That combined with the HUGE roster limits and making so many changes folks are retiring guys well before they're useful and it's one huge mess. I know you guys carry 55, but seriously, you'd be just as good with 45. We never go above 45 and have run off stretches where we only lost 5 games in 3 seasons.
comicfanman
offline
offline
Saipan Sin-Eaters are back for another shot and hopefully a more competitive team this season.
beenlurken
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ruger7mmmag
That combined with the HUGE roster limits and making so many changes folks are retiring guys well before they're useful and it's one huge mess. I know you guys carry 55, but seriously, you'd be just as good with 45. We never go above 45 and have run off stretches where we only lost 5 games in 3 seasons.
I expect better out of someone who has been around this game as long as you have. They would be nowhere near as good with 45 players as they are with 55.
Show me 3 consecutive seasons where Oberon has only lost 5 games during that span.
55 roster limit is not the problem...
That combined with the HUGE roster limits and making so many changes folks are retiring guys well before they're useful and it's one huge mess. I know you guys carry 55, but seriously, you'd be just as good with 45. We never go above 45 and have run off stretches where we only lost 5 games in 3 seasons.
I expect better out of someone who has been around this game as long as you have. They would be nowhere near as good with 45 players as they are with 55.
Show me 3 consecutive seasons where Oberon has only lost 5 games during that span.55 roster limit is not the problem...
Ruger7mmmag
offline
offline
We had 45 when we went 22-1 here in AAA a few seasons ago with the only loss being to OffTopica which sucked bc we had beaten them in the regular season. It wasn't bc we had 45 that season that we lost either, it was an incredibly crazy sim. You seriously don't need 55 players to have a good team on here if you recruit your 45 well.
If you take 10 players off every team in WL alone, it would make for better PRO and AAA leagues and would stop many teams from going CPU early in the season as they'd actually be more competitive top to bottom. There are guys who get very little playing time on those 55 player rosters that could be big contributors on other teams. Some teams are better than others in utilizing their players, but look how many TEs and WRs on some of those teams end the year averaging less than 1-2 receptions per game when they could easily be a 30-40 catch guy at the same level.
Anyway, not worth arguing. Plenty of other crazy stuff in this game happening right now.
If you take 10 players off every team in WL alone, it would make for better PRO and AAA leagues and would stop many teams from going CPU early in the season as they'd actually be more competitive top to bottom. There are guys who get very little playing time on those 55 player rosters that could be big contributors on other teams. Some teams are better than others in utilizing their players, but look how many TEs and WRs on some of those teams end the year averaging less than 1-2 receptions per game when they could easily be a 30-40 catch guy at the same level.
Anyway, not worth arguing. Plenty of other crazy stuff in this game happening right now.
beenlurken
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ruger7mmmag
We had 45 when we went 22-1 here in AAA a few seasons ago with the only loss being to OffTopica which sucked bc we had beaten them in the regular season. It wasn't bc we had 45 that season that we lost either, it was an incredibly crazy sim. You seriously don't need 55 players to have a good team on here if you recruit your 45 well.
If you take 10 players off every team in WL alone, it would make for better PRO and AAA leagues and would stop many teams from going CPU early in the season as they'd actually be more competitive top to bottom. There are guys who get very little playing time on those 55 player rosters that could be big contributors on other teams. Some teams are better than others in utilizing their players, but look how many TEs and WRs on some of those teams end the year averaging less than 1-2 receptions per game when they could easily be a 30-40 catch guy at the same level.
Anyway, not worth arguing. Plenty of other crazy stuff in this game happening right now.

To try and change your paradigm... why do you automatically assume a meaningful season for a TE and WR = receptions?
We had 45 when we went 22-1 here in AAA a few seasons ago with the only loss being to OffTopica which sucked bc we had beaten them in the regular season. It wasn't bc we had 45 that season that we lost either, it was an incredibly crazy sim. You seriously don't need 55 players to have a good team on here if you recruit your 45 well.
If you take 10 players off every team in WL alone, it would make for better PRO and AAA leagues and would stop many teams from going CPU early in the season as they'd actually be more competitive top to bottom. There are guys who get very little playing time on those 55 player rosters that could be big contributors on other teams. Some teams are better than others in utilizing their players, but look how many TEs and WRs on some of those teams end the year averaging less than 1-2 receptions per game when they could easily be a 30-40 catch guy at the same level.
