User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Extra boosting incentive tied to extending player plateau
Page:
 
amace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
Originally posted by pottsman

But if the issue is "nonboosters beat boosters when both are level 32", this does nothing to level the playing field at level 32. It lets the booster have more fun with his player by giving him an extra season, but the booster also gets to have more fun by playing in uncapped leagues, which nonboosters are never high enough to truly be effective in (if you don't think uncapped are fun, then don't boost).


They are the one's that paid for the experience.. not the nonboosters therefore it makes sense to give the one that paid for the experience to experience the paid experience longer than the one that did not. How is this being overlooked.?


lol.... uncapped and AA is just a necessary step to getting to AAA and pros. they are not as fun as some might think.
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nomargfan661
+1

I think it would actually give more incentive for people to actually pay for this game. Below is a model of how it may work (boosting ability should stop at the end of the plateau point as opposed to a hard deadline at day 440) if it's implemented.

Season 1: 40 days +3
Season 2: 80 days +3
Season 3: 120 days +3
Season 4: 160 days +3
Season 5: 200 days +3
Season 6: 240 days +3
Season 7: 280 days +3
Season 8: 320 days +3
Season 9: 360 days +3
Season 10: 400 days +3
Season 11: 440 days +3 (scheduled plateau)
-------------------------------------------------------
So that's either 33 or 66 days added onto the system (let's say it's changed to 66 days for shiggles). That would give us another 2 seasons to boost.
Season 12: 480 days +3 (adds another 6 days, making the official total 72-40=32 days)
Season 13: 520 days +3 (adds another 6 days, making the official total 38 days, meaning the last day of the plateau would be on day 38 of this season).

So realistically, you could add an extra two or three seasons.



Further... that should be the idea. Give more incentives for those to want to pay to play the game.

 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
Originally posted by pottsman

But if the issue is "nonboosters beat boosters when both are level 32", this does nothing to level the playing field at level 32. It lets the booster have more fun with his player by giving him an extra season, but the booster also gets to have more fun by playing in uncapped leagues, which nonboosters are never high enough to truly be effective in (if you don't think uncapped are fun, then don't boost).


They are the one's that paid for the experience.. not the nonboosters therefore it makes sense to give the one that paid for the experience to experience the paid experience longer than the one that did not. How is this being overlooked.?


If the goal, as stated, is to level the playing field, then the level 32 nonbooster still wins. Playing field, not leveled. If the goal is to increase the plateau, there are currently free proposals being considered, or others that are less reliant on consistent paying. Additionally, again, the boosters get the better experience. Both get the same amount, but the boosters are given the good version of the game.
 
amace
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
but the boosters are given the good version of the game.


This is really what people are overlooking.

This game isn't a public service, its a business, designed to make money.

Look at it like anything else you pay for.

Software... sure, you can get free software, but it comes with poor support, upgrades are far and few in between and it lacks features. Or you can spend some money and get osme decent stuff. Would you rather work with MS paint or photoshop?

What aobut going to the grocery store. Frequently they set up little booths handing out free samples. The point? Not to feed you, but to entice you to buy more.


What people are doing, is essentially going to the grocery store and demanding they give them more free food, then leaving without buying anything.

Does that make any sense to you?
 
cosine4
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
If the goal, as stated, is to level the playing field, then the level 32 nonbooster still wins. Playing field, not leveled. If the goal is to increase the plateau, there are currently free proposals being considered, or others that are less reliant on consistent paying. Additionally, again, the boosters get the better experience. Both get the same amount, but the boosters are given the good version of the game.


This. As I stated in the other thread boosters have plenty of incentives to boost.
 
talmon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by talmon
+1


I said i would support it, i did 1 time, so now -1
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
If the goal, as stated, is to level the playing field, then the level 32 nonbooster still wins. Playing field, not leveled. If the goal is to increase the plateau, there are currently free proposals being considered, or others that are less reliant on consistent paying. Additionally, again, the boosters get the better experience. Both get the same amount, but the boosters are given the good version of the game.


the idea is that the playing field can't be leveled fairly. If you gave out TP for boosting than it opens the doors to potential exploits in training (since you'd get loads of TP at once). Also the question of how much TP per boost you get comes into question.

so in many cases you have to accept that an older player at the same level is going to be better than you. (despite the fact that you are the one that paid money). So to balance this out (and make it so you don't feel ripped off) you are given some extra time at the end of your dots career when you are going to be playing other boosters exclusively (for the most part).

edit: essentially it's a "sorry that people who don't play have an advantage over you at the start, so we are going to increase the time at the end so you get more time where your player is competing with like players"

rather than a "tough S***, that's that downside to boosting" ... as if there should be a down side for paying to play the game vs not paying to play the game
Edited by Chysil on May 13, 2010 14:43:31
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
the idea is that the playing field can't be leveled fairly. If you gave out TP for boosting than it opens the doors to potential exploits in training (since you'd get loads of TP at once). Also the question of how much TP per boost you get comes into question.

so in many cases you have to accept that an older player at the same level is going to be better than you. (despite the fact that you are the one that paid money). So to balance this out (and make it so you don't feel ripped off) you are given some extra time at the end of your dots career when you are going to be playing other boosters exclusively (for the most part).

edit: essentially it's a "sorry that people who don't play have an advantage over you at the start, so we are going to increase the time at the end so you get more time where your player is competing with like players"

rather than a "tough S***, that's that downside to boosting" ... as if there should be a down side for paying to play the game vs not paying to play the game

thus leveling the playing field that we are talking about. Think outside the box and realize that a playing field is not a particular moment in time. I can't imagine how you guys could possibly be missing the fact that this would be good for Bort to offer in the long run. It is short sighted to not even consider it... of course that doesn't surprise me coming from the group of people that are discounting it so quickly.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00

thus leveling the playing field that we are talking about. Think outside the box and realize that a playing field is not a particular moment in time. I can't imagine how you guys could possibly be missing the fact that this would be good for Bort to offer in the long run. