial speech imposed by Sections 3(B)(9) and (10) that are indispensable to the maintenance of the integrity, impartiality, and independence of the judiciary.
The prohibition against behaving with impropriety or the appearance of impropriety applies to both the professional and personal conduct of a judge. Because it is not practicable to list all prohibited acts, the proscription is necessarily cast in general terms that extend to conduct by judges that is harmful although not specifically mentioned in the Code. Actual improprieties under this standard include violations of law, court rules or other specific provisions of this Code. The test for appearance of impropriety is whether the conduct would create in reasonable minds a perception that the judge’s ability to carry out judicial responsibilities with integrity, impartiality and competence is impaired. See also Commentary under Section 2C."
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Awesome
Public confidence in the judiciary is eroded by irresponsible or improper conduct by judges. A judge must avoid all impropriety and appearance of impropriety. A judge must expect to be the subject of constant public scrutiny. A judge must therefore accept restrictions on the judge’s conduct that might be viewed as burdensome by the ordinary citizen and should do so freely and willingly.
I'm not a judge and thus I need not accept restrictions that as an ordinary citizen I would view as burdensome freely and willingly.
Hence, I am unwilling to back any standard as to what might be allowed on this site to be limited in such a manner.
Public confidence in the judiciary is eroded by irresponsible or improper conduct by judges. A judge must avoid all impropriety and appearance of impropriety. A judge must expect to be the subject of constant public scrutiny. A judge must therefore accept restrictions on the judge’s conduct that might be viewed as burdensome by the ordinary citizen and should do so freely and willingly.
I'm not a judge and thus I need not accept restrictions that as an ordinary citizen I would view as burdensome freely and willingly.
Hence, I am unwilling to back any standard as to what might be allowed on this site to be limited in such a manner.
awesome
offline
offline
Well, unfortunately, it is not up to you as to whom the administrators want to prevent from using their site.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























