+1
Forum > Suggestions > Offical Thread for Promotion System Changes (Enforcing Level Caps Etc)
-1
This really isn't a problem and breaking up teams or over promoting them will only make competitive balance worse. Every season people freak out about the few over cap guys on some team in their league, then those teams turn out to be a non-issue because they suck, which is why they are so far above their leagues level. Happens every time.
This is what happened to the first team in the OP against cap 22 teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994
This really isn't a problem and breaking up teams or over promoting them will only make competitive balance worse. Every season people freak out about the few over cap guys on some team in their league, then those teams turn out to be a non-issue because they suck, which is why they are so far above their leagues level. Happens every time.
This is what happened to the first team in the OP against cap 22 teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994
azrolator
offline
offline
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
This really isn't a problem and breaking up teams or over promoting them will only make competitive balance worse. Every season people freak out about the few over cap guys on some team in their league, then those teams turn out to be a non-issue because they suck, which is why they are so far above their leagues level. Happens every time.
This is what happened to the first team in the OP against cap 22 teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994
One of those was a scrim against a 22 cap team, but the team in question is in an 18 cap league, the other link was from one of the regular season games, both wins.. It looks to me as if they played 1 team of double promoted boosters, who were level 14 to the other teams 25, and then 1 game against double promoted non boosters that were level 11 to the other teams 25. Both wins obviously, which is exactly what the original post was pointing out, that level 25 guys shouldn't be in this level 18 competitive league against level 11's and 14's. Even if they played a team that had players all the way to the level cap, those guys would still be outleveled by 7!
I really don't understand your reply, as you gave links to a game that was from 18 cap league, and said it was 22. Your seem to be making the statement that teams that are 7 levels higher than the league cap they are in, somehow, suck and are non-issues, but you backed it up with links to a team that is 7 levels higher than the league cap, that has won both its games by a large margin. Not sure if I just am not understanding what you were trying to say, but thanks for providing examples to back up the OPs suggestion anyways.
Edited: took out your -1 as I didn't want people to think I agreed with you.
This really isn't a problem and breaking up teams or over promoting them will only make competitive balance worse. Every season people freak out about the few over cap guys on some team in their league, then those teams turn out to be a non-issue because they suck, which is why they are so far above their leagues level. Happens every time.
This is what happened to the first team in the OP against cap 22 teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994
One of those was a scrim against a 22 cap team, but the team in question is in an 18 cap league, the other link was from one of the regular season games, both wins.. It looks to me as if they played 1 team of double promoted boosters, who were level 14 to the other teams 25, and then 1 game against double promoted non boosters that were level 11 to the other teams 25. Both wins obviously, which is exactly what the original post was pointing out, that level 25 guys shouldn't be in this level 18 competitive league against level 11's and 14's. Even if they played a team that had players all the way to the level cap, those guys would still be outleveled by 7!
I really don't understand your reply, as you gave links to a game that was from 18 cap league, and said it was 22. Your seem to be making the statement that teams that are 7 levels higher than the league cap they are in, somehow, suck and are non-issues, but you backed it up with links to a team that is 7 levels higher than the league cap, that has won both its games by a large margin. Not sure if I just am not understanding what you were trying to say, but thanks for providing examples to back up the OPs suggestion anyways.
Edited: took out your -1 as I didn't want people to think I agreed with you.
Edited by azrolator on Aug 2, 2010 05:02:32
Edited by azrolator on Aug 2, 2010 05:01:08
Dr. E
offline
offline
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
-1
This really isn't a problem and breaking up teams or over promoting them will only make competitive balance worse. Every season people freak out about the few over cap guys on some team in their league, then those teams turn out to be a non-issue because they suck, which is why they are so far above their leagues level. Happens every time.
This is what happened to the first team in the OP against cap 22 teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
-1
This really isn't a problem and breaking up teams or over promoting them will only make competitive balance worse. Every season people freak out about the few over cap guys on some team in their league, then those teams turn out to be a non-issue because they suck, which is why they are so far above their leagues level. Happens every time.
This is what happened to the first team in the OP against cap 22 teams:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342266
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1342994
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
Edited by Dr. E on Aug 2, 2010 07:58:09
kennyyoso
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dr. E
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
+1
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
+1
Originally posted by kennyyoso
Originally posted by Dr. E
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
+1
a less drastic approach that would still get the job done. But a little worried that teams might try to get like half people at minimum contracts (that they'll cut) and over the cap to still try and game the system. So while it is a bit more flexible (not going to promote a team for having 1 or 2 players a level above the cap) it does allow for some exploitation (although much harder)
I'd probably rather them just be firm about the caps, and use the 3 tiers of leagues to place you where you needed to be rather than allowing any sort of opening for exploitation / gaming the system etc
Originally posted by Dr. E
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
+1
a less drastic approach that would still get the job done. But a little worried that teams might try to get like half people at minimum contracts (that they'll cut) and over the cap to still try and game the system. So while it is a bit more flexible (not going to promote a team for having 1 or 2 players a level above the cap) it does allow for some exploitation (although much harder)
I'd probably rather them just be firm about the caps, and use the 3 tiers of leagues to place you where you needed to be rather than allowing any sort of opening for exploitation / gaming the system etc
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
offline
+1: they just need to set hard limits to Day 0 & disallow any signing > the limit during season.
Yes, it will make it harder to sign during the season for replacements, but it should really come down to Trades or running with who you have once the season starts.
Also, with 3 tiers of competitiveness & Minor leagues that jump only 4 levels per season...any under performing team should be just going into the bottom tier. If they suck & are not trying, so be it. They should not be getting levels of players over their competition just to be considered 'competitive'.
