This isn't a bug and not an exploit either imo. You have a 6 on 5 situation. The people saying to hold somebody back may be missing the fact that this is a 5 wide set and there is no HB, FB, or TE to keep in. However, the opposing DC is making a calculated risk in bringing 6 blitzers against a 5 WR set. In this situation it worked. Maybe better scouting would have precluded the use of this particular formation or at least used a quick slant or something shorter.
Originally posted by VolBrian This isn't a bug and not an exploit either imo. You have a 6 on 5 situation. The people saying to hold somebody back may be missing the fact that this is a 5 wide set and there is no HB, FB, or TE to keep in. However, the opposing DC is making a calculated risk in bringing 6 blitzers against a 5 WR set. In this situation it worked. Maybe better scouting would have precluded the use of this particular formation or at least used a quick slant or something shorter.
Not likely a bug
5WR set? The play the OP linked is Strong-I (2WR). Are you looking at a different play?
I saw this and assumed the first play was a link mistake. Although, I do see the overload on the first one as well. Definitely don't see an issue with that. The HB breaks one of those tackles and it's 10+ yards.
Originally posted by TheBear What makes it an exploit is there is no way for an offense to make an in game adjustment to counter it. In real life you can bet a defense would get burned if they ran that same thing over and over. You can say they should have scouted the opponent better, but what if thats the first time they did that?
Originally posted by VolBrian This isn't a bug and not an exploit either imo. You have a 6 on 5 situation. The people saying to hold somebody back may be missing the fact that this is a 5 wide set and there is no HB, FB, or TE to keep in. However, the opposing DC is making a calculated risk in bringing 6 blitzers against a 5 WR set. In this situation it worked. Maybe better scouting would have precluded the use of this particular formation or at least used a quick slant or something shorter.
Not likely a bug
So by this rational the I Slam was not an exploit either. It was simply playing to a strength and taking a gamble that if I run the same play 4 times I will get 10+ yards Which would still be possible except for the RPP.
When a defense runs the same exact play every down and it allows a player to go unblocked every down I would consider it an exploit. There is no RPP to compensate for this.
If you think the ability to run away from the play make it less of an exploit then watch the entire game. Sometimes the DE gets to the HB the same time as the ball. The number of possible plays you can run against this D gets cut down to very few which brings the RPP into play.There is also no way to force a TE to line up on the weak side on a running play.
Originally posted by Forbin It's not that hard. Seriously.
5WR - throw the slant
Any other formation, simply allow all 3 audible options (TE, HB, FB stay-in to block).
Barring that, if they're overloading one side, do something real snazzy on the other side. What's the problem? It's extremely simple.
ok so what if they run this same kind of play on the strong side?( I dont know if there is such a play but lets assume for argument sake there is) basically you will have to guess which side they will do it to you on and if you guess right you may win...guess wrong on get spanked. Not really how this game is designed to work.
There should not be a defensive play that completely eliminates more than one half of the playbook and a player from the game. The player being the receiving TE because you would have to keep a blocking TE in every pass play.
In an audible situation you keep the RB in to block but you are now counting on a RB (lol) to block a stud pass rusher. Thats not going to work. I guess if you had a FB with very high vision, agi, and blocking he could be kept in the backfield to pick up the DE but FBs are not really built that way.