User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > OAI Got "Stuck" and only called 1 play from each package - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Yeah this just came to mind too. Since it is possible to have plays in packages not in your current playbook, perhaps you have a gap in coverage, reverting to a basic tactic and that is the only play available. If perhaps in the playbook you have only 1-2 plays available, it has to call one of those if the Basic ai decides that should be called (which it did often on 1st downs)

In the second half you called HB Slam weak on 1st down every time except once (on a 2nd down).

In the first half It was called on various second downs and once on 1st down late in the second.

I'd check though your AI for anything special happening in the 3rd or 4th quarters on 1st down. And also check 2nd down conditions for gaps in overall or for 1st/2nd Q specific.

Ah perhaps not, since you said in your post while i was typing that you did check your playbook. But i'd still check through those AI conditions, and see what your basic tactic settings are to see if you have anything unusual, like it being set to 100% run or something.


I will. But what I really don't understand is how this has come about. I've not changed my AI since last season, just amended the outputs. In fact the AI has been in place for 4 seasons already, as has the playbook. Off to check Basic AI and every other percentage I can find on any page relating to the team now.

Edit: Ok so the ONLY input in my AI that calls anything other than a package may be the culprit however I don't see why. Its a 4th and 1 play, and checking settings it is set up as Down between 4 and 4, yards between 0 and 1. The play than calls 40% HB Blast using my elusive back and 60% HB Slam Weak using my power back. So this would account for the use of these plays if I had somehow made this the only call...however using the AI tester it is only ever called correctly and is so far down my AI tree it can't be superceding anything.

In addition to this the team that just played actually calls a package here and not specific plays, and they still had this issue. So whatever it is I don't think its this as it only exists in 1 of the two places the error has occurred.

Edited by Arayel on Nov 15, 2010 13:53:24
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Ok Basic settings are also all normal. 50/50 pass run, 60/40 inside outside, 50/50 left right.
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Ok well this is getting ridiculous.

Can I give a Bugs mod or admin access to my AI's to check this out?

In the game I was waiting for with this team http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4949 there was slightly more variation but still the distribution is so far from what I have asked for its ridiculous.

Between both my HB's (not including pitches that run from a separate package) they basically ran 4 plays all game from a possible 16. Now considering I run a maximim of 15% chance for any individual play, no auto-adjust and the packages are being called correctly (elusive calls did seem down but I need to check that out), I see no reason why the AI should focus on calling the same 4 plays over and over again.

The same package setup is working entirely as ecpected for my passing game.

And before you ask....NO I am not using Auto-Adjust. Yes I ahve selected my AI turned on - if it wasnt the packages wouldn't get called anyway. Not my basic settings are not odd, Yes my playbook contains all the plays in the entire game so Im covered there. Yes I ahve checked there are no wayward percentages. Yes the AI tester calls all packages and plays correctly. Put simply I have checked everything I know to check from my 17 seasons running offenses.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Ok, leave everything as is and I'll check it out with access tomorrow. Grant me access at anytime, but I won't be able to test until the morning sometime.

 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Ok, leave everything as is and I'll check it out with access tomorrow. Grant me access at anytime, but I won't be able to test until the morning sometime.



Access sent. We have another game in an hour or so. I've only made minor changes to certain packages. The two major culprits are still as they were last game. Will be interesting to see if they perform the same two games in a row.
 
Red Sox
offline
Link
 
Anyway a mod/admin can see this AI?
 
Red Sox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by redsoxboy34
Anyway a mod/admin can see this AI?


never mind, late on the convo
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Have now sent access for the Iron-Men and the Monks who have just played twice. Is it a regular occurrance for all teams that specific plays just rise to the top? I find it incredible that certain plays seem to always be at the top even though they are only called 5% more than plays that get maybe a single call per game.

It feels like Auto-Adjust is stuck on in the background, or at least this is how I would imagine a game would look...the only problme, in some cases the plays aren't working yet keep getting called anyway.

Lets hope Valbrian can shed some light...I'm all out of ideas now
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arayel
...
Lets hope Valbrian can shed some light...I'm all out of ideas now


Assuming this will not turn out to be a human error there is a hard way to solve it:
- Step one: check that your packages are called correctly (there is a GM script that change all AI output name to the package name)
- Step two: If you can Identify the input causing problem then redo it and the relevant packages
- Step three :Redo the AI and packages from start (print, load the default AI and then type it in Input after input).

This is a lot of work, but I saw it work (I've been on a team that it defense kept calling basic plays, it was fixed by retyping the DAI and custom plays).

Edited by tragula on Nov 16, 2010 06:41:00
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
When did I become "Val"?

Likely causes PM'd.
 
Arayel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Assuming this will not turn out to be a human error there is a hard way to solve it:
- Step one: check that your packages are called correctly (there is a GM script that change all AI output name to the package name)
- Step two: If you can Identify the input causing problem then redo it and the relevant packages
- Step three :Redo the AI and packages from start (print, load the default AI and then type it in Input after input).

This is a lot of work, but I saw it work (I've been on a team that it defense kept calling basic plays, it was fixed by retyping the DAI and custom plays).



Yep beginning to think I might have to do this. Think my first step would be to rebuild the packages.

And err sorry about that VolBrian......thanks for the PM
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
More PM's sent. Initial theory may have been wrong, but couldn't hurt to fix I think.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Ok, we are resolving this through PM's and there is nothing about this issue that could be called a bug tbh so I'll go ahead and close this out.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.