User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > SS decides not to kill the HB - NOT A BUG - CLOSED - #465
Page:
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
But he changes the angle way too much. He should have changed direction about 1/2 as much as he did, and at the very least should have tried to attack the outside should of the HB rather than the inside.

But the FB would have kicked him out and the HB try to run between the SS and the DE.


Had the FB kicked him out it would have worked correctly, he still should have stayed outside and moved laterally, not turn around and to behind the los
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1525473&pbp_id=4191295
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1525473&pbp_id=4192656

SS is set to blitz, looks to me like he has a clean shot at the HB and changes his path to meet him at the los instead of behind it.

Prob not a bug, but looks wrong

edit: for the record, the play is Strong I HB off tackle
http://goallineblitz.com/images/plays/52.gif


he changes his angle rather then run free into an empty backfield.

just becuz the play is designed to run off tackle doesnt mean the RB can't cut back.
which is what he does. which is why the SS changes angles. then he gets blocked.
pretty simple stuff.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
he changes his angle rather then run free into an empty backfield.

just becuz the play is designed to run off tackle doesnt mean the RB can't cut back.
which is what he does. which is why the SS changes angles. then he gets blocked.
pretty simple stuff.


Okay so your experience on a football field is either water boy or kicker, either way, you're missing the point of both lack of containment and attacking the hb in the wrong direction.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
he changes his angle rather then run free into an empty backfield.

just becuz the play is designed to run off tackle doesnt mean the RB can't cut back.
which is what he does. which is why the SS changes angles. then he gets blocked.
pretty simple stuff.


Even at that he changes his angle way too much. Throwing football logic out the window (which would be his job is to make the HB cut back) and going with GLB logic, he should have cut and taken an angle that went behind the ROT toward the C. Basically, changed angle and gone parallel with the LOS. Instead he cut over the top of the ROT and went way too far inside.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
i see the SS stay on the outside. the RB is going straight up the middle.
then when the SS makes his move to the outside, the SS can't cut back as fast.
it looks like the issue is only that the RB has better agility than the SS does.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Even at that he changes his angle way too much. Throwing football logic out the window (which would be his job is to make the HB cut back) and going with GLB logic, he should have cut and taken an angle that went behind the ROT toward the C. Basically, changed angle and gone parallel with the LOS. Instead he cut over the top of the ROT and went way too far inside.


but, then he will run directly into the LT.
which would screen him. but of course the RB can run thru the LT like he's not there.
i think thats the real problem.
 
MC_Hammer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
i see the SS stay on the outside. the RB is going straight up the middle.
then when the SS makes his move to the outside, the SS can't cut back as fast.
it looks like the issue is only that the RB has better agility than the SS does.


Knowing these 2 teams pretty well, I highly doubt that, but I suppose there is like a 2% chance.
It's still pathing issues imo.
Edited by MC_Hammer on Jan 24, 2011 21:51:22
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
. Originally posted by darncat
i see the SS stay on the outside. the RB is going straight up the middle.
then when the SS makes his move to the outside, the SS can't cut back as fast.
it looks like the issue is only that the RB has better agility than the SS does.


Both ss' have 84 agility and 10 and 6 in change direction respectively. Judging by the hb's lolbars and total sp value I would say he has 83 natural speed and 78 natural agility.

edit: thanks mc
Edited by bug03 on Jan 24, 2011 21:54:37
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1525561&pbp_id=2952257

This is the same Defensive play against the same offensive formation but a different play call.
The SS does exactly what we are describing here, going horizontally to maintain his contain.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
but, the HB doesnt cut back as soon as he gets the hand off
in the first replays he cuts up the middle right away (then cuts back towards tackle)
here, he goes towards off tackle until he cuts back to the middle.
he does the opposite so i'd expect a different reaction.

it does look like the SS is being over aggressive in the ORs,
but that does happen sometimes on the football field...
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
This is not a bug though. Just bad football logic coded into the SIM. Probably making a suggestion is better way to go. Really if there is a "bug" in the original replay it is the FB not blocking the SS.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
This is not a bug though. Just bad football logic coded into the SIM. Probably making a suggestion is better way to go. Really if there is a "bug" in the original replay it is the FB not blocking the SS.


If the FB blocks the SS, the MLB goes unblocked and makes the play. That would be the reason why you blitz the SS in that situation.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
I don't think its a bug either, but by posting it here we can discuss what went wrong to suggest a fix. I think it is the play itself and not the coding.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
If the FB blocks the SS, the MLB goes unblocked and makes the play. That would be the reason why you blitz the SS in that situation.


Maybe he does, but that becomes a build issue, and depends on the MLB being fast enough to get there, and having the attributes to make the tackle.

What should happen is FB kick out SS. WR try to block CB. HB run between ROT blocking DE and FB kicking out SS, and try to cut outside the WR blocking the CB.

MLB would then have to make the play on the HB before he gets to the hole and cuts outside, or the CB playing deep zone would have to try and make the tackle once the HB got to the outside.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Maybe he does, but that becomes a build issue, and depends on the MLB being fast enough to get there, and having the attributes to make the tackle.

What should happen is FB kick out SS. WR try to block CB. HB run between ROT blocking DE and FB kicking out SS, and try to cut outside the WR blocking the CB.

MLB would then have to make the play on the HB before he gets to the hole and cuts outside, or the CB playing deep zone would have to try and make the tackle once the HB got to the outside.


Sounds like a pretty good running play to me
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.