User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Hagalaz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eldonko
3-8 record vs my 10-1 record. #1 guy does not seem to be helping THAT much. I suppose he is 1 of 11 real players on a CPU team though so compared to the team he is good. Does that warrant MVP?


You do not get it >_<

How important is THE PLAYER'S CONTRIBUTION to his team's performance.

Let's look at WRs for example. One has 10 TDs, and his team scored 100 TDs. The second one has 5 TDs and his team scored 10 TDs. The MVP award goes to number two, because he will have a higher contribution to his team, get it? I know there are other factors, but this is the one most commonly ignored, and the reason why so many people get surprised. DO NOT GET SURPRISED. It is easy to understand.
 
Eldonko
offline
Link
 
I think you are the one that doesnt get it. Did you read my last post? CPU players all suck and a human player on a CPU team will get the majority of the stats. Even if that player is terrible they wont be as bad as the CPU players. The point is this system doesnt work when your whole dam league is CPU teams.
 
Hagalaz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eldonko
I think you are the one that doesnt get it. Did you read my last post? CPU players all suck and a human player on a CPU team will get the majority of the stats. Even if that player is terrible they wont be as bad as the CPU players. The point is this system doesnt work when your whole dam league is CPU teams.


I read your post. But in a CPU team, he will not be MVP simply because he will not have tactics built around him and he will be misused. If you think otherwise, I have several seasons of MVP results to provide to prove it
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
eldonko, you are arguing logic, whilst hagalaz is arguing GLB. its arguing apples and oranges, and you both are right but the only one that matters is the glb reference. people have been bitching about the mvp calculations since the day they were implemented.

bort has said that he'd consider tweaking it based on a good suggestion but wont be revamping the whole system. the problem is that since we dont know how its currently calculated, its impossible to come up with a good suggestion.

so you need to realize that the mvp is really FUBAR and not worry about it like the rest of us have been forced to do.
 
Eldonko
offline
Link
 
fair enough, I guess Ill forget about it
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.