User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > True Impact Players, Level Cap Exception
Page:
 
-boz-
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
The cap's there so everybody in the league has as level a playing field as possible and was implemented to prevent over-leveled people from being introduced into a league and unbalancing it; this basically just says "Re-unbalance it because I have some good players that want to join my team and I should be able to bring them in to give me an advantage, but to 'balance' that out I'll allow every other owner the possibility to sign or trade for any one of the 0 level 20+ players in the game that would consider joining a level-capped, lowest-tier league so they could be buried with 'wow what a cheater' accusations every day they're in the league".


ah yes, lets call it a tie, because losing isnt fun for anyone.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
In addition, I doubt that many top-level players would shoot down in the league just to pump up their stats. As in the NFL, many players will move to a team for a ring for less money, but very few would move to a worse team to be the stars. They may do it for the money, but, teams in lower leagues would have less money to spend on acquiring unbelievably over-leveled players.

Your doubt shows how uneducated you are on the topic.

The only reason level caps were implemented was because ENTIRE TEAMS of high-level players were doing anything they could to move into new and lower-tier leagues. A South America AAA team tried to move into Africa AA twice just this past offseason, and there were at least two other instances of established teams colluding their way into African leagues. The only leagues that have never had this issue are Pro leagues & the new Western Europes with level caps.

Level caps are working exactly as intended.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Hey, chief, the level caps would still exist, EXCEPT for 3 players per team. The balance would be there. I am not against a level cap at all. I just think this would add some interest to scouting and team management.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
What do the day-time trollers think of this idea?
 
bluprintkok
offline
Link
 
i like this also, especially if its limited to 2 or 3 guys. Adds some more depth to the overall framework of gathering a team.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Hey, chief, the level caps would still exist, EXCEPT for 3 players per team. The balance would be there. I am not against a level cap at all. I just think this would add some interest to scouting and team management.
actually the "chief" is right. it's not just for stats either. in the lower levels they have the stamina to get max XP every time out, whereas at higher and higher levels max XP is harder to attain, especially for glamour positions.

oh and as agents, we want our player to be the best he/she can be. for a lot of those agents, that comes at the expense of whatever team he/she plays for. it's fun to win 315 to 0, like that one team did on the GLB forums (where they found out the max score is 255).
 
Link
 
It defeats the whole purpose of a cap. The cap is there for a reason. If you have a higher leveled player go look somewhere else. You don't need to be moving into a league with a bunch of lvl 10s. Try finding a team in on of the established leagues. It's just gonna make it harder for established teams looking for FAs because they are gonna have a bunch of high levels guys wanting to go PWN n00bs. Now, maybe if you had it so that the cap is 13 and you can have 3 players up to lvl 15. That wouldn't be as bad. However, lvl 20 players don't need to be coming into the new leagues. It unbalances the leagues that are already there like USA Pro, the AAAs, AAs, etc. The idea is to give lower level players a place to play so they can play gainst similar leveled players, not lvl 20 players(whether that's 3 of them or a team of them).
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Good point. I guess the modification to XP for playing against weaker teams would need to be implemented. This way, a player would really have to think about moving down in leagues.

And I respect what the chief has to say when he is on the forum boards. I just think he missed my point on this one. That may have been my fault. A whole team would not be able to move. Just 3 players per team. Okay, it would be done more than I imagined, but every team would have this option. That's all I'm saying.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by palmer_garnett_95
It defeats the whole purpose of a cap. The cap is there for a reason. If you have a higher leveled player go look somewhere else. You don't need to be moving into a league with a bunch of lvl 10s. Try finding a team in on of the established leagues. It's just gonna make it harder for established teams looking for FAs because they are gonna have a bunch of high levels guys wanting to go PWN n00bs. Now, maybe if you had it so that the cap is 13 and you can have 3 players up to lvl 15. That wouldn't be as bad. However, lvl 20 players don't need to be coming into the new leagues. It unbalances the leagues that are already there like USA Pro, the AAAs, AAs, etc. The idea is to give lower level players a place to play so they can play gainst similar leveled players, not lvl 20 players(whether that's 3 of them or a team of them).


