I can honestly say my non-boosters will rarely train on light.
Forum > Suggestions > Receive TP for Boosting
charwh
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
I can honestly say my non-boosters will rarely train on light.
I'm sure it depends quite a bit on a players specific build plan. In any case, a booster is still going to see a much greater return per TP up to lvl 42, and they're already going to be receiving quite a lot of SP's at the playoffs for boosting.
Right now, the non-booster advantage has more to do with build strategy than training. I don't want to see it made so that long term build plans are equalized against short term plans, then boosters suddenly starting to build for short term, and being unstoppable.
Even if all other things were made equal, boosting for the playoffs would make boosters pretty much unsurmountable in the post season, as it already is in Pee Wees and 14 caps.
I have some players I boost, and others I don't, and I just see it as a choice for building for long term vs. short term success.
Also, with the recent changes made to aging and decline, a booster will already get to see more highly competitive days than a non-booster, and those days will all get to be in the World league.
I can honestly say my non-boosters will rarely train on light.
I'm sure it depends quite a bit on a players specific build plan. In any case, a booster is still going to see a much greater return per TP up to lvl 42, and they're already going to be receiving quite a lot of SP's at the playoffs for boosting.
Right now, the non-booster advantage has more to do with build strategy than training. I don't want to see it made so that long term build plans are equalized against short term plans, then boosters suddenly starting to build for short term, and being unstoppable.
Even if all other things were made equal, boosting for the playoffs would make boosters pretty much unsurmountable in the post season, as it already is in Pee Wees and 14 caps.
I have some players I boost, and others I don't, and I just see it as a choice for building for long term vs. short term success.
Also, with the recent changes made to aging and decline, a booster will already get to see more highly competitive days than a non-booster, and those days will all get to be in the World league.
zorgoth
offline
offline
It's the in-between from level 20 to 40 for a booster that causes problems. We see players with decent build having numbers like lvl 36 / effective 32 all the time, because they boost and miss precious training. After lvl 40, almost all of them rally to even these numbers before level 50, unless they were not built well at all. Maybe we should allow TPs - or even as suggested earlier BTs - to boosters between levels 20 and 40 to help them to not trail down too much. Or maybe a boost could grant 6 SPs to the player instead of 5 as a regular level up.
Edited by zorgoth on Sep 2, 2010 15:18:36
charwh
offline
offline
Originally posted by zorgoth
It's the in-between from level 20 to 40 for a booster that causes problems. We see players with decent build having numbers like lvl 36 / effective 32 all the time, because they boost and miss precious training. After lvl 40, almost all of them rally to even these numbers before level 50, unless they were not built well at all. Maybe we should allow TPs - or even as suggested earlier BTs - to boosters between levels 20 and 40 to help them to not trail down too much. Or maybe a boost could grant 6 SPs to the player instead of 5 as a regular level up.
It still mostly comes from the long term nature of the build.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1999483
I made him on day 41, and boosted to level 4 the last day before preseason. He's taken every boost available to him to date. I'm building him like I would a non-booster. Not only has he not fallen behind, but his effective level is above his actual level. On top of that, I'm thinking about starting him over because he should be about 15 effective SP's higher, had I done his training smarter. I disbelieve that he will only gain 2 more effective levels in the next 7 levels.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1654176
This player has boosted every season but one. I know he's getting above the non-boosters now, but when he was level 36, his effective level was still 40.
Granted, an equivalently built non-booster would be level 36, effective level 44, but that difference can be negated by boosting for playoffs. In any case, it's the far from the difference of effective level 34 vs. effective level 44.
If the long-term-build boosters were more equalized to non-boosters, short term built boosters like mine would be unstoppable.
The lost training should only account for about ~45 effective SP's if you're comparing two equivalent builds.
by level 42, the right build should gain >35 effective SP's for boosting because of ALG's, and those lost 10 effective skill points when your player has over 600 are going to matter less than a slew of other factors.
It's the in-between from level 20 to 40 for a booster that causes problems. We see players with decent build having numbers like lvl 36 / effective 32 all the time, because they boost and miss precious training. After lvl 40, almost all of them rally to even these numbers before level 50, unless they were not built well at all. Maybe we should allow TPs - or even as suggested earlier BTs - to boosters between levels 20 and 40 to help them to not trail down too much. Or maybe a boost could grant 6 SPs to the player instead of 5 as a regular level up.
It still mostly comes from the long term nature of the build.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1999483
I made him on day 41, and boosted to level 4 the last day before preseason. He's taken every boost available to him to date. I'm building him like I would a non-booster. Not only has he not fallen behind, but his effective level is above his actual level. On top of that, I'm thinking about starting him over because he should be about 15 effective SP's higher, had I done his training smarter. I disbelieve that he will only gain 2 more effective levels in the next 7 levels.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1654176
This player has boosted every season but one. I know he's getting above the non-boosters now, but when he was level 36, his effective level was still 40.