Anyway, not worth arguing. Plenty of other crazy stuff in this game happening right now.

To try and change your paradigm... why do you automatically assume a meaningful season for a TE and WR = receptions?
Ruger7mmmag
offline
offline
The same way I assume that QBs were meant to throw the ball and RBs to run the ball and LBs to make tackles. Seriously, who the heck builds a WR to catch one pass a game?
Last season here, we had very few games decided by less than 50 points and that's due to the lack of talent to support these leagues. Take those benchwarmers, put them on those lesser teams and we'd actually have some competitive games all season long...
That's my opinion is all and we all know about opinions...
Last season here, we had very few games decided by less than 50 points and that's due to the lack of talent to support these leagues. Take those benchwarmers, put them on those lesser teams and we'd actually have some competitive games all season long...
That's my opinion is all and we all know about opinions...
MC_Hammer
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ruger7mmmag
The same way I assume that QBs were meant to throw the ball and RBs to run the ball and LBs to make tackles. Seriously, who the heck builds a WR to catch one pass a game?
Last season here, we had very few games decided by less than 50 points and that's due to the lack of talent to support these leagues. Take those benchwarmers, put them on those lesser teams and we'd actually have some competitive games all season long...
That's my opinion is all and we all know about opinions...
Anyone with a WR under level 40?
But seriously, there are some agents that build really good blocking WRs for running teams.
The same way I assume that QBs were meant to throw the ball and RBs to run the ball and LBs to make tackles. Seriously, who the heck builds a WR to catch one pass a game?
Last season here, we had very few games decided by less than 50 points and that's due to the lack of talent to support these leagues. Take those benchwarmers, put them on those lesser teams and we'd actually have some competitive games all season long...
That's my opinion is all and we all know about opinions...
Anyone with a WR under level 40?

But seriously, there are some agents that build really good blocking WRs for running teams.
Ruger7mmmag
offline
offline
I know those guys exist. I'm talking about the players built to catch passes. Anyway, my point still stands, look at the scores from last season. Very few games were even remotely entertaining.
MC_Hammer
offline
offline
My personal TEs have no desire to catch passes (although they sometimes do).
They are built to take out blitzing LBs/SSs and run block like mad men.
The non-competitive games had less to do with 55 man rosters than with so many agents quitting between S13 and S15.
They are built to take out blitzing LBs/SSs and run block like mad men.
The non-competitive games had less to do with 55 man rosters than with so many agents quitting between S13 and S15.
Ruger7mmmag
offline
offline
If you want more competitive games when there is a less supply of agents, you need to put more agents into the system, IE smaller roster sizes.
I had no problem with the roster sizes when this game was kicking. But when all those changes turned folks off, it was plain to see there was going to be a massive shortage which was going to be seen the most in AAA and I was dead on. It's probably going to be worse this season if recruiting is any indication. I'm seeing players sign with WL teams that wouldn't have been signed by AAA teams just two seasons ago.
What's even scarier, there's still a number of teams in WL and PRO that have slots left to fill.
The new changes I'm afraid are going to turn off more people than draw people to the game IMHO. It's about become impossible for one person to run a team which is what made this game great to start and got people wanting to join. Would be interested to see how many of the new agents are being generated by actual $$$ being infused vs. recycling of flex...
I had no problem with the roster sizes when this game was kicking. But when all those changes turned folks off, it was plain to see there was going to be a massive shortage which was going to be seen the most in AAA and I was dead on. It's probably going to be worse this season if recruiting is any indication. I'm seeing players sign with WL teams that wouldn't have been signed by AAA teams just two seasons ago.
What's even scarier, there's still a number of teams in WL and PRO that have slots left to fill.
The new changes I'm afraid are going to turn off more people than draw people to the game IMHO. It's about become impossible for one person to run a team which is what made this game great to start and got people wanting to join. Would be interested to see how many of the new agents are being generated by actual $$$ being infused vs. recycling of flex...
beenlurken
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ruger7mmmag
If you want more competitive games when there is a less supply of agents, you need to put more agents into the system, IE smaller roster sizes.
Your solution to low supply of agents is the worst possible solution. Decreasing the roster limit would be the death blow to Special Teams and STOP players. Why do you want to kill Special Teams?