I agree. There should be, as Bort puts it, "wiggle room." Maybe 3 players 5 levels over the maximum. The numbers are essentially arbitrary. I just though it was a good idea to add strategy to building a team...aside from assembling the best level 10 players available.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Hey, chief, the level caps would still exist, EXCEPT for 3 players per team. The balance would be there. I am not against a level cap at all. I just think this would add some interest to scouting and team management.


No, actually, you ARE against a level cap. The POINT of these leagues is that everyone is potentially equal. Not "kind of equal" unless you are lined up against their franchise player 10 levels higher than you, but equal. Right now it is a battle of tactics and scouting and builds rather than levels and ringers.

Nor does it really add any depth. You gonna bring in a level 24 kicker? Not hardly. You are bringing in a level 24 HB, WR, and maybe DE or DT. And everyone else is as well.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by palmer_garnett_95

It defeats the whole purpose of a cap. The cap is there for a reason. If you have a higher leveled player go look somewhere else. You don't need to be moving into a league with a bunch of lvl 10s. Try finding a team in on of the established leagues. It's just gonna make it harder for established teams looking for FAs because they are gonna have a bunch of high levels guys wanting to go PWN n00bs. Now, maybe if you had it so that the cap is 13 and you can have 3 players up to lvl 15. That wouldn't be as bad. However, lvl 20 players don't need to be coming into the new leagues. It unbalances the leagues that are already there like USA Pro, the AAAs, AAs, etc. The idea is to give lower level players a place to play so they can play gainst similar leveled players, not lvl 20 players(whether that's 3 of them or a team of them).


I agree. There should be, as Bort puts it, "wiggle room." Maybe 3 players 5 levels over the maximum. The numbers are essentially arbitrary. I just though it was a good idea to add strategy to building a team...aside from assembling the best level 10 players available.


Your strategy is to build your team by studying player builds and tactics. What you are proposing actually eliminates that. The strategy will again be levels.

 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SmithersOT
Originally posted by kretchfoop

Originally posted by palmer_garnett_95


It defeats the whole purpose of a cap. The cap is there for a reason. If you have a higher leveled player go look somewhere else. You don't need to be moving into a league with a bunch of lvl 10s. Try finding a team in on of the established leagues. It's just gonna make it harder for established teams looking for FAs because they are gonna have a bunch of high levels guys wanting to go PWN n00bs. Now, maybe if you had it so that the cap is 13 and you can have 3 players up to lvl 15. That wouldn't be as bad. However, lvl 20 players don't need to be coming into the new leagues. It unbalances the leagues that are already there like USA Pro, the AAAs, AAs, etc. The idea is to give lower level players a place to play so they can play gainst similar leveled players, not lvl 20 players(whether that's 3 of them or a team of them).


I agree. There should be, as Bort puts it, "wiggle room." Maybe 3 players 5 levels over the maximum. The numbers are essentially arbitrary. I just though it was a good idea to add strategy to building a team...aside from assembling the best level 10 players available.


Your strategy is to build your team by studying player builds and tactics. What you are proposing actually eliminates that. The strategy will again be levels.



It will not be levels. This is only for 3 players. Top threats is meaningless right now. It would be nice if every team had the chance to pump up a certain aspect of their game so that they are known for said aspect. May people click on teams to do cursory scouting and base a lot on level, already.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
i like the idea, but there is one floating around that suggests that a team can name a captain(s) and the captain(s) will have a statistic boost.

i think that is simpler to implement and will add another strategic element to planning.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I really have not seen that idea. However, I imagine that owners would decide who is captain. Many owners have players on the team. See the problem with that?

And captains should exist, but should not play better because of their position. They should make everyone else play better.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Either way, I think this general idea to allow a few ringers or captains or whatever will add some diversity to planning and strategy. Good job OP!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.