User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Defending the Screen Coverage Issue - RESOLVED BUG
Page:
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Just adding some fuel to the fire here...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416744&pbp_id=4617738


ROLB is blitzing.

Watch the ROLB and LDE.

Edited by tautology on Sep 29, 2010 21:39:35
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Just adding some fuel to the fire here...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416744&pbp_id=4617738


ROLB is blitzing.

Watch the ROLB and LDE.





Also, more fuel. Watch LDE.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1375327&pbp_id=4683081
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
The not tackling the QB on screens is most definitely a bug and it's terrible that the bugs mods just sit and wait for some weird 15 replay quota or whatever. Screen issues all need to be looked at bort/catch and should be treated differently. If bort/catch don't like it, they should've tested it more before springing after the preseason.


Also, i think DEs on passive reading the blitz look a bit weird. Look how they just pause and wait for the ball to be thrown but just stand way short of being able to make any kind of play. Pausing like while the play is happening around him shouldn't be happening on any play. Definitely doesn't look right

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416744&pbp_id=4617139
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416744&pbp_id=4617678
bunch more games i saw the past day or two with more and more teams testing screens and passive tactics
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ninja turtles
and so my question is, is it a bug or is it intended that you can no longer cover the HB in man on those plays because he is initially assumed to be a blocker by the defender?


This falls into the grey area, and its about the timing of the vision check.

I'll use this play for example : http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1386312&pbp_id=4227282 where you say the settings are HB Strong - WR2.

What you are basically asking for here is for the SS to vision check to see if the HB is running a route to the Strong side, and if he is not then cover WR2.

Watch the play frame by frame.

By the time the HB is outside of the pocket and could be considered to be running a route, WR2 is 5 yards downfield, which takes him beyond the SS starting position.

Given the SS starting position, he cant afford to cover the HB for this long and have any chance of covering the WR. (Remember that the WR is now one yard ahead and probably up to top speed, while the SS is pretty much on his heels if he has to cover the HB first)

At the point where he needs to make a decision to cover WR2, the HB is still in the backfield and looks to all intents to be doubling the LDE.
What makes it appear so buggy is that CB1 is already covering WR2, so the SS can afford to take more time.

But Technically your dot responded to the input correctly, hence not a stonewall Bug, and it is really very easily managed within the custom AI by just selecting the assignments more thoughtfully.

Most of the other examples posted have the same type of issue, and honestly, without wanting to hurt feelings, no one input should allow a player to cover a Screen pass to the HB AND a 40 yard WR streak (In a few examples that WR is also lining up on the other side of the field, fwiw.)

So the questions that need asking are;

A: When and how often are the vision checks happening on the Primary assignment.
B: When does the Secondary assignment vision check start.
C: Is there enough gap between the A and B to ensure that a player has at least a chance of spotting a screen?


If all thats fine, then we will live with it and adjust.


 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon


Also, more fuel. Watch LDE.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1375327&pbp_id=4683081


Now these are BUGS
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Echo, echo, echo... Anyone reading this? Come on guys... There is some action that needs to be taken with this.
 
ninja turtles
offline
Link
 
i can't totally disagree with you here, but if this is the NEW way that defenders react to HB's going out for a pass then it should be that way for all plays. The defenders have never responded like that before in the past and don't do it on all HB routes. Is this the new normal? There are other passing plays (besides HB screens) where the HB is slow to get out of the "pocket" area. Should we not be allowed to play man coverage on a HB who delays out of the backfield? The way it's working now the defender always seems to jump to his next assignment on those screen plays, however on other passing plays the defender will immedialtly recognize that he is a receiver and wait for him.



Originally posted by Mike Rogers
This falls into the grey area, and its about the timing of the vision check.

I'll use this play for example : http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1386312&pbp_id=4227282 where you say the settings are HB Strong - WR2.

What you are basically asking for here is for the SS to vision check to see if the HB is running a route to the Strong side, and if he is not then cover WR2.

Watch the play frame by frame.

By the time the HB is outside of the pocket and could be considered to be running a route, WR2 is 5 yards downfield, which takes him beyond the SS starting position.

Given the SS starting position, he cant afford to cover the HB for this long and have any chance of covering the WR. (Remember that the WR is now one yard ahead and probably up to top speed, while the SS is pretty much on his heels if he has to cover the HB first)

At the point where he needs to make a decision to cover WR2, the HB is still in the backfield and looks to all intents to be doubling the LDE.
What makes it appear so buggy is that CB1 is already covering WR2, so the SS can afford to take more time.

But Technically your dot responded to the input correctly, hence not a stonewall Bug, and it is really very easily managed within the custom AI by just selecting the assignments more thoughtfully.

