+1. loopholes abound.
Forum > Suggestions > Fix the Promotion System
Empire_Strikes_Back
offline
offline
+1 System is flawed at this time.
Agree with the solutions put forward: your highest level player defines the minimum cap you can fit under.
Agree with the solutions put forward: your highest level player defines the minimum cap you can fit under.
Sprocket
offline
offline
Originally posted by Empire_Strikes_Back
+1 System is flawed at this time.
Agree with the solutions put forward: your highest level player defines the minimum cap you can fit under.
Oh, but this is way too easy. It HAS to be more complicated than that.
Seriously, I thought this was how it was supposed to be to begin with.
+1 System is flawed at this time.
Agree with the solutions put forward: your highest level player defines the minimum cap you can fit under.
Oh, but this is way too easy. It HAS to be more complicated than that.
Seriously, I thought this was how it was supposed to be to begin with.
Clarka3
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sprocket
Oh, but this is way too easy. It HAS to be more complicated than that.
Seriously, I thought this was how it was supposed to be to begin with.
well, the reason for the changes was ease for processing promotions/demotions for the staff. In theory it's a great idea- if everybody played correctly. However, there's no penalty for teams tanking season after season- and the teams that are underleveled but trying to win end up making the playoffs and are then penalized even further because they get a 2 cap jump while they're already low and the good teams that are losing on purpose only get the 1 cap jump.
So, easier for the site, worse for the users.
Oh, but this is way too easy. It HAS to be more complicated than that.
Seriously, I thought this was how it was supposed to be to begin with.
well, the reason for the changes was ease for processing promotions/demotions for the staff. In theory it's a great idea- if everybody played correctly. However, there's no penalty for teams tanking season after season- and the teams that are underleveled but trying to win end up making the playoffs and are then penalized even further because they get a 2 cap jump while they're already low and the good teams that are losing on purpose only get the 1 cap jump.
So, easier for the site, worse for the users.
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
Bleh... just do away with the cap system altogether. It's causing more problems than it solves, imo.
amace
offline
offline
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Bleh... just do away with the cap system altogether. It's causing more problems than it solves, imo.
that wouldn't help. What would you do then, have level 11 players up against level 50's? Hardly helpful.
We need caps, just make them hardcaps. If you have a player over a cap, when it comes to promotion time, you go up until that player fits in the proper cap, or you release that player and go to the cap that works the bvest for you.
Bleh... just do away with the cap system altogether. It's causing more problems than it solves, imo.
that wouldn't help. What would you do then, have level 11 players up against level 50's? Hardly helpful.
We need caps, just make them hardcaps. If you have a player over a cap, when it comes to promotion time, you go up until that player fits in the proper cap, or you release that player and go to the cap that works the bvest for you.
Clarka3
offline
offline
Originally posted by amace
that wouldn't help. What would you do then, have level 11 players up against level 50's? Hardly helpful.
We need caps, just make them hardcaps. If you have a player over a cap, when it comes to promotion time, you go up until that player fits in the proper cap, or you release that player and go to the cap that works the bvest for you.
this.
here's the thread from previous discussion on the subject.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4003442&page=1
that wouldn't help. What would you do then, have level 11 players up against level 50's? Hardly helpful.
We need caps, just make them hardcaps. If you have a player over a cap, when it comes to promotion time, you go up until that player fits in the proper cap, or you release that player and go to the cap that works the bvest for you.
this.
here's the thread from previous discussion on the subject.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4003442&page=1
chief c
offline
offline
-1
No, gaming the system will always be part of the game. We all know there are teams out there that play all the angles and we just have to learn to deal with them. It would be one thing if there was a secret that not everyone knew about. But its a given in this system that if you want to tank a season you can do it for whatever reason. Frankly, I think its karmic and what goes around comes around. If you tank a season on purpose just to totally dominate the next cap level league, somebody, like my team is apt to surprise and upset your scheming butt. Now your agents are doubly demoralized, because of no success for TWO seasons and they start to bail. I've always taken the Herm Edwards approach to sports.
"You play the Game to Win!"
(no one can say he was great at it, but you gotta believe in his professionalism)
-
So quit the nancy boy whining stuff and deal with it.
