well just pm me and I will help you with whatever you want.
Forum > Southeast Asia AAA Leagues > Southeast Asia AAA #2 > Pro Bowl/MVP ideas for this season here
Raider Nation
offline
offline
If you go with one player per team, and have the teams nominate players, you could limit the nominations to like 3 or 4 player per team. May not be totally fair to all teams, but would be reasonably fair. Did any team have more than 3 last year? I'm sure they did.
Coach_Schaar
offline
offline
Heres what I suggested last season and it makes it easier for coaches to scout a few players instead of every single person on all the teams throughout the league.
I think that Coaches should nominate players from their team. Lets say there top 5 players. Then a ballot is put together with these names and the players vote off the ballot.
I think that Coaches should nominate players from their team. Lets say there top 5 players. Then a ballot is put together with these names and the players vote off the ballot.
GBeer
offline
offline
Originally posted by coach_schaar
Maybe 5 Offensive and 5 Defensive players from each team.
That's not a bad idea at all. It will certainly make it easier.
Maybe 5 Offensive and 5 Defensive players from each team.
That's not a bad idea at all. It will certainly make it easier.
boomer82
offline
offline
Originally posted by coach_schaar
Maybe 5 Offensive and 5 Defensive players from each team.
You'll have to exclude the playoffs if you want to include Tire Fire players!
Sweep the ARRRRGGGGHHHH!!!!!
Maybe 5 Offensive and 5 Defensive players from each team.
You'll have to exclude the playoffs if you want to include Tire Fire players!
Sweep the ARRRRGGGGHHHH!!!!!
Raider Nation
offline
offline
Originally posted by coach_schaar
Maybe 5 Offensive and 5 Defensive players from each team.
I think this idea is probably the best Idea, but I may limit it to like 8 players per team. Ten seems like a lot.
Maybe 5 Offensive and 5 Defensive players from each team.
I think this idea is probably the best Idea, but I may limit it to like 8 players per team. Ten seems like a lot.
damngooddawg23
offline
offline
Originally posted by Raider Nation
Originally posted by coach_schaar
Maybe 5 Offensive and 5 Defensive players from each team.
I think this idea is probably the best Idea, but I may limit it to like 8 players per team. Ten seems like a lot.
I agree. I think 8 should be the cap too. Should we have atleast one from every team like MLB, or just have the best players no matter what team?
Originally posted by coach_schaar
Maybe 5 Offensive and 5 Defensive players from each team.
I think this idea is probably the best Idea, but I may limit it to like 8 players per team. Ten seems like a lot.
I agree. I think 8 should be the cap too. Should we have atleast one from every team like MLB, or just have the best players no matter what team?
TaintStick
offline
offline
I liked the way it worked last year. I thought it was good exposure for each team to have to go pick OTHER teams players not their own. Plus we had a great thread going to promote your own players for the Pro-Bowl voting. I know some have said it is alot of work, but heck, I think everyone here scouts teams, reads the power rankings, or at least watches there team games play-by-play so I think we all have a good feeling for who the best players are(besides the ones on our own teams). Just my opinion...I'm probably wrong.
Either way, I would like to see Owner/GM added to the Pro-Bowl balloting as well, as we have had some teams in Zeta that have improved tremendously from last year, and should be recognized.
Either way, I would like to see Owner/GM added to the Pro-Bowl balloting as well, as we have had some teams in Zeta that have improved tremendously from last year, and should be recognized.
aeakers
offline
offline
What I did not like last year is there was a huge bias towards stat machines. A cornerback who shuts down his guy and never gets thrown at but gets only a few tackles a game, and just a few picks on the season has no chance.
I really like the idea of owners nominating 4 guys on each side of the ball. This helps voters be able to do research and without investing a lot of time.
I dont think every team deserves to be recognized, although it was disappointing last year to have two playoff teams without representation.
As far as who votes, I think maybe something like owners get a vote plus each team can nominate two players/GMs to vote as well.
I could make a web based poll/web form to help automate the process if that is something that sounds good to you guys.
I really like the idea of owners nominating 4 guys on each side of the ball. This helps voters be able to do research and without investing a lot of time.
I dont think every team deserves to be recognized, although it was disappointing last year to have two playoff teams without representation.
As far as who votes, I think maybe something like owners get a vote plus each team can nominate two players/GMs to vote as well.
I could make a web based poll/web form to help automate the process if that is something that sounds good to you guys.
TaintStick
offline
offline
Originally posted by aeakers
What I did not like last year is there was a huge bias towards stat machines. A cornerback who shuts down his guy and never gets thrown at but gets only a few tackles a game, and just a few picks on the season has no chance.
I really like the idea of owners nominating 4 guys on each side of the ball. This helps voters be able to do research and without investing a lot of time.
I dont think every team deserves to be recognized, although it was disappointing last year to have two playoff teams without representation.
As far as who votes, I think maybe something like owners get a vote plus each team can nominate two players/GMs to vote as well.
I could make a web based poll/web form to help automate the process if that is something that sounds good to you guys.
I like the web based polling, that would be sweet! And our team LSP was a playoff team that was not represented in the pro-bowl last year, so i feel your pain. But even with nominating 4 players, voting by all will still be required, so if people are voting for stat machines only, they are going to do that regardless. I think we have one of the better conferences in GLB, and most of the owners/GMs are smart enough to know when someone is just padding stats...besides, everyone get's to pad their stats against the same teams
I guess in the end, I could go either way, I just like the fact that by making people vote for other players, it gives our conference more exposure in general, and forces people to stop focusing on their team only.
What I did not like last year is there was a huge bias towards stat machines. A cornerback who shuts down his guy and never gets thrown at but gets only a few tackles a game, and just a few picks on the season has no chance.
