Would you make OC, DC of the year trophies?
TallyDawg
offline
offline
I am on the road this week for work, but once, I get back in town on Friday I will get an OC and DC award drawn up as well. Also, I tried (see pasted email below):
__________________________________________________________
I'm sorry, at this point there isn't a way to add in a mvp or coaching awards. Some day in the future we my expand into this.
-Thorn
---------- Original message ----------
From: TallyDawg
Date: Jun 16, 2008 12:39:12
Subject: Season Awards
To: Thorn
To whom it may concern:
I have just a quick question. I am familiar with the seasonal awards for key positions and stats. However, many leagues also take part in voting for MVPs at positions as well as an overall league MVP.
Oceania AA #1 formerly Ociania A) is no different. For the first two seasons, we have just done voting and announced the winners (more or less for bragging rights). However, for season three I have gone ahead and generated some jpg awards that the winners can use for their avatars/player profile images.
My question is if moderators can upload these awards onto the awards pages for those players who are voted in as MVPs? I know it might be difficult to do and also there is the issue of if one league does it, it would have to be streamlined across the board for all leagues (which can be time consuming). But it would be nice to see who received MVP awards each season by their own league peers.
If you are curious of the awards: I have uploaded two sample images to photobucket:
http://i302.photobucket.com/albums/nn90/TallyDawg1/Coach.jpg
http://i302.photobucket.com/albums/nn90/TallyDawg1/MVP.jpg
My plan is to add in the players name to each individual award upon the completion of voting. Whether they can be included on the awards page or not: I will respect your decision, and appreciate your taking the time to answer this.
-TallyDawg (Jeff)-
_____________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________
I'm sorry, at this point there isn't a way to add in a mvp or coaching awards. Some day in the future we my expand into this.
-Thorn
---------- Original message ----------
From: TallyDawg
Date: Jun 16, 2008 12:39:12
Subject: Season Awards
To: Thorn
To whom it may concern:
I have just a quick question. I am familiar with the seasonal awards for key positions and stats. However, many leagues also take part in voting for MVPs at positions as well as an overall league MVP.
Oceania AA #1 formerly Ociania A) is no different. For the first two seasons, we have just done voting and announced the winners (more or less for bragging rights). However, for season three I have gone ahead and generated some jpg awards that the winners can use for their avatars/player profile images.
My question is if moderators can upload these awards onto the awards pages for those players who are voted in as MVPs? I know it might be difficult to do and also there is the issue of if one league does it, it would have to be streamlined across the board for all leagues (which can be time consuming). But it would be nice to see who received MVP awards each season by their own league peers.
If you are curious of the awards: I have uploaded two sample images to photobucket:
http://i302.photobucket.com/albums/nn90/TallyDawg1/Coach.jpg
http://i302.photobucket.com/albums/nn90/TallyDawg1/MVP.jpg
My plan is to add in the players name to each individual award upon the completion of voting. Whether they can be included on the awards page or not: I will respect your decision, and appreciate your taking the time to answer this.
-TallyDawg (Jeff)-
_____________________________________________________________________
NavyGiant
offline
offline
Tally great work. I was just wondering (hoping) you would lay out the voting system that we ALL will follow. I know last year there were a lot of disagreements on voting for All-Pro's.
Semineer
offline
offline
Originally posted by Develop
How are we gonna vote on FBs?
Most productive. Pancakes, YPC, TD's, First Downs, Broken Tackles....
How are we gonna vote on FBs?
Most productive. Pancakes, YPC, TD's, First Downs, Broken Tackles....
Last edited Jun 18, 2008 08:52:28
Develop
offline
offline
Originally posted by Semineer
Originally posted by Develop
How are we gonna vote on FBs?
Most productive. Pancakes, YPC, TD's, First Downs, Broken Tackles....
FBs=/=HBs
Originally posted by Develop
How are we gonna vote on FBs?
Most productive. Pancakes, YPC, TD's, First Downs, Broken Tackles....
FBs=/=HBs
Semineer
offline
offline
Originally posted by Develop
Originally posted by Semineer
Originally posted by Develop
How are we gonna vote on FBs?
Most productive. Pancakes, YPC, TD's, First Downs, Broken Tackles....
FBs=/=HBs
Thanks Captain Obvious. You can only judge based on what they do, which is what I listed. FB's can have one of two roles...a blocker or a power runner, or even both. Pancakes are important when blocking. What's important for a power running FB? YPC, Broken Tackles, TD's, First Downs (like 3rd and short), broken tackles to get those FD's and TD's. It's really not that hard.
Originally posted by Semineer
Originally posted by Develop
How are we gonna vote on FBs?
Most productive. Pancakes, YPC, TD's, First Downs, Broken Tackles....
FBs=/=HBs
Thanks Captain Obvious. You can only judge based on what they do, which is what I listed. FB's can have one of two roles...a blocker or a power runner, or even both. Pancakes are important when blocking. What's important for a power running FB? YPC, Broken Tackles, TD's, First Downs (like 3rd and short), broken tackles to get those FD's and TD's. It's really not that hard.