The best way to address these supply issues is to first change the league structure (Bort overexpanded the leagues)... reduce the amount teams within this new structure (problem is that there are too many teams... not the other way around)... and finally have longer "true" plateau (this increases player population at the higher levels).
If you want more competitive games when there is a less supply of agents, you need to put more agents into the system, IE smaller roster sizes.
Your solution to low supply of agents is the worst possible solution. Decreasing the roster limit would be the death blow to Special Teams and STOP players. Why do you want to kill Special Teams?
The best way to address these supply issues is to first change the league structure (Bort overexpanded the leagues)... reduce the amount teams within this new structure (problem is that there are too many teams... not the other way around)... and finally have longer "true" plateau (this increases player population at the higher levels).
Ruger7mmmag
offline
offline
I'm open to anything bc the FA pool we're all pulling for at this level is only getting worse to the point where folks don't know where there player really fits. It's got everyone thinking their dot is WL ready as soon as they hit the 200 day mark. lol
Oh well. Wasted enough time on this subject. Need to figure out this ticket thing now...sold ZERO tickets yesterday...So I guess the 1.5 thing was true! lol
Oh well. Wasted enough time on this subject. Need to figure out this ticket thing now...sold ZERO tickets yesterday...So I guess the 1.5 thing was true! lol
Justargos
offline
offline
Originally posted by beenlurken
Your solution to low supply of agents is the worst possible solution. Decreasing the roster limit would be the death blow to Special Teams and STOP players. Why do you want to kill Special Teams?
The best way to address these supply issues is to first change the league structure (Bort overexpanded the leagues)... reduce the amount teams within this new structure (problem is that there are too many teams... not the other way around)... and finally have longer "true" plateau (this increases player population at the higher levels).
I do see the roster size limit as a helper tool. The NFL essentially runs with a 45 man roster, the official size is 53, but they have to declare 8 players inactive each week. If the NFL can do it then an NFL simulator ought to be able to as well, especially since we don't have to worry about injuries.
This would essentially free up 10 more players per team that could be signed by other teams looking for players. This would eliminate 7-8 teams that can't recruit and go CPU each season in each league. We hardly ever go above 50 on my team, but we could run just fine with 45 players, we sign more because we can, but being at 45 would not cripple us, especially if everyone else was there as well.
Your solution to low supply of agents is the worst possible solution. Decreasing the roster limit would be the death blow to Special Teams and STOP players. Why do you want to kill Special Teams?
The best way to address these supply issues is to first change the league structure (Bort overexpanded the leagues)... reduce the amount teams within this new structure (problem is that there are too many teams... not the other way around)... and finally have longer "true" plateau (this increases player population at the higher levels).
I do see the roster size limit as a helper tool. The NFL essentially runs with a 45 man roster, the official size is 53, but they have to declare 8 players inactive each week. If the NFL can do it then an NFL simulator ought to be able to as well, especially since we don't have to worry about injuries.
This would essentially free up 10 more players per team that could be signed by other teams looking for players. This would eliminate 7-8 teams that can't recruit and go CPU each season in each league. We hardly ever go above 50 on my team, but we could run just fine with 45 players, we sign more because we can, but being at 45 would not cripple us, especially if everyone else was there as well.
beenlurken
offline
offline
Originally posted by Justargos
I do see the roster size limit as a helper tool. The NFL essentially runs with a 45 man roster, the official size is 53, but they have to declare 8 players inactive each week. If the NFL can do it then an NFL simulator ought to be able to as well, especially since we don't have to worry about injuries.
This would essentially free up 10 more players per team that could be signed by other teams looking for players. This would eliminate 7-8 teams that can't recruit and go CPU each season in each league. We hardly ever go above 50 on my team, but we could run just fine with 45 players, we sign more because we can, but being at 45 would not cripple us, especially if everyone else was there as well.
Here we go... another GLB should = NFL
The NFL is not bound by the strict rules that a game like this is... the NFL does not have strict rules on stamina/morale/etc like GLB does. The average GLB dot plays a lot more snaps.. spends a lot more time in game action than an NFL player (unless we are talking about QBs... you have to use 2 in GLB). NFL players can be elite at multiple roles where GLB dots must choose only one role to excel at. There are no strict out of position penalties in the NFL. I could go on and on about how GLB will never be like the NFL... I hope the point has sunk in.
