User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Sometimes the FS needs a little help when he is "walking the line":

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=8224013
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
This could be a pump fake, but it's strange how after the ball is in the air the CB stops and the WR continues to advanced to catch the ball.

CB has very good vision and agility

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=8227748
 
ironman4579
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by RAPB

I got a new favorite. It is called...

The runaway corner

The idea is, that the corner back runs away from his WR as fast as can be. To be effective, the CB not only has to go deep, but also towards the sideline. That way, the WR is wide open. It works perfectly!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7591674
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7591750
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7592155
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7592494
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7594510

Actually, that perfect play is screwed up by WRs going too deep. As the WR continues on his way, the CB is finally free from his assignment to make sure that the sideline is in good shape - so he starts to do his work and will catch up. Someone better makes that corner rush the sideline for another 10 yards to make it a really sure gainer!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7593043


It's called the CB is so much slower then the WR he has to go back to a point as to where he won't get beat long before being able to turn around. Not a bug, just a bad CB.



I completely disagree with you here. I've had my corner play the exact same coverage against a WR that I know he was much faster than because not only did the owner of the WR have his settings to "everyone can view," but my CB also ran him down from behind easily on one play, and pulled away from him easily after an INT on another play. It looks more like the sim is making the CB play outside leverage on the WR to force him to the middle of the field. If so, then fine, but then the sim is simming the play incorrectly. On outside leverage, either the safety would come over the top knowing that the CB is playing outside leverage to provide some help, which they never/almost never do until the ball is thrown that way, or the LB or DE would be dropping into zone in that direction to make the CB throw the ball over them to complatet a short pass. That play has nothing to do with the speed of the receiver.

And to be honest, even if by some miracle it did, it shouldn't be if the CB has his coverage to close coverage "stick like glue." If he gets beat it's his own fault, but the sim shouldn't be automatically dropping corners 10 yards off the ball because they "know the receivers way faster than they are."

And it's ridiculous anyway. It's just poor design of that one particular coverage. As an example:

Right CB takes outside leverage(which is what it is, and note that he has no inside help, as the LB is in man on the TE and the SS instantly rolls toward the other side of the field) apparently because the WR is way too fast:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7536732

Same CB, Same WR, this time he goes right at him and stays with him throughout the play.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7536732

Same CB, Same WR matched up. Goes at him again.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7537332

Same again. Receiver does not blow by him, shockingly

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7537332


I can go through the whole game, plus basically every other game if you'd like. But the bottom line is it's a broken coverage in the sim that needs to be fixed by either removing it or actually making the sim run the play correctly, with some inside help. There's no need for you to be insulting by declaring that the CB's are just "bad" and that's why they do it, when they don't do it on every play, or even close to every play.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
A lot of those "runaway" corners you posted look a lot like zone coverage. They drop back to a spot and then react (as intended)
Also they will only happen in a long pass coverage play, because that's the only time the CB's are really worried about getting beat.

The agility one has a lot to do with their current momentum. It's a lot easier to react if you're already moving in the same general direction. Plus in the one where it took a really long time it's possible that he got bumped into by the SS causing him to lose his balance.

On the ROLB vision is the problem. To see the HB he would have to look through 2 big guys. So instead he sees the hole created by the LG and assumes that the run will be coming from there and shifts over until he's able to see that the HB has gone to the outside.
 
Bearded
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=7702774

Their CB seems to follow the same path as our HB
 
ironman4579
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
A lot of those "runaway" corners you posted look a lot like zone coverage. They drop back to a spot and then react (as intended)
Also they will only happen in a long pass coverage play, because that's the only time the CB's are really worried about getting beat.

The agility one has a lot to do with their current momentum. It's a lot easier to react if you're already moving in the same general direction. Plus in the one where it took a really long time it's possible that he got bumped into by the SS causing him to lose his balance.

On the ROLB vision is the problem. To see the HB he would have to look through 2 big guys. So instead he sees the hole created by the LG and assumes that the run will be coming from there and shifts over until he's able to see that the HB has gone to the outside.


The other CB and LB are in man coverage so no, it's not because of zone coverage. And during that game we had it set to 0% zone coverage. Now I realize that even with CPU changes turned completely off, the sim will still slightly alter your game plan. However, that was during the first drive of the game, on the first or second play of the game. If the CPU is changing my gameplan that fast to something that I didn't want to occur at all, then that's also a bug that needs to be looked at. But regardless, it's not zone coverage. And also during that game, we had it set to 0% long coverage, so again, the sim shouldn't be doing something I specifically don't want it to do 1 or 2 plays into the game. It's off man, outside leverage coverage, simpe as that, and it's broken.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
It's a zone
a) the LB doesn't follow the TE once he gets past him just stays in that area
b) the RE is dropping back which only happens in zone
 
ironman4579
offline
Link
 
I don't really agree that the ends only drop in a zone, as I'm almost positive I can find a play in which the RE drops but the ROLB is in man coverage against the HB and the CB's are both in man, but you could be right about that.

However, in that case, that would be a bug in my opinion. The CPU shouldn't be throwing out a zone plus long coverage, both things that I specifically set to 0, 1 or 2 plays into the game, especially when the auto adjust was set to 0 for that game. And if it's a zone, it's still busted, because in any zone, you'd always have more than one player covering one whole half of the field, yet the safety is moving to the opposite side of the field right off the snap. My point is that while the coverage is technically an accurater coverage, the overall design of the coverage is flawed no matter if it's a man or a zone. My other point is that the if it is a zone, it should not be happening on the second play from scrimmage when I have zone set to 0, and the auto adjust set to 0. If that's the case, what's the point of making any game plan, as the CPU is going to adjust it 2 plays into the game.
Last edited Jun 27, 2008 16:36:17
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ironman4579
... It looks more like the sim is making the CB play outside leverage on the WR to force him to the middle of the field. If so, then fine, but then the sim is simming the play incorrectly. On outside leverage, either the safety would come over the top knowing that the CB is playing outside leverage to provide some help, which they never/almost never do until the ball is thrown that way, or the LB or DE would be dropping into zone in that direction to make the CB throw the ball over them to complatet a short pass. That play has nothing to do with the speed of the receiver.

