User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Lost TP when contract ran up - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
bobdakota
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian


Nobody tells anybody how to build their dot, but there are rules in place to prevent the re-emergence of SSB-ing. If one was able to carry over an unlimited amount of TP's into FA, then they could effectively SSB by saving all their TP's while on a team and then spending a season as a FA training. So, the rule is there to prevent that kind of thing and a user should be aware that they can only carry a max of 14 TP's into free agency.


You can only train when you are on a team. Right? I could see why a player should not be able to get more TP, but to take them away doesn't seem right.

 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bobdakota
You can only train when you are on a team. Right? I could see why a player should not be able to get more TP, but to take them away doesn't seem right.


It seems we have a winner. I forgot about that aspect tbh. I'm gonna switch this to needs more info while we try to nail down specifically, without rumor, what the max number of TP's you can hold is and then determine if this is WAI or not.
 
shane827
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
I don't know, if it was announced specifically, but it was certainly implied. When the new training system was rolled out it was specifically stated that you could hold no more than 14 TP's as a FA. It stands to reason that you would lose them if you had more when you became a FA imo.


lol u know it was never announced but just dont want to admit it, nice try tho. ur reasoning makes no sense if u really believe (which i dont think u do) ur dot should lose TPs that he already has
 
odt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
In that case, I believe it's 30. not certain, but I've seen that number a few places over the last few minutes.


This is stupid then. If you can only save up 30 TP and don't get any TP while unsigned, then there is no advantage for a player to sit out a season so that they can train ala SSBing and unless I'm missing something even if there isn't a limit I don't see what you are worried about. By sitting out to train you are doing nothing more than losing a season of gaining experience and this limit on how many TP a FA can hold is pointless, especially during the offseason.
 
shane827
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Originally posted by bobdakota

You can only train when you are on a team. Right? I could see why a player should not be able to get more TP, but to take them away doesn't seem right.


It seems we have a winner. I forgot about that aspect tbh. I'm gonna switch this to needs more info while we try to nail down specifically, without rumor, what the max number of TP's you can hold is and then determine if this is WAI or not.


i thought u couldnt train as a FA either but i just trained my HB 1 time because he is a FA and had 14 TPs saved. I didnt want to lose any TPs i should gain so i did 1 training and it did the training without any problems
 
bobdakota
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shane827


i thought u couldnt train as a FA either but i just trained my HB 1 time because he is a FA and had 14 TPs saved. I didnt want to lose any TPs i should gain so i did 1 training and it did the training without any problems


I have no clue than. It is so hard keeping up with the changes to the changes of the changes.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shane827
lol u know it was never announced but just dont want to admit it, nice try tho. ur reasoning makes no sense if u really believe (which i dont think u do) ur dot should lose TPs that he already has


Actually I don't. My specific answer, which you quoted incidentally, was:

Originally posted by VolBrian
I don't know


I don't know if there was a specific announcement that you would lose anything over 14 by going a FA, but:

Originally posted by VolBrian
it was certainly implied


When they made the announcements and stated facts about the new training system including that you could not hold more than 14 as a FA.

So, if you can't have more than 14 as a FA, you go FA with 30, you are likely to to lose 16 TP's since FA's can't have more than 14.

/Reasoning

*****************************

Now, I also am no longer sure this is something that should happen as I stated above and I've kicked it up for a closer look.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shane827
i thought u couldnt train as a FA either but i just trained my HB 1 time because he is a FA and had 14 TPs saved. I didnt want to lose any TPs i should gain so i did 1 training and it did the training without any problems


You can on day 41
 
odt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
When they made the announcements and stated facts about the new training system including that you could not hold more than 14 as a FA.

So, if you can't have more than 14 as a FA, you go FA with 30, you are likely to to lose 16 TP's since FA's can't have more than 14.

/Reasoning

*****************************

Now, I also am no longer sure this is something that should happen as I stated above and I've kicked it up for a closer look.


Even if this info was announced (I obviously didn't remember ever seeing it), things like this should have been announced along with the "make sure you get your team requests in" stuff before the offseason begins.

Like I said a few posts ago its pretty unnecessary to stop SSB, so shouldn't be here in the first place.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
You can during the offseason.


fyp
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
And it is very stupid to take away points from a player.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
fyp


ty
 
lz2112
offline
Link
 
I lost TP on 8 players, most in the 8-12 range. I knew they were going FA, and knew FAs couldn't hold TP>14, but just didn't make the connection until this morning when all were at 14. A reminder would have been nice.

And before someone blasts me for having players with that many TP, when you have a lot of players, it's very easy to do (I retired 15 today, many of them lost TP too, but who cares).

 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Same thing could conceivably happen to a dot who's dropped mid-season for some reason. Probably shouldn't be happening at all, but god knows we had to stop those evil SSBers. So this is how we pay for it.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
This isn't a bug. It's working as intended. Bugs CS Mod, notify OP and close. Thanks.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.