User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > now the LO loses his mind - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
mwindle
offline
Link
 
Seems to be a lot of discussion about why he was playing zone, but that's not the issue. Is that why it's being discussed? Is anyone questioning the obvious thing standing out here. Why did the LOLB suddenly run towards the strong side of the Oline and go behind the LOS when nobody was there? He was playing a middle zone and just took off for the locker rooms I assume. I guess this is just common place. It has been stated already that this play is not in the package for this situation. So how do we even know what the LOLB assignment was. THe bug is not the fact he played a zone. It's the fact that he didn't keep playing it!

Also why do we always have to find more examples. It's a problem, it happened, can't deny it. Are you suggesting that if we don't find more examples then it's not a problem? You don't really need more examples to determine that it is a problem. You need them to fix it. I for one am tired of Bort/GLB expecting it's users to do the foot work for them. It's not our job to do this. You know a problem exists. You have thousands of games to look through. Go right ahead and find more examples. I have to pay to play. If I got paid then I would look for more examples. Perhaps finding an effective way to identify, test & fix sim bugs, without so much input from the users would have been a better way to spend the time of the last 16 seasons, instead of changing training, EQ, and ever other aspect of the game you can think of in an attempt to stop people from building effective players.

It's great CS to insist that if the OPer doesn't find more examples then his issue is ignored. Could you imagine buying food at a restaurant, finding a bug in your food, only to have them respond that you need to provide more examples before it is clear it is actually a bug in your food?

Once again as I regularly post...no disrespect meant to Mods, only towards Admin. Really no disrespect meant on a personal basis...just an honest and due criticism of the lack professionalism of this game. I sometimes wonder if they realize that this is a business.
 
MC_Hammer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mwindle
It has been stated already that this play is not in the package for this situation. So how do we even know what the LOLB assignment was.


Not true, the play that was mentioned as not in the AI was the second link, NOT the one from the OP.
Similar =/= same.

Originally posted by mwindle
Also why do we always have to find more examples. It's a problem, it happened, can't deny it. Are you suggesting that if we don't find more examples then it's not a problem?


Because a bug is defined by the fact that it can be reproduced. A glitch/problem is not the same thing as a bug.
And for the record, noone is denying that there is a problem, only that it does not fit the bill as a bug until it can be proven to be replicated..... hence why it "needs more info".

Originally posted by mwindle

Once again as I regularly post...no disrespect meant to Mods, only towards Admin. Really no disrespect meant on a personal basis...just an honest and due criticism of the lack professionalism of this game.


If you are not intending any disrespect, then why do you continuously take a condescending tone? (serious question)
 
Talcion
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MC_Hammer
Originally posted by mwindle

It has been stated already that this play is not in the package for this situation. So how do we even know what the LOLB assignment was.


Not true, the play that was mentioned as not in the AI was the second link, NOT the one from the OP.
Similar =/= same.


The OP is posting FOR Johnbarber, therefore, is the same thing, not similar, not almost... The Same...
 
MC_Hammer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Talcion
Originally posted by MC_Hammer

Originally posted by mwindle


It has been stated already that this play is not in the package for this situation. So how do we even know what the LOLB assignment was.


Not true, the play that was mentioned as not in the AI was the second link, NOT the one from the OP.
Similar =/= same.


The OP is posting FOR Johnbarber, therefore, is the same thing, not similar, not almost... The Same...


Again not true and here is why....

Original post:

Originally posted by cosmoxl
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1215897&pbp_id=5784378

johnbarber, owner and dc, says LO is supposed to man TE or blitz if TE stays in to block.

well, that's not what happened here.

contact him, he'll get you access if you need it.


In post 3 on page 1 JB adds another play to the thread which is questioned by cosmoxyl in post 5.
In post 6 JB mentions that the SECOND linked play is not in his AI, he does NOT make reference to his linked play from the OP.
So again, it is NOT the same.

And for the record, I am a GM on the team in question also (the Guadalcanal Gunners).

 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
As there has been no further activity on this in 10 days, no further examples, and it has already been to QA and back, I'm gonna close this one out.

I don't believe this is a bug to begin with and the lack of any further evidence to the contrary seems to support that.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.