And to be honest, even if by some miracle it did, it shouldn't be if the CB has his coverage to close coverage "stick like glue." If he gets beat it's his own fault, but the sim shouldn't be automatically dropping corners 10 yards off the ball because they "know the receivers way faster than they are."
...


Thats why I consider it still buggy and someone might look over the path someday.

As CB, it sure is sometimes a good idea to cut the WR off the outside. Just make sure, you stay a little more to the sideline. If the WR turns toward the sideline, you'd do the same and there you are - right in his route. But there is no reason to head towards the sideline if the WR is not turning there. In the "Runaway Corner" plays, the CB gets like 5 yards towards the sideline without any lateral movement of the WR (thats the most annoying part of this play).

It is a no brainer, that CBs like to keep some cushion between themselfes and their man sometimes. According to what play is expected, that cushion might be 3, 5 or even 7+ yards - but they don't want to keep that the entire play! That cushion is supposed to be "eaten up" during the play. The CB will watch the WR: Most routes have a cut/turn at 5 yd, 7 yd or 10 yd (otherwise it's a deep route). So the CB is backpedaling (thats MUCH slower than sprinting!) while watching WR (man coverage) or WR/QB/TE/RB (zone coverage). But the CB wants to make sure that he can start towards LOS anytime to cover that WR or any receiver thats threatening his zone. Basically: that cushion gives the CB more time to watch first before he has to turn and get close to the WR he decides to play. Now a "Runaway Corner" does the opposite: he doesn't eat up his cushion, he'd move at full speed (not possible while backpedaling!) and he is also moving laterally (towards the sideline) without reason - so he'd have an even harder time to turn towards LOS / his WR.

Now I guess, that the SIM probably has the CB dropping back to the middle of "his" zone - but that is executed no matter what. That's buggy. If there is noone else attacking his zone, he is supposed to play the (only) receiver there - not as close as man coverage, but close enough to get to him in time. Zone is not about not beeing able to do anything and just preventing the worst (the big play). Zone is about not assigning a certain defender to a certain receiver and therefore keeping the defender in a position where he can react immediatly towards anyone attacking his zone (a CB wants to make sure his momentum is not preventing him from doing so!). But that Runaway Corners give up 8-10 yards every time because they are not even in a position to defend anytime soon.
Last edited Jun 27, 2008 17:35:16
 
ironman4579
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB




Now I guess, that the SIM probably has the CB dropping back to the middle of "his" zone - but that is executed no matter what. That's buggy. If there is noone else attacking his zone, he is supposed to play the (only) receiver there - not as close as man coverage, but close enough to get to him in time. Zone is not about not beeing able to do anything and just preventing the worst (the big play). Zone is about not assigning a certain defender to a certain receiver and therefore keeping the defender in a position where he can react immediatly towards anyone attacking his zone (a CB wants to make sure his momentum is not preventing him from doing so!). But that Runaway Corners give up 8-10 yards every time because they are not even in a position to defend anytime soon.


Exactly. I'm not necessarily saying that it's a "bug." What I am saying is that the play is being run incorrectly by the sim from the outset. It's designed wrong.

And I'd still say that no team would have one player in zone coverage watching one whole half of the field either. The safety on that side would never be rolling to the opposite side of the field right off the snap. So we'd have one guy covering an entire half of the field with the other 3-5 guys covering the other half? On that play both safeties rolled to the right side off the snap, plus the RE dropped into coverage. So we had one guy on one side and 4 guys covering the other? That's a fairly poorly designed zone. And again, the zone % was set to 0, so they shouldn't have been playing zone anyway on the first or second play of the game.
Last edited Jun 28, 2008 10:42:38
 
Raider5280
offline
Link
 
I hate more when my CB gets put off the line 5 yds & gives up that quick lil 5 on 3rd & 2.

I agree completely that the zone is crap.
When I played Zone...I COVERED THE GUY THAT CAME INTO MY ZONE
running to a spot was what we did in pee-wee.
 
Raider5280
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Raider5280
I hate more when my CB gets put off the line 5 yds & gives up that quick lil 5 on 3rd & 2.

I agree completely that the zone is crap.
When I played Zone...I COVERED THE GUY THAT CAME INTO MY ZONE
running to a spot was what we did in pee-wee.


Case in point...this mornings games.....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=8332956

@ LEAST HE GETS TO HIS "SPOT"!

 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Why won't anyone admit that something is wrong?

It's very obvious that there is something funny about the majority of these plays, and besides that, I've seen my own CB perform the same way against lesser WRs.

It doesn't make sense, it definitely looks like a bug and I think we deserve a little more than the standard reply.

This happens in almost every game. How much more often does it need to take place, for someone to actually say that it's not supposed to be ran like that?
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Another "Waterbreak" corner:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=8315663

(got his stats open; he sure lacks agility - but thats ridiculous. Have him stop first and then go for the runner)


And I recently scouted another strange play, I like to call "TE'll touchdown". The idea is to not cover the TE at all when it comes to red zone defense.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=8679949
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=8680903
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Last edited Jun 30, 2008 23:49:25
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.