No, gaming the system will always be part of the game. We all know there are teams out there that play all the angles and we just have to learn to deal with them. It would be one thing if there was a secret that not everyone knew about. But its a given in this system that if you want to tank a season you can do it for whatever reason. Frankly, I think its karmic and what goes around comes around. If you tank a season on purpose just to totally dominate the next cap level league, somebody, like my team is apt to surprise and upset your scheming butt. Now your agents are doubly demoralized, because of no success for TWO seasons and they start to bail. I've always taken the Herm Edwards approach to sports.
"You play the Game to Win!"
(no one can say he was great at it, but you gotta believe in his professionalism)
-
So quit the nancy boy whining stuff and deal with it.
amace
offline
offline
Originally posted by chief c
-1
No, gaming the system will always be part of the game. We all know there are teams out there that play all the angles and we just have to learn to deal with them. It would be one thing if there was a secret that not everyone knew about. But its a given in this system that if you want to tank a season you can do it for whatever reason. Frankly, I think its karmic and what goes around comes around. If you tank a season on purpose just to totally dominate the next cap level league, somebody, like my team is apt to surprise and upset your scheming butt. Now your agents are doubly demoralized, because of no success for TWO seasons and they start to bail. I've always taken the Herm Edwards approach to sports.
"You play the Game to Win!"
(no one can say he was great at it, but you gotta believe in his professionalism)
-
So quit the nancy boy whining stuff and deal with it.
are you high?
In no level of sport anywhere, can somebody blow three seasons, stay in the same league then kill the competition.
Thats like a high school team keeping the same kids, but going 0-10 each season for 7 years, then they have a bunch of 21 year old kids playing 17 year olds and blow them out of the water. Does that make any sense?
-1
No, gaming the system will always be part of the game. We all know there are teams out there that play all the angles and we just have to learn to deal with them. It would be one thing if there was a secret that not everyone knew about. But its a given in this system that if you want to tank a season you can do it for whatever reason. Frankly, I think its karmic and what goes around comes around. If you tank a season on purpose just to totally dominate the next cap level league, somebody, like my team is apt to surprise and upset your scheming butt. Now your agents are doubly demoralized, because of no success for TWO seasons and they start to bail. I've always taken the Herm Edwards approach to sports.
"You play the Game to Win!"
(no one can say he was great at it, but you gotta believe in his professionalism)
-
So quit the nancy boy whining stuff and deal with it.
are you high?
In no level of sport anywhere, can somebody blow three seasons, stay in the same league then kill the competition.
Thats like a high school team keeping the same kids, but going 0-10 each season for 7 years, then they have a bunch of 21 year old kids playing 17 year olds and blow them out of the water. Does that make any sense?
chief c
offline
offline
Originally posted by amace
are you high?
In no level of sport anywhere, can somebody blow three seasons, stay in the same league then kill the competition.
Thats like a high school team keeping the same kids, but going 0-10 each season for 7 years, then they have a bunch of 21 year old kids playing 17 year olds and blow them out of the water. Does that make any sense?
Different subject altogether.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3998823&page=2
are you high?
In no level of sport anywhere, can somebody blow three seasons, stay in the same league then kill the competition.
Thats like a high school team keeping the same kids, but going 0-10 each season for 7 years, then they have a bunch of 21 year old kids playing 17 year olds and blow them out of the water. Does that make any sense?
Different subject altogether.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3998823&page=2
Originally posted by chief c
-1
No, gaming the system will always be part of the game. We all know there are teams out there that play all the angles and we just have to learn to deal with them. It would be one thing if there was a secret that not everyone knew about. But its a given in this system that if you want to tank a season you can do it for whatever reason. Frankly, I think its karmic and what goes around comes around. If you tank a season on purpose just to totally dominate the next cap level league, somebody, like my team is apt to surprise and upset your scheming butt. Now your agents are doubly demoralized, because of no success for TWO seasons and they start to bail. I've always taken the Herm Edwards approach to sports.
"You play the Game to Win!"
(no one can say he was great at it, but you gotta believe in his professionalism)
-
So quit the nancy boy whining stuff and deal with it.
You own a level 4 team sir and I own a level 15 team that is in the league that the OP team is in.
How about this, how about you take your level 4 team and scrimmage my level 15, league champions, tournament champions never lost a game Maryville Truckers. Let's see what the out come is. THAT IS THE SAME THING THAT IS GOING ON HERE. They out level everyone by 8-9 levels. Same as we do you.
We play to win, obviously. But you can not win if you are the local high school playing against the New England Patriots.
