User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #2 > Computer Rankings After Game #5
Page:
 
Craelath
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kikdadog
Originally posted by Craelath

Originally posted by kikdadog


ok, I see your point, but you must see mine to. Still I thought to myself "myself Im getting to the bottom of this" and did a little research. Anybody can see the ease of the monkeys schedule is what is throwing this off. They only played one real team and lost to them in convincing fashion. Say what you will but you know its true.


They are 100% stats. Stats are only as good as the number of games played to get them. Do you really expect expert power rankings for the NFL to be the same in week one as they are in week 16? No. This will adjust with time. Come week 16, you will know exactly where you stand statistically in your conference. You should have a relatively good idea of how you will fare in the playoffs, or why you didn't even make them.


ok for pretend just for the stats thingy then the monkeys are better then the fancyboys, but in real life they got their monkey butts handed to them


Wow, you missed my point entirely. Didn't even come close to touching on it. That's pretty impressive. Let me spell it out for you: When you play the teams the Monkeys played, and they play the teams you faced already, this will all even out. The system gets more accurate with more games played.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by kikdadog

i do get the idea of the rankings, im just saying the stats are a bit off because they do not take strength of schedule into effect, otherwise the freaking monkeys wouldnt be ranked above unbeaten teams!! And it doesnt matter if the pack boosted or not ;p


Good luck with that. I tried valiantly last season to explain to krwynn why strength of schedule matters in round robin schedules before all of the teams have played each other. He refused to accept this, despite it being common sense when comparing two teams that have no (or few) common opponents.

At the end of the regular season, strength of schedule will be irrelevant. Until then, their just computer generated rankings. Your place on them doesn't really mean anything.


And you could not find ONE source to back that up. Find just one source to back that up. Just one. Just because you say it doesn't make it so, no matter how hard you try. Every site you look up you'll find that they all say that there is no such thing as strength of schedule with round robin schedules. Period. I gave you source after source after source, and you could and can't provide 1. Because there is no such thing. Win percentage is the only measure. The only reason strength of schedule exists is/was for College Sports rankings.

Last edited Jun 22, 2008 22:16:35
 
Ryiotgear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by RunningMn9

Originally posted by kikdadog


i do get the idea of the rankings, im just saying the stats are a bit off because they do not take strength of schedule into effect, otherwise the freaking monkeys wouldnt be ranked above unbeaten teams!! And it doesnt matter if the pack boosted or not ;p


Good luck with that. I tried valiantly last season to explain to krwynn why strength of schedule matters in round robin schedules before all of the teams have played each other. He refused to accept this, despite it being common sense when comparing two teams that have no (or few) common opponents.

At the end of the regular season, strength of schedule will be irrelevant. Until then, their just computer generated rankings. Your place on them doesn't really mean anything.


And you could not find ONE source to back that up.


I enjoy the rankings and think it is kind of pointless for everyone to worry too much about them being perfect - he laid out the system he is using and that is what the results will show.

I think to say SOS doesn't matter is incorrect though. The rankings are based upon descriptive statistics of games played to date. The rankings can therefore only describe what has happened to this point. At this time we have not played a round-robin schedule, so the stats and rankings are not based upon a round robin format.

Besides the 1 cross-conference matchup we will eventually come very close to a round-robin schedule, but right now the schedule is pretty far from that so we can't rely on the round robin format making SOS negligible until we have truly played out the format. Once week 16 rolls around I think it would be accurate to say SOS has very little bearing on your rankings.
 
snowmonkey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by snowmonkey

Originally posted by krwynn


Originally posted by kikdadog



you post them I'll read them, but it is a little strange, they do have a loss,so they cant be 2, no matter how hard you wish , so's I still say there borked this week.


Rankings have no personal opinion associated with them. 100% stats.


just curious where our defense ranks with three consecutive shut outs. tia.