Most of the other examples posted have the same type of issue, and honestly, without wanting to hurt feelings, no one input should allow a player to cover a Screen pass to the HB AND a 40 yard WR streak (In a few examples that WR is also lining up on the other side of the field, fwiw.)

So the questions that need asking are;

A: When and how often are the vision checks happening on the Primary assignment.
B: When does the Secondary assignment vision check start.
C: Is there enough gap between the A and B to ensure that a player has at least a chance of spotting a screen?


If all thats fine, then we will live with it and adjust.




 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
Wow... That replay from the Alpine game where the RDE runs right past the QB was baffling as well.

I am marking this as likely a bug. After looking through the Sunami defensive AI everything ninja said, adds up. Some coverages not being followed.

 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by P@nda
Wow... That replay from the Alpine game where the RDE runs right past the QB was baffling as well.

I am marking this as likely a bug. After looking through the Sunami defensive AI everything ninja said, adds up. Some coverages not being followed.



to restate if it helps bort/catch the only input on that play for the guy on alpine was blitz and was on all the way aggressive

my guess is when bort changed the logic for defenders following screens and QBs selling it they messed something up in there where the defenders won't try and sack the QB
Edited by chronoaug on Sep 30, 2010 09:11:46
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Sending up to QA
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
Originally posted by P@nda

Wow... That replay from the Alpine game where the RDE runs right past the QB was baffling as well.

I am marking this as likely a bug. After looking through the Sunami defensive AI everything ninja said, adds up. Some coverages not being followed.



to restate if it helps bort/catch the only input on that play for the guy on alpine was blitz and was on all the way aggressive

my guess is when bort changed the logic for defenders following screens and QBs selling it they messed something up in there where the defenders won't try and sack the QB


I don't agree with this 100%, because I have seen our LDE sack the QB on a screen. Just not the LB - or ROLB in particular. Something is definitely not working from the replays obviously.

My concern is why the SS/LOLB when set to HB - ignore him and progress to either Zone or cover the WR2. That basically causes a huge void in the defense and enables the screen to develop and eat some easy yards.
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Bugged? Yes and no. Players that are covering in man to man particularly have the tendency to give up their assignment even though their coverage is clearly not pass blocking...

In these two, the SS is set to HB strong, which he fulfills. However, watch the LOLB who is on the TE. The TE is clearly not blocking but the LOLB gives up his assignment...
LOLB is set to TE, then WR2
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1387923&pbp_id=3680882
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1387923&pbp_id=3681557
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1387923&pbp_id=3684835

Pro Set looks okay. MLB: HB Strong, LOLB, TE; However, the SS is set to man coverage against WR2 and he blitzes? (this one is odd to me)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1387923&pbp_id=3682708
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1387923&pbp_id=3684325

HOWEVER:
These look okay. MLB: TE, SS: HB Strong
+++MLB doesn't have a secondary man coverage assignment, so he sticks with the TE (apparently)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1387923&pbp_id=3683891
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1387923&pbp_id=3684283

EDIT: After further review, I think the source of the bug is that players have multiple man coverage assignments, and they check down to their next coverage. I would lean in the way of NOT calling this a bug. If you want to make sure you cover the screen well, don't give your LBs and safeties secondary assignments to make sure they stay with the initial player.
Edited by saintedix on Sep 30, 2010 22:58:43
Edited by saintedix on Sep 30, 2010 22:56:21
Edited by saintedix on Sep 30, 2010 22:51:28
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1386312&pbp_id=4227282

On this play, for example. Who the heck is supposed to be covering the FB and TE?
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
The not tackling the QB on screens is most definitely a bug and it's terrible that the bugs mods just sit and wait for some weird 15 replay quota or whatever. Screen issues all need to be looked at bort/catch and should be treated differently. If bort/catch don't like it, they should've tested it more before springing after the preseason.


Also, i think DEs on passive reading the blitz look a bit weird. Look how they just pause and wait for the ball to be thrown but just stand way short of being able to make any kind of play. Pausing like while the play is happening around him shouldn't be happening on any play. Definitely doesn't look right

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416744&pbp_id=4617139
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416744&pbp_id=4617678
bunch more games i saw the past day or two with more and more teams testing screens and passive tactics


Sorry for the triple. These are definitely bugs. The LE should either bounce back into coverage, or simply engage the HB in a block (this is completely legal), messing with the route.
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1386312&pbp_id=4227282

On this play, for example. Who the heck is supposed to be covering the FB and TE?


That is a bug. No way anyone just has their dudes drop like that.... From what I have seen, I-formation is terrible.
Edited by TyrannyVaunt on Oct 1, 2010 00:11:07
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.