I really like the idea of owners nominating 4 guys on each side of the ball. This helps voters be able to do research and without investing a lot of time.
I dont think every team deserves to be recognized, although it was disappointing last year to have two playoff teams without representation.
As far as who votes, I think maybe something like owners get a vote plus each team can nominate two players/GMs to vote as well.
I could make a web based poll/web form to help automate the process if that is something that sounds good to you guys.
I like the web based polling, that would be sweet! And our team LSP was a playoff team that was not represented in the pro-bowl last year, so i feel your pain. But even with nominating 4 players, voting by all will still be required, so if people are voting for stat machines only, they are going to do that regardless. I think we have one of the better conferences in GLB, and most of the owners/GMs are smart enough to know when someone is just padding stats...besides, everyone get's to pad their stats against the same teams

I guess in the end, I could go either way, I just like the fact that by making people vote for other players, it gives our conference more exposure in general, and forces people to stop focusing on their team only.
Raider Nation
offline
offline
Originally posted by aeakers
What I did not like last year is there was a huge bias towards stat machines. A cornerback who shuts down his guy and never gets thrown at but gets only a few tackles a game, and just a few picks on the season has no chance.
I really like the idea of owners nominating 4 guys on each side of the ball. This helps voters be able to do research and without investing a lot of time.
I dont think every team deserves to be recognized, although it was disappointing last year to have two playoff teams without representation.
As far as who votes, I think maybe something like owners get a vote plus each team can nominate two players/GMs to vote as well.
I could make a web based poll/web form to help automate the process if that is something that sounds good to you guys.
Stats are good in some positions and not in others. CB's with a lot of tackles aren't the best CB's. An OT should be recognized for the sacks he HASN'T allowed. A LB, on the other hand, should be recognized for the no. of tackles he has, etc.
I guess there are a few ways to do it. I started the promotion thread last season so good players on bad teams could get a little attention.
Maybe not every team should get recognized, but by nominating players from each team, hopefully the good players will get some love.
What I did not like last year is there was a huge bias towards stat machines. A cornerback who shuts down his guy and never gets thrown at but gets only a few tackles a game, and just a few picks on the season has no chance.
I really like the idea of owners nominating 4 guys on each side of the ball. This helps voters be able to do research and without investing a lot of time.
I dont think every team deserves to be recognized, although it was disappointing last year to have two playoff teams without representation.
As far as who votes, I think maybe something like owners get a vote plus each team can nominate two players/GMs to vote as well.
I could make a web based poll/web form to help automate the process if that is something that sounds good to you guys.
Stats are good in some positions and not in others. CB's with a lot of tackles aren't the best CB's. An OT should be recognized for the sacks he HASN'T allowed. A LB, on the other hand, should be recognized for the no. of tackles he has, etc.
I guess there are a few ways to do it. I started the promotion thread last season so good players on bad teams could get a little attention.
Maybe not every team should get recognized, but by nominating players from each team, hopefully the good players will get some love.
Originally posted by Raider Nation
Originally posted by aeakers
What I did not like last year is there was a huge bias towards stat machines. A cornerback who shuts down his guy and never gets thrown at but gets only a few tackles a game, and just a few picks on the season has no chance.
I really like the idea of owners nominating 4 guys on each side of the ball. This helps voters be able to do research and without investing a lot of time.
I dont think every team deserves to be recognized, although it was disappointing last year to have two playoff teams without representation.
As far as who votes, I think maybe something like owners get a vote plus each team can nominate two players/GMs to vote as well.
I could make a web based poll/web form to help automate the process if that is something that sounds good to you guys.
Stats are good in some positions and not in others. CB's with a lot of tackles aren't the best CB's. An OT should be recognized for the sacks he HASN'T allowed. A LB, on the other hand, should be recognized for the no. of tackles he has, etc.
I guess there are a few ways to do it. I started the promotion thread last season so good players on bad teams could get a little attention.
Maybe not every team should get recognized, but by nominating players from each team, hopefully the good players will get some love.
yeah, i think the key, if we go with the nominating players from our own teams, is making a case with every player nominated, beyond just quoting some stats.
Originally posted by aeakers
What I did not like last year is there was a huge bias towards stat machines. A cornerback who shuts down his guy and never gets thrown at but gets only a few tackles a game, and just a few picks on the season has no chance.
I really like the idea of owners nominating 4 guys on each side of the ball. This helps voters be able to do research and without investing a lot of time.
I dont think every team deserves to be recognized, although it was disappointing last year to have two playoff teams without representation.
As far as who votes, I think maybe something like owners get a vote plus each team can nominate two players/GMs to vote as well.
I could make a web based poll/web form to help automate the process if that is something that sounds good to you guys.
Stats are good in some positions and not in others. CB's with a lot of tackles aren't the best CB's. An OT should be recognized for the sacks he HASN'T allowed. A LB, on the other hand, should be recognized for the no. of tackles he has, etc.
I guess there are a few ways to do it. I started the promotion thread last season so good players on bad teams could get a little attention.
Maybe not every team should get recognized, but by nominating players from each team, hopefully the good players will get some love.
yeah, i think the key, if we go with the nominating players from our own teams, is making a case with every player nominated, beyond just quoting some stats.
Raider Nation
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
yeah, i think the key, if we go with the nominating players from our own teams, is making a case with every player nominated, beyond just quoting some stats.
Agreed.
yeah, i think the key, if we go with the nominating players from our own teams, is making a case with every player nominated, beyond just quoting some stats.
Agreed.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























