User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > QB ran 3 times with rush setting at 0 - RESOLVED BUG #509
Page:
 
ezra_
You pick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KLKRTR
I'm just curious, but if auto-adjust is doing this, doesn't it mean that it's not working as intended?


yes, obviously

Edited by Lensar on Jan 26, 2011 11:54:59 (Admin Review)
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KLKRTR
I'm just curious, but if auto-adjust is doing this, doesn't it mean that it's not working as intended?


No, not necessarily, and it's not that it is definitely auto-adjust causing this, it's more that we can not investigate it as a bug because auto-adjust is being used. That's why the request to repost if this reoccurs without auto-adjust being used.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
The fact that auto-adjust is on prevents us from considering this a bug tbh. Auto-adjust being used allows for some leeway in play calling by the sim, even if it's something you haven't seen a pattern of.

If this continues with no auto-adjust on, repost and we'll evaluate from there.

Not likely a bug


It happens also with auto adjust set to 0. It is going on forever since casual leagues where started. Bort explained it a few times that 0% QB run doesn´t mean 0% the sim could also read it as 0,4 or 0,6% and therefore calls a QB run from time to time.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Disastermaster
It happens also with auto adjust set to 0. It is going on forever since casual leagues where started. Bort explained it a few times that 0% QB run doesn´t mean 0% the sim could also read it as 0,4 or 0,6% and therefore calls a QB run from time to time.


Then there is your answer.

Would love to have that quote from Bort though. Would come in handy down the road for me.
 
Link
 
But if you like an example for auto adjust at 0 and QB running with the ball with QB running set to 0% here is one from last season:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1380547

1 sack allowed and 3 runs for the Eivissia QB´s
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Disastermaster
It happens also with auto adjust set to 0. It is going on forever since casual leagues where started. Bort explained it a few times that 0% QB run doesn´t mean 0% the sim could also read it as 0,4 or 0,6% and therefore calls a QB run from time to time.


Seems like something is broken then.....it looks the same as:

Aug 19, 2010
- Fix package plays able to be called at 0% bias settings


It's bad enough in casual to not have control over much of anything, but to allow the sim to call plays at it's whim due to "programming" of the sim....

Now if Bort says "I'm not going to fix this" that is a different issue....but it IS a bug.

Just because it's always been this way doesn't make it correct.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
Seems like something is broken then.....it looks the same as:

Aug 19, 2010
- Fix package plays able to be called at 0% bias settings


It's bad enough in casual to not have control over much of anything, but to allow the sim to call plays at it's whim due to "programming" of the sim....

Now if Bort says "I'm not going to fix this" that is a different issue....but it IS a bug.

Just because it's always been this way doesn't make it correct.


It's not the same as the package play calling.
 
KLKRTR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Disastermaster
But if you like an example for auto adjust at 0 and QB running with the ball with QB running set to 0% here is one from last season:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1380547

1 sack allowed and 3 runs for the Eivissia QB´s


This tells me that it needs to be fixed.

Some people may say it's not a big deal, but just imagine this scenario:
You're in an evenly-matched playoff game. You don't have a rushing QB, so you set it to 0% QB runs. The sim decides that it could be 0.6% of the time, so it runs the QB. Somehow that 0.6% translates into 3 QB runs. With the FF machines some DEs have become, that's a scary thought...lose a fumble deep on your side of the field, and suddenly your team is going to lose.

No thanks. This is a bug. It's just been around for a while.
 
Savitar
Ghost Recon
offline
Link
 
It used to drive me crazy when I owned a casual team, but I've never noticed it happen on my regular team. Now if a regular team's OC uses basic settings in the advanced AI (which to me is dumb), but some do......then that might happen, IDK.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
It's not the same as the package play calling.


OK, you're right...it's not the same thing as package play calling....
In package play calling you're selecting specific plays that can be called, regardless of what position is the "runner"
In casual, setting a "position" to a 0% only makes it a low % probability.

Do you want this to be a suggestion?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4394497
 
ezra_
You pick
offline
Link
 
Edited by tuba_samurai on Nov 24, 2010 06:02:29 (No Posting PMs)
Edited by Ezbollah on Nov 24, 2010 03:35:45
Edited by Ezbollah on Nov 24, 2010 03:33:00
 
Hukton Vioxx
offline
Link
 
Noone cares about casual but this has been happening to me as well...happened in a close game yesterday on a third down play I believe...
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hukton Vioxx
Noone cares about casual but this has been happening to me as well...happened in a close game yesterday on a third down play I believe...


No one especially doesn't care about regular, aren't there enough of the regular owned team whiner threads?
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
If a play is set to 0% auto adjust should NEVER call it, that's just asinine to think it would work that way. How the fuck backwards is the play call logic if this is what is calling this?

My assumption, and how i would assume anyone coding this particular part of the sim would do it, is that auto-adjust only affects the play being called, not other plays.

Basically...

5 plays

0%
40%
50%
70%
40%

Bort has said before that this would basically curve everything down automatically, so 200% total. 0%/2 is still 0%, always 0%. 40 becomes 20, 50 becomes 25, etc. If you have under 100% say...

0%
20%
10%
5%
15%

Everything is rounded up. 0%*2 is still 0%, always 0%. 20 becomes 40, 10 becomes 20, etc.

Auto adjust should work the same way. let's say hypothetically that auto-adjust medium is a 10% bonus/penalty if a play is "good" or "bad" based on criteria that should be set out logically. 0% change for plays that are "ok" like a 3 yard run on 1st down i.e.

So, if you have 6 inputs set:

0%
20%
20%
20%
20%
20%

And play two goes bad, a 10% penalty brings it down to 18%, but with a 98% total % now, so 0%, 18.4%, 20.4%, 20.4%, 20.4%, 20.4% is roughly what the new % SHOULD be.

What it sounds like people are hypothesizing is that the logic doesn't work this way, but rather that the math may involve a more simpleton formula in the above scenario. Something like the 2% penalty from the bad play gets redistributed amongst all 6 outputs. So, 0% would become .33%, 18.33%, 20.33%, 20.33% etc. Take that over a whole game and it would be easy to see how a 0% could become something significant and get called a few times.

In conclusion, if this is how the logic behind auto-adjust is working, it IS a bug. There is no question about that. Basically, if you have something at 0%, it should never be auto-adjusted, ever.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
This thread is about casual tactics. Not about package play calling percentages and auto adjust or AI percentages and auto adjust.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.