10th. Mostly because you don't recover fumbles(22nd) and PD's(21st) are really low.


does the fact that your defense is on the field for 20% more plays than ours skew your numbers any? I would think plays/game should factor into the other stats. suddenly our #s shoot way up.
 
snowmonkey
offline
Link
 
the average # of plays a defense is on the field is 94.4/game
 
Craelath
offline
Link
 
On an unrelated note, Krwynn, do you take bribes? If so, how much to make the #1 spot for the rest of the season?
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by snowmonkey

does the fact that your defense is on the field for 20% more plays than ours skew your numbers any? I would think plays/game should factor into the other stats. suddenly our #s shoot way up.


We have kicked off 32 more times than you. Besides us having 483 plays and 20 points given up vs 400 plays and giving up 42 points doesn't help your argument.
Last edited Jun 22, 2008 22:29:17
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by snowmonkey
the average # of plays a defense is on the field is 94.4/game


Unless you're scoring 18 points more per game than everyone else.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ryiotgear

I enjoy the rankings and think it is kind of pointless for everyone to worry too much about them being perfect - he laid out the system he is using and that is what the results will show.

I think to say SOS doesn't matter is incorrect though. The rankings are based upon descriptive statistics of games played to date. The rankings can therefore only describe what has happened to this point. At this time we have not played a round-robin schedule, so the stats and rankings are not based upon a round robin format.

Besides the 1 cross-conference matchup we will eventually come very close to a round-robin schedule, but right now the schedule is pretty far from that so we can't rely on the round robin format making SOS negligible until we have truly played out the format. Once week 16 rolls around I think it would be accurate to say SOS has very little bearing on your rankings.


How about this, when someone can provide an SOS, a true SOS, which would be based on LAST season...nevermind. It's irrelevant. SOS just plainly, simply, does not factor in. Does anyone really think the monkeys will be easier to beat because they've lost a game? And you have other factors, boosting, player's coming on a team, players leaving. To even think you could arrive at an SOS is preposterous. Besides after today I'll more than likely keep them in house. I feel like I have to defend myself for posting stats. lol. I quit doing things like that for no $$ years ago.
Last edited Jun 22, 2008 22:48:52
 
snowmonkey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by snowmonkey


does the fact that your defense is on the field for 20% more plays than ours skew your numbers any? I would think plays/game should factor into the other stats. suddenly our #s shoot way up.


We have kicked off 32 more times than you. Besides us having 483 plays and 20 points given up vs 400 plays and giving up 42 points doesn't help your argument.


there. you've completely and utterly destroyed my argument.
 
snowmonkey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Ryiotgear


I enjoy the rankings and think it is kind of pointless for everyone to worry too much about them being perfect - he laid out the system he is using and that is what the results will show.

I think to say SOS doesn't matter is incorrect though. The rankings are based upon descriptive statistics of games played to date. The rankings can therefore only describe what has happened to this point. At this time we have not played a round-robin schedule, so the stats and rankings are not based upon a round robin format.

Besides the 1 cross-conference matchup we will eventually come very close to a round-robin schedule, but right now the schedule is pretty far from that so we can't rely on the round robin format making SOS negligible until we have truly played out the format. Once week 16 rolls around I think it would be accurate to say SOS has very little bearing on your rankings.


How about this, when someone can provide an SOS, a true SOS, which would be based on LAST season...nevermind. It's irrelevant. SOS just plainly, simply, does not factor in. Does anyone really think the monkeys will be easier to beat because they've lost a game? And you have other factors, boosting, player's coming on a team, players leaving. To even think you could arrive at an SOS is preposterous. Besides after today I'll more than likely keep them in house. I feel like I have to defend myself for posting stats. lol. I quit doing things like that for no $$ years ago.


nice attitude. take your ball and go home. I think my point about plays/game is a valid one. the only one taking this personally is you.
 
Craelath
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Ryiotgear


I enjoy the rankings and think it is kind of pointless for everyone to worry too much about them being perfect - he laid out the system he is using and that is what the results will show.

I think to say SOS doesn't matter is incorrect though. The rankings are based upon descriptive statistics of games played to date. The rankings can therefore only describe what has happened to this point. At this time we have not played a round-robin schedule, so the stats and rankings are not based upon a round robin format.