I acknowledged that a smaller roster limit is a potential solution/helper tool.... but again, it is a poor solution, another band-aid, when the problem that should be fixed is team structure/amount of teams/plateau.
QBx2.. HBx2.. FBx2.. TEx2.. Gx4.. OTx4.. Cx2.. WRx5 = 23
DTx4.. DEx4.. SSx2.. FSx2.. LBx5.. CBx5 = 22
K/P/R =3
That right there is the bare minimum of what team needs in GLB. That is already 48 players. Considering the new effects of stamina, I would even argue that at the very least you need 6 CB's and 6 LB's and 6 WR's to really be effective (was necessary before stamina change... basically a must now). That brings us to 51.
Oh wait, what about agents who want to build STOP's and enjoy the ST aspect of the game? We going to tell them to F off because Bort wants to implement BS additions like Coaches (side note: I hope you are against coaches and have been vocal about it... it will be one more headache for you to recruit... one more aspect that will separate your team from those that are elite) instead of spending his time on league structure and plateau/decline (not to mention he wont just eliminate the CPU teams and keeps recycling these teams even though the game cant support them)... granted he apparently is working on league structure / plateau / and such but its starting to become too little too late.
That said, I dont think it is too much to allow for 4 additional players so there is room for STOP's. You drop down to a 45 limit or even 48 then all the ST'er VA's pretty much become useless. Who wants to build a defensive or offensive player but sacrifice part of there effectiveness on O and D to be skilled for ST's too?
Again, smaller roster limit = death of ST's.
I do see the roster size limit as a helper tool. The NFL essentially runs with a 45 man roster, the official size is 53, but they have to declare 8 players inactive each week. If the NFL can do it then an NFL simulator ought to be able to as well, especially since we don't have to worry about injuries.
This would essentially free up 10 more players per team that could be signed by other teams looking for players. This would eliminate 7-8 teams that can't recruit and go CPU each season in each league. We hardly ever go above 50 on my team, but we could run just fine with 45 players, we sign more because we can, but being at 45 would not cripple us, especially if everyone else was there as well.
Here we go... another GLB should = NFL
The NFL is not bound by the strict rules that a game like this is... the NFL does not have strict rules on stamina/morale/etc like GLB does. The average GLB dot plays a lot more snaps.. spends a lot more time in game action than an NFL player (unless we are talking about QBs... you have to use 2 in GLB). NFL players can be elite at multiple roles where GLB dots must choose only one role to excel at. There are no strict out of position penalties in the NFL. I could go on and on about how GLB will never be like the NFL... I hope the point has sunk in.I acknowledged that a smaller roster limit is a potential solution/helper tool.... but again, it is a poor solution, another band-aid, when the problem that should be fixed is team structure/amount of teams/plateau.
QBx2.. HBx2.. FBx2.. TEx2.. Gx4.. OTx4.. Cx2.. WRx5 = 23
DTx4.. DEx4.. SSx2.. FSx2.. LBx5.. CBx5 = 22
K/P/R =3
That right there is the bare minimum of what team needs in GLB. That is already 48 players. Considering the new effects of stamina, I would even argue that at the very least you need 6 CB's and 6 LB's and 6 WR's to really be effective (was necessary before stamina change... basically a must now). That brings us to 51.
Oh wait, what about agents who want to build STOP's and enjoy the ST aspect of the game? We going to tell them to F off because Bort wants to implement BS additions like Coaches (side note: I hope you are against coaches and have been vocal about it... it will be one more headache for you to recruit... one more aspect that will separate your team from those that are elite) instead of spending his time on league structure and plateau/decline (not to mention he wont just eliminate the CPU teams and keeps recycling these teams even though the game cant support them)... granted he apparently is working on league structure / plateau / and such but its starting to become too little too late.
That said, I dont think it is too much to allow for 4 additional players so there is room for STOP's. You drop down to a 45 limit or even 48 then all the ST'er VA's pretty much become useless. Who wants to build a defensive or offensive player but sacrifice part of there effectiveness on O and D to be skilled for ST's too?
Again, smaller roster limit = death of ST's.
Edited by beenlurken on May 26, 2010 17:06:34
MC_Hammer
offline
offline
Originally posted by beenlurken
Again, smaller roster limit = death of effective ST's.
FYP
Again, smaller roster limit = death of effective ST's.
FYP

You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.

