Granted, an equivalently built non-booster would be level 36, effective level 44, but that difference can be negated by boosting for playoffs. In any case, it's the far from the difference of effective level 34 vs. effective level 44.
If the long-term-build boosters were more equalized to non-boosters, short term built boosters like mine would be unstoppable.
The lost training should only account for about ~45 effective SP's if you're comparing two equivalent builds.
by level 42, the right build should gain >35 effective SP's for boosting because of ALG's, and those lost 10 effective skill points when your player has over 600 are going to matter less than a slew of other factors.
Edited by charwh on Sep 2, 2010 16:45:11
naraic
offline
offline
I made a similar suggestion recently, someone suggested 8-10 as a fair compromise to slash the difference between boosters and non boosters.
It would also probably popularise boosting to 4 before your first season.
It would also probably popularise boosting to 4 before your first season.
zorgoth
offline
offline
Originally posted by charwh
It still mostly comes from the long term nature of the build.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1654176
This player has boosted every season but one. I know he's getting above the non-boosters now, but when he was level 36, his effective level was still 40.
Maybe your WR is above his level but when you look at the scouting bars, catching and carrying are low, that tells me you had to split your points among the secondary attributes instead of go deep in speed, agility, catching and carrying - like almost WRs - to keep his effective level high like non-boosters; shall I say it's cheating? I have a WR who is level 41/37. Even though he's under his level, his scouting bars are way better than your guy cause I trained him as if he were a non-booster and sacrificed some effective levels to give the catching and carrying attributes he must have. I'd rather be under in terms of effective level and catch up later. I boosted him every time I was able to, I don't regret it, but if something was helping catch up the levels I lost with him, he would be even and going up instead.
Your guy : http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1654176
My guy : http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1763965
We have the same archetype but we aren't built alike at all...
It still mostly comes from the long term nature of the build.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1654176
This player has boosted every season but one. I know he's getting above the non-boosters now, but when he was level 36, his effective level was still 40.
Maybe your WR is above his level but when you look at the scouting bars, catching and carrying are low, that tells me you had to split your points among the secondary attributes instead of go deep in speed, agility, catching and carrying - like almost WRs - to keep his effective level high like non-boosters; shall I say it's cheating? I have a WR who is level 41/37. Even though he's under his level, his scouting bars are way better than your guy cause I trained him as if he were a non-booster and sacrificed some effective levels to give the catching and carrying attributes he must have. I'd rather be under in terms of effective level and catch up later. I boosted him every time I was able to, I don't regret it, but if something was helping catch up the levels I lost with him, he would be even and going up instead.
Your guy : http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1654176
My guy : http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1763965
We have the same archetype but we aren't built alike at all...
charwh
offline
offline
Your argument fails to consider that I may have made a very balanced posession receiver because, at the time of his inception, that is the kind of receiver I thought would best play the way I wanted. Secondly, your implication is that ranks in things like stamina, confidence, or strength really don't help a WR play better, but are instead only a ploy to pad out extra "illusionary" SP's. Is it unreasonable that I may have possibly wanted to qualify for more prerequisite based VA's?
Lastly, however, you're not appreciating that a non-booster receives 3/4 of all the SP's they will ever have by level 30. If they're ever going to have their secondary attributes worked, they better have done it by now, especially if they ever want SA's too.
So, yes, it is by working on secondary attributes prior to level 30 that the SP advantage is gained. That is a build choice issue, however, and that is the way non boosters build, and that's why they get so far ahead at intermediate levels. It's not the Training issue boosters want to blame it on.
This said, however, I agree that your WR is better right now, and will continue to get better because my build peaked in the level 30 cap, and you're building to peak as a pro.
Edited to add: my players all-time Offense and WR ranking is also higher.
I also have another WR who is built almost identical, and he's higher yet.
Just saying...
Edited again to add:
Take a look at the effective SP's of some of Catch22's boosted players.
Lastly, however, you're not appreciating that a non-booster receives 3/4 of all the SP's they will ever have by level 30. If they're ever going to have their secondary attributes worked, they better have done it by now, especially if they ever want SA's too.
So, yes, it is by working on secondary attributes prior to level 30 that the SP advantage is gained. That is a build choice issue, however, and that is the way non boosters build, and that's why they get so far ahead at intermediate levels. It's not the Training issue boosters want to blame it on.
This said, however, I agree that your WR is better right now, and will continue to get better because my build peaked in the level 30 cap, and you're building to peak as a pro.
Edited to add: my players all-time Offense and WR ranking is also higher.
I also have another WR who is built almost identical, and he's higher yet.
Just saying...
Edited again to add:
Take a look at the effective SP's of some of Catch22's boosted players.
Edited by charwh on Sep 5, 2010 16:35:43
Edited by charwh on Sep 5, 2010 16:01:04
Edited by charwh on Sep 5, 2010 15:56:50
Edited by charwh on Sep 5, 2010 14:23:55
Edited by charwh on Sep 5, 2010 14:21:46
mandyross
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Originally posted by TruthHammer
This is why I didn't go for an "equal" number of TP. I think ideal would be a middle ground between the nothing we get now and the "equal" you suggest.