Besides the 1 cross-conference matchup we will eventually come very close to a round-robin schedule, but right now the schedule is pretty far from that so we can't rely on the round robin format making SOS negligible until we have truly played out the format. Once week 16 rolls around I think it would be accurate to say SOS has very little bearing on your rankings.


How about this, when someone can provide an SOS, a true SOS, which would be based on LAST season...nevermind. It's irrelevant. SOS just plainly, simply, does not factor in. Does anyone really think the monkeys will be easier to beat because they've lost a game? And you have other factors, boosting, player's coming on a team, players leaving. To even think you could arrive at an SOS is preposterous. Besides after today I'll more than likely keep them in house. I feel like I have to defend myself for posting stats. lol. I quit doing things like that for no $$ years ago.


That's a shame. I've been watching the couple you've posted and, like I said, it looks like it could be quite a valuable tool. It starts off rather sketchy, but that's due to limited data which you have no control over, but like I said, it gets infinitely more accurate when more data is accumulated.
 
Craelath
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by snowmonkey
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by snowmonkey


Originally posted by krwynn



Originally posted by kikdadog




you post them I'll read them, but it is a little strange, they do have a loss,so they cant be 2, no matter how hard you wish , so's I still say there borked this week.


Rankings have no personal opinion associated with them. 100% stats.


just curious where our defense ranks with three consecutive shut outs. tia.


10th. Mostly because you don't recover fumbles(22nd) and PD's(21st) are really low.


does the fact that your defense is on the field for 20% more plays than ours skew your numbers any? I would think plays/game should factor into the other stats. suddenly our #s shoot way up.


I don't see how this is relevant, since that would put your offense on the field more than his and should balance out on the other side. And again, with more data comes a more accurate ranking. Far as the "take your ball and go home" comment, thanks. Someone put hard work into this, you question it at every turn, never knowing the system so clearly not providing constructive criticism, and then expect the guy to just take it? I'd bail on this, too.
 
Eli Blanton
offline
Link
 
Just take it for what it is.

I enjoy looking at them Krwynn. Thanks for taking the time to generate it.
 
@ftermath
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Craelath
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by Ryiotgear



I enjoy the rankings and think it is kind of pointless for everyone to worry too much about them being perfect - he laid out the system he is using and that is what the results will show.

I think to say SOS doesn't matter is incorrect though. The rankings are based upon descriptive statistics of games played to date. The rankings can therefore only describe what has happened to this point. At this time we have not played a round-robin schedule, so the stats and rankings are not based upon a round robin format.

Besides the 1 cross-conference matchup we will eventually come very close to a round-robin schedule, but right now the schedule is pretty far from that so we can't rely on the round robin format making SOS negligible until we have truly played out the format. Once week 16 rolls around I think it would be accurate to say SOS has very little bearing on your rankings.


How about this, when someone can provide an SOS, a true SOS, which would be based on LAST season...nevermind. It's irrelevant. SOS just plainly, simply, does not factor in. Does anyone really think the monkeys will be easier to beat because they've lost a game? And you have other factors, boosting, player's coming on a team, players leaving. To even think you could arrive at an SOS is preposterous. Besides after today I'll more than likely keep them in house. I feel like I have to defend myself for posting stats. lol. I quit doing things like that for no $$ years ago.


That's a shame. I've been watching the couple you've posted and, like I said, it looks like it could be quite a valuable tool. It starts off rather sketchy, but that's due to limited data which you have no control over, but like I said, it gets infinitely more accurate when more data is accumulated.



Well if he added a human voting portion to offset the skewed data and portions of the game that a computer can't simulate he may have something. Wait, someone already does that. Ah yes it's the BCS and it doesn't work.

Anyway, it's one guy putting some time into something that can be fun if you enjoy this sort of thing and ignored if you don't. It's a bit like a certain appreciation thread that I refuse to even look at because I think it's ridiculous. But that's my opinion so I just stay away.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.