52500
offline
offline
we dont need to vote, its phillip fredrick every time. so that saves us some effort later.
TallyDawg
offline
offline
A little further into the season, I'll generate a thread for discussing/plugging of players for the awards. About 1 or 2 games after that I'll open up a voting thread as well. This way we can keep the vote thread and discussion seperate. Once you vote, feel free to edit your original vote message if you decide to make any changes to your original vote. This will make it easier to count up the final votes from each person. But, I'll make it a little clearer when the thread opens.
As for the positions, I leave how you vote for each position up to the individual. Just like in RL you have people who merely vote based on player popularity, others vote on skill/experience, and others go by the season stats. In my view: to limit what you are using to vote for each position would actually hinder the voting process. But, thats JMHO.
As for the positions, I leave how you vote for each position up to the individual. Just like in RL you have people who merely vote based on player popularity, others vote on skill/experience, and others go by the season stats. In my view: to limit what you are using to vote for each position would actually hinder the voting process. But, thats JMHO.
Drunzer
offline
offline
Originally posted by 52500
we dont need to vote, its phillip fredrick every time. so that saves us some effort later.
I dunno about that there's a fullback on the Nightmare called Gene Parmesan who might have something to say about that
we dont need to vote, its phillip fredrick every time. so that saves us some effort later.
I dunno about that there's a fullback on the Nightmare called Gene Parmesan who might have something to say about that
52500
offline
offline
you know what he has to say "blaaargh. phillip fredrick is better than me in every way, up to and including his need for human sacrifice."
kapouchet
offline
offline
How about a Captain Crunch trophy, it's the only trophy I could win because I don't think I could win a HB award even with this great season.
deasterling32
offline
offline
What about a seperate "Shutdown Corner" Award. I know my CB doesnt get the stats because they've only thrown his way 13 times this year through 7 games. Of those 13 he's deflected 11, Intercepted 1 and allowed 1 completion and even then he was covering the WR, the TE and the Fb in the flats. This may hard to track, but we could nominate one per team and then narrow it down. It may not be my guy who gets it, but i know there are other CB's out there who are good at shutting thier side of the ball down(including run stopping) but wont ever see an award. Champ Bailey is considered one of the best CB's of all time and his stats will never show it. Just an idea.
MrMoose
offline
offline
Originally posted by deasterling32
What about a seperate "Shutdown Corner" Award. I know my CB doesnt get the stats because they've only thrown his way 13 times this year through 7 games. Of those 13 he's deflected 11, Intercepted 1 and allowed 1 completion and even then he was covering the WR, the TE and the Fb in the flats. This may hard to track, but we could nominate one per team and then narrow it down. It may not be my guy who gets it, but i know there are other CB's out there who are good at shutting thier side of the ball down(including run stopping) but wont ever see an award. Champ Bailey is considered one of the best CB's of all time and his stats will never show it. Just an idea.
Oh god, not this discussion again
We do not have the stats we need to prove this kind of stuff at this point. We would have to watch every single play of every single game to see how many times the corner has been thrown to, how many of those passes were caught, etc. I don't think there will be a need for a separate trophy when we get these stats -- you'll just vote for who you think is the best. Plus, there's still the argument I made last year -- is it fair to penalize the players on teams with good corners all around? People have to pass somewhere and all. Not to mention, teams that get ahead early will have all of their corners getting tons of passes tossed their way due to the catch-up AI.
No offense intended at all to Papeete, since I think you all are cool guys, but you really haven't blown anyone out this year, so there will be less passes in general thrown your way. Teams that get ahead early will have more passes thrown against them.
What about a seperate "Shutdown Corner" Award. I know my CB doesnt get the stats because they've only thrown his way 13 times this year through 7 games. Of those 13 he's deflected 11, Intercepted 1 and allowed 1 completion and even then he was covering the WR, the TE and the Fb in the flats. This may hard to track, but we could nominate one per team and then narrow it down. It may not be my guy who gets it, but i know there are other CB's out there who are good at shutting thier side of the ball down(including run stopping) but wont ever see an award. Champ Bailey is considered one of the best CB's of all time and his stats will never show it. Just an idea.
Oh god, not this discussion again
We do not have the stats we need to prove this kind of stuff at this point. We would have to watch every single play of every single game to see how many times the corner has been thrown to, how many of those passes were caught, etc. I don't think there will be a need for a separate trophy when we get these stats -- you'll just vote for who you think is the best. Plus, there's still the argument I made last year -- is it fair to penalize the players on teams with good corners all around? People have to pass somewhere and all. Not to mention, teams that get ahead early will have all of their corners getting tons of passes tossed their way due to the catch-up AI.
No offense intended at all to Papeete, since I think you all are cool guys, but you really haven't blown anyone out this year, so there will be less passes in general thrown your way. Teams that get ahead early will have more passes thrown against them.
Last edited Jun 25, 2008 10:31:50
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.