THe trouble is there's no middle ground. I guess you could do something like is suggested above and ratchet up the TP granted as the player boosts more, maxing it out at the 12th boost, and then not granting any more after that (no need to b/c non boosters will never pass level 41).
Something like
Boost # / TPs
1 / 2
2 / 4
3 / 6
4 / 12
5 / 16
6 / 20
7 / 40
8 / 50
9 / 60
10 / 90
11 / 100
12 / 110
13 / 0
...
30 / 0
510 total TP for boosters during their first 12 boosts.
This would go a long way towards sorting out the discrepancy which currently exists.
Originally posted by TruthHammer
This is why I didn't go for an "equal" number of TP. I think ideal would be a middle ground between the nothing we get now and the "equal" you suggest.
THe trouble is there's no middle ground. I guess you could do something like is suggested above and ratchet up the TP granted as the player boosts more, maxing it out at the 12th boost, and then not granting any more after that (no need to b/c non boosters will never pass level 41).
Something like
Boost # / TPs
1 / 2
2 / 4
3 / 6
4 / 12
5 / 16
6 / 20
7 / 40
8 / 50
9 / 60
10 / 90
11 / 100
12 / 110
13 / 0
...
30 / 0
510 total TP for boosters during their first 12 boosts.
This would go a long way towards sorting out the discrepancy which currently exists.
-AB-
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
THe trouble is there's no middle ground. I guess you could do something like is suggested above and ratchet up the TP granted as the player boosts more, maxing it out at the 12th boost, and then not granting any more after that (no need to b/c non boosters will never pass level 41).
Something like
Boost # / TPs
1 / 2
2 / 4
3 / 6
4 / 12
5 / 16
6 / 20
7 / 40
8 / 50
9 / 60
10 / 90
11 / 100
12 / 110
13 / 0
...
30 / 0
510 total TP for boosters during their first 12 boosts.
+1
THe trouble is there's no middle ground. I guess you could do something like is suggested above and ratchet up the TP granted as the player boosts more, maxing it out at the 12th boost, and then not granting any more after that (no need to b/c non boosters will never pass level 41).
Something like
Boost # / TPs
1 / 2
2 / 4
3 / 6
4 / 12
5 / 16
6 / 20
7 / 40
8 / 50
9 / 60
10 / 90
11 / 100
12 / 110
13 / 0
...
30 / 0
510 total TP for boosters during their first 12 boosts.
+1
TheGreatPuma
offline
offline
The numbers probably need to be tweaked a bit, but if it shuts up the non-boost whiners I'm all for it.
Stonewall Paul
offline
offline
Giving training points basically gives you BTs which would be way overpowered unless you changed the price of AEQ.
Also you need to consider the damage you cause to players that won't fully receive these benefits. You would be shortening their Pro/WL careers because the dots behind them were able to train more and better. Something drastic like this would require a full reset to be fair.
Also you need to consider the damage you cause to players that won't fully receive these benefits. You would be shortening their Pro/WL careers because the dots behind them were able to train more and better. Something drastic like this would require a full reset to be fair.
Edited by Stonewall Paul on Oct 6, 2010 16:53:06
mandyross
offline
offline
Originally posted by Stonewall Paul
Giving training points basically gives you BTs which would be way overpowered unless you changed the price of AEQ.
Also you need to consider the damage you cause to players that won't fully receive these benefits. You would be shortening their Pro/WL careers because the dots behind them were able to train more and better. Something drastic like this would require a full reset to be fair.
Change the AEQ price and give older players reciprocal TPs?
Giving training points basically gives you BTs which would be way overpowered unless you changed the price of AEQ.
Also you need to consider the damage you cause to players that won't fully receive these benefits. You would be shortening their Pro/WL careers because the dots behind them were able to train more and better. Something drastic like this would require a full reset to be fair.
Change the AEQ price and give older players reciprocal TPs?
TheGreatPuma
offline
offline
There are a whole generation of AT dots that are going to whip up on their older brethren. We didn't get a full reset then.
Originally posted by mandyross
Change the AEQ price and give older players reciprocal TPs?
Due to the training setup, most everyone would not get equal value training now, as opposed to earlier in a build. That doesn't even take into account ALGs.
As for AEQ pricing, there would be no need to change the price.
Boosters can have 4 pieces fully equipped while still training on intense for 8 seasons, and normal for 2. Boosters need to train on light for 5, and multi for 3.
Change the AEQ price and give older players reciprocal TPs?
Due to the training setup, most everyone would not get equal value training now, as opposed to earlier in a build. That doesn't even take into account ALGs.
As for AEQ pricing, there would be no need to change the price.
Boosters can have 4 pieces fully equipped while still training on intense for 8 seasons, and normal for 2. Boosters need to train on light for 5, and multi for 3.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























