User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > DE not reacting to screens - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Ok, after some PM's with zakatakrr I chose to reopen the thread.

I don't think this issue is as much related to the slider as it is to this or at least in conjunction with this:
Sept 20, 2010
- Fix issue causing some QB's to throw a larger number of low screen passes
- Update pass blocking to handle overloads inside out
- Add 1 tick to blitzer base reaction time
- Increase reaction delay for blitzers after pass is thrown
- Increase difficulty of vision check for DE's sniffing out screen passes

zakatakrr will post the Vision of these DE's and I'm marking Needs More Info.

I would like replays of other similar leveled DE's showing this kind of behavior at -100 passive.

If it's happening across the board with various levels and different levels of Vision then we probably have an issue.
 
zakatakrr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Ok, after some PM's with zakatakrr I chose to reopen the thread.


- Increase difficulty of vision check for DE's sniffing out screen passes

zakatakrr will post the Vision of these DE's and I'm marking Needs More Info.

I would like replays of other similar leveled DE's showing this kind of behavior at -100 passive.

If it's happening across the board with various levels and different levels of Vision then we probably have an issue.


thanks VB, as I said in the PMs, my comment to your bolded changelog is:

At some point the slider should start to decrease the vision needed for that vision check and by the time you get to -100 it should almost eliminate that vision check. That would be trade off with breaking fewer blocks
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Right, but what we don't know is how much easier the slider being completely passive will make that Vision check that is no tougher.

Will other DE's on -100 passive act the same?

I can't send it up based on what we have know because the exact formula will obviously not be released, but we need more replays to see if the slider has any affect whatsoever anymore.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zakatakrr
why is pass rush aggression a player tactic option if it doesn't work?

It doesn't work every time, but I have observed a difference in the past regarding how often they recognize screens based on their slider setting. Maybe another adjustment could be made to give -100 DEs a little boost to their vision check, or else exempt them from the change Bort made recently.


Originally posted by zakatakrr
by the time you get to -100 it should almost eliminate that vision check.

Here's the part where you get lost, because that's never going to happen. Bort doesn't want you to always pass vision checks if you're on a certain setting. Plus I don't think the penalty to breaking blocks is really all that large, which it would need to be if the bonus to vision checks was as enormous as you want it to be.
Edited by jdbolick on Oct 5, 2010 10:55:52
 
zakatakrr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Here's the part where you get lost, because that's never going to happen. Bort doesn't want you to always pass vision checks if you're on a certain setting. Plus I don't think the penalty to breaking blocks is really all that large, which it would need to be if the bonus to vision checks was as enormous as you want it to be.


I understand what you are saying, I think my reasoning stems from the huge difference between 99 elusive running and 100 elusive running.

Why is there such a huge disparity there if you 'sell out' on the elusive running slider but not on the Pass Rush Slider?

If you 'sell out' you should see large shifts in both directions: screen recognition, and breaking blocks

Other wise there really isn't any need for a slider
 
zakatakrr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Right, but what we don't know is how much easier the slider being completely passive will make that Vision check that is no tougher.

Will other DE's on -100 passive act the same?

I can't send it up based on what we have know because the exact formula will obviously not be released, but we need more replays to see if the slider has any affect whatsoever anymore.


I understand that currently the bugs forum requires countless examples before it is deemed a bug.

But isn't that what the test server is for? Why not test a game with all screens and 4 DEs all with different levels of vision and set to -100 and see what happens?

That way GLB could know the exact builds and tactics of the players involved
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zakatakrr
I understand that currently the bugs forum requires countless examples before it is deemed a bug.

But isn't that what the test server is for? Why not test a game with all screens and 4 DEs all with different levels of vision and set to -100 and see what happens?

That way GLB could know the exact builds and tactics of the players involved


Basically because we're not gonna take time away from figuring out the phantom play call issue, etc to do a test request on something that is, with all existing examples/replays, working as it's supposed to. Plus, I'm not allowed to do that per procedures.

With just the three examples we have right now, it's 95% likely it was the Vision issue imo. With each successive replay we get, that percentage will drop until we have something that I can take to QA, Testing, and the Admins and say "look, this might not be working like you intended it to or your tougher vision check may have invalidated the tactics slider and here is a fairly wide sample size of evidence why".
Edited by VolBrian on Oct 5, 2010 11:18:00
Edited by VolBrian on Oct 5, 2010 11:17:42
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zakatakrr
I understand what you are saying, I think my reasoning stems from the huge difference between 99 elusive running and 100 elusive running.

Super Elusive is really the only slider setting like that out of all the ones in GLB. For quarterbacks, there is virtually no difference between 100 passing style and 99 passing style.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Super Elusive is really the only slider setting like that out of all the ones in GLB. For quarterbacks, there is virtually no difference between 100 passing style and 99 passing style.


Yeah, and this is evdienced by the fact taking the HB from 99 to 100, indicates "Super Elusive" whereas a QB from 99 to 100 does not indicate "Super Bullet" (which would be awesome imo) or a DE from 99 to 100 indicate "Super Break Block", etc.
 
zakatakrr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Super Elusive is really the only slider setting like that out of all the ones in GLB. For quarterbacks, there is virtually no difference between 100 passing style and 99 passing style.


agreed, but that doesn't make it right, there is a big difference between 100 passing style and -100 passing style.

that doesn't seem to be the case for the Pass Rush Slider

 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zakatakrr
agreed, but that doesn't make it right, there is a big difference between 100 passing style and -100 passing style.

that doesn't seem to be the case for the Pass Rush Slider



Ahh, I see your point
 
zakatakrr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Basically because we're not gonna take time away from figuring out the phantom play call issue, etc to do a test request on something that is, with all existing examples/replays, working as it's supposed to. Plus, I'm not allowed to do that per procedures.

With just the three examples we have right now, it's 95% likely it was the Vision issue imo. With each successive replay we get, that percentage will drop until we have something that I can take to QA, Testing, and the Admins and say "look, this might not be working like you intended it to or your tougher vision check may have invalidated the tactics slider and here is a fairly wide sample size of evidence why".


Yes, I know bug mods don't have that kind of power and are here to sort and follow procedure, this isn't a shot at you or any other bugs mods. More of a complaint about the implementation of the screen sim changes.

Doesn't seem like the testing that went into the screen changes considered the Pass Rush Aggression slider and that is a mistake that should be addressed and not force the users to test and try and prove is broken.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zakatakrr
agreed, but that doesn't make it right, there is a big difference between 100 passing style and -100 passing style. that doesn't seem to be the case for the Pass Rush Slider

That's because of what I already said. If there were a huge bonus to the vision check, then there would need to be a huge penalty to breaking blocks, and everyone would scream bloody murder over that.
 
zakatakrr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

That's because of what I already said. If there were a huge bonus to the vision check, then there would need to be a huge penalty to breaking blocks, and everyone would scream bloody murder over that.


isn't that the reason to have a slider? to have a wide variety of options between two extremes
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zakatakrr
isn't that the reason to have a slider? to have a wide variety of options between two extremes

That's one way of thinking, but actually most of the sliders and settings in personal tactics do relatively little.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.