Yes, it will make it harder to sign during the season for replacements, but it should really come down to Trades or running with who you have once the season starts.
Also, with 3 tiers of competitiveness & Minor leagues that jump only 4 levels per season...any under performing team should be just going into the bottom tier. If they suck & are not trying, so be it. They should not be getting levels of players over their competition just to be considered 'competitive'.
Edited by Skoll Wolfrun on Aug 2, 2010 10:18:18
azrolator
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dr. E
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
I see teams exploiting the system now, giving leeway is only going to allow them to do it still, just in a different way. I can see if they made it a team average, that there would be teams signing the lowest level they could for backups and filling up roster with these aside from the key positions. say an 18 cap team with 50 level 12's, an lt lg c rg rt and running back of level 65. this is the same average as a team of 55 level 18's. But you can throw every player you have at that rb and not have a shot. not to say that they are going to have level 65s in that 18 cap league, just pointing out how easy that would be to exploit.
Drake Slaughter
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dr. E
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
this
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
this
Dr. E
offline
offline
Originally posted by azrolator
I see teams exploiting the system now, giving leeway is only going to allow them to do it still, just in a different way. I can see if they made it a team average, that there would be teams signing the lowest level they could for backups and filling up roster with these aside from the key positions. say an 18 cap team with 50 level 12's, an lt lg c rg rt and running back of level 65. this is the same average as a team of 55 level 18's. But you can throw every player you have at that rb and not have a shot. not to say that they are going to have level 65s in that 18 cap league, just pointing out how easy that would be to exploit.
yea, they could get over by carrying low level guys, that has been done before, but it leaves weak spots in the line up to exploit.
I see teams exploiting the system now, giving leeway is only going to allow them to do it still, just in a different way. I can see if they made it a team average, that there would be teams signing the lowest level they could for backups and filling up roster with these aside from the key positions. say an 18 cap team with 50 level 12's, an lt lg c rg rt and running back of level 65. this is the same average as a team of 55 level 18's. But you can throw every player you have at that rb and not have a shot. not to say that they are going to have level 65s in that 18 cap league, just pointing out how easy that would be to exploit.
yea, they could get over by carrying low level guys, that has been done before, but it leaves weak spots in the line up to exploit.
Malchesis
offline
offline
Originally posted by kennyyoso
Originally posted by Dr. E
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
+1
+1
Originally posted by Dr. E
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
+1
+1
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
offline
Originally posted by azrolator
Originally posted by Dr. E
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
I see teams exploiting the system now, giving leeway is only going to allow them to do it still, just in a different way. I can see if they made it a team average, that there would be teams signing the lowest level they could for backups and filling up roster with these aside from the key positions. say an 18 cap team with 50 level 12's, an lt lg c rg rt and running back of level 65. this is the same average as a team of 55 level 18's. But you can throw every player you have at that rb and not have a shot. not to say that they are going to have level 65s in that 18 cap league, just pointing out how easy that would be to exploit.
I could see this working in combination with a hard cap of +1-2 levels over the League Limit (allow lvl 26 in a lvl 24 league as long as the team has a lvl 22 for each lvl 26).
But imo, with the current 3 tier system, is should not be needed.
Originally posted by Dr. E
No need to break up teams. Just need a little change in the rules for minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.
1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.
I see teams exploiting the system now, giving leeway is only going to allow them to do it still, just in a different way. I can see if they made it a team average, that there would be teams signing the lowest level they could for backups and filling up roster with these aside from the key positions. say an 18 cap team with 50 level 12's, an lt lg c rg rt and running back of level 65. this is the same average as a team of 55 level 18's. But you can throw every player you have at that rb and not have a shot. not to say that they are going to have level 65s in that 18 cap league, just pointing out how easy that would be to exploit.
I could see this working in combination with a hard cap of +1-2 levels over the League Limit (allow lvl 26 in a lvl 24 league as long as the team has a lvl 22 for each lvl 26).
But imo, with the current 3 tier system, is should not be needed.
Mightyhalo
offline
offline
Just do something and know that there are a bunch of teams that try to play the game fair and square, and some teams like that get promoted 2 caps only because 3-4 teams that could win go out of their way to lose, forcing teams up that have no business in a higher cap.
The exploiters and cap gamers abuse the system, yet it's the good guys who get screwed.
And it would be so easy to fix, but they don't want to piss off the exploiters, although they don't mind pissing off the ones who try and play within the spirit of fair play season after season.
The exploiters and cap gamers abuse the system, yet it's the good guys who get screwed.
And it would be so easy to fix, but they don't want to piss off the exploiters, although they don't mind pissing off the ones who try and play within the spirit of fair play season after season.
Morbid Da Clown
offline
offline
+1 to original OP
-1 to an avg. level.
To many teams load up on skill positions that are over caps of league. All it takes is a top HB,DE,Return Man or whatever in a league he doesnt belong and it makes a huge difference. You add 3-4 of these and its almost impossible for other teams, especially in casuals.
-1 to an avg. level.
To many teams load up on skill positions that are over caps of league. All it takes is a top HB,DE,Return Man or whatever in a league he doesnt belong and it makes a huge difference. You add 3-4 of these and its almost impossible for other teams, especially in casuals.
Edited by Morbid Da Clown on Aug 3, 2010 12:22:47
geekor
offline
offline
Punishing teams for doing badly and then stripping them of their players
-1
If a team tanks on purpose to game the caps (some team play all their guys OOP, etc) take the team away.
Very rarely do any of the bad teams with players over the cap end up winning something.
-1
If a team tanks on purpose to game the caps (some team play all their guys OOP, etc) take the team away.
Very rarely do any of the bad teams with players over the cap end up winning something.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