-1
No, gaming the system will always be part of the game. We all know there are teams out there that play all the angles and we just have to learn to deal with them. It would be one thing if there was a secret that not everyone knew about. But its a given in this system that if you want to tank a season you can do it for whatever reason. Frankly, I think its karmic and what goes around comes around. If you tank a season on purpose just to totally dominate the next cap level league, somebody, like my team is apt to surprise and upset your scheming butt. Now your agents are doubly demoralized, because of no success for TWO seasons and they start to bail. I've always taken the Herm Edwards approach to sports.
"You play the Game to Win!"
(no one can say he was great at it, but you gotta believe in his professionalism)
-
So quit the nancy boy whining stuff and deal with it.
You own a level 4 team sir and I own a level 15 team that is in the league that the OP team is in.
How about this, how about you take your level 4 team and scrimmage my level 15, league champions, tournament champions never lost a game Maryville Truckers. Let's see what the out come is. THAT IS THE SAME THING THAT IS GOING ON HERE. They out level everyone by 8-9 levels. Same as we do you.
We play to win, obviously. But you can not win if you are the local high school playing against the New England Patriots.
toobad4u_00
offline
offline
Originally posted by amace
high levels =|= good dots
should be high levels <> good dots?
high levels =|= good dots
should be high levels <> good dots?
Edited by toobad4u_00 on May 19, 2010 13:51:34
The Other Football
offline
offline
Originally posted by chief c
-1
No, gaming the system will always be part of the game. We all know there are teams out there that play all the angles and we just have to learn to deal with them. It would be one thing if there was a secret that not everyone knew about. But its a given in this system that if you want to tank a season you can do it for whatever reason. Frankly, I think its karmic and what goes around comes around. If you tank a season on purpose just to totally dominate the next cap level league, somebody, like my team is apt to surprise and upset your scheming butt. Now your agents are doubly demoralized, because of no success for TWO seasons and they start to bail. I've always taken the Herm Edwards approach to sports.
"You play the Game to Win!"
(no one can say he was great at it, but you gotta believe in his professionalism)
-
So quit the nancy boy whining stuff and deal with it.
First of all, Herm was and is a piece of shit...period.
Second, you taking his approach...and this other BS with a Cap 4 "trying to learn the game" crap means that you have absolutely no room to speak...period.
Go game plan your season and come back when you actually have enough time to realize how stupid you sound.
-1
No, gaming the system will always be part of the game. We all know there are teams out there that play all the angles and we just have to learn to deal with them. It would be one thing if there was a secret that not everyone knew about. But its a given in this system that if you want to tank a season you can do it for whatever reason. Frankly, I think its karmic and what goes around comes around. If you tank a season on purpose just to totally dominate the next cap level league, somebody, like my team is apt to surprise and upset your scheming butt. Now your agents are doubly demoralized, because of no success for TWO seasons and they start to bail. I've always taken the Herm Edwards approach to sports.
"You play the Game to Win!"
(no one can say he was great at it, but you gotta believe in his professionalism)
-
So quit the nancy boy whining stuff and deal with it.
First of all, Herm was and is a piece of shit...period.
Second, you taking his approach...and this other BS with a Cap 4 "trying to learn the game" crap means that you have absolutely no room to speak...period.
Go game plan your season and come back when you actually have enough time to realize how stupid you sound.
VenomCoach
offline
offline
Originally posted by The Other Football
First of all, Herm was and is a piece of shit...period.
Second, you taking his approach...and this other BS with a Cap 4 "trying to learn the game" crap means that you have absolutely no room to speak...period.
Go game plan your season and come back when you actually have enough time to realize how stupid you sound.
Don't poke fun at guys who actually try and win. It comes off wrong when it comes from a guy who cheers when the magic sponge comes on the field, pitch or em place where nothing happens until penalty kicks.
First of all, Herm was and is a piece of shit...period.
Second, you taking his approach...and this other BS with a Cap 4 "trying to learn the game" crap means that you have absolutely no room to speak...period.
Go game plan your season and come back when you actually have enough time to realize how stupid you sound.
Don't poke fun at guys who actually try and win. It comes off wrong when it comes from a guy who cheers when the magic sponge comes on the field, pitch or em place where nothing happens until penalty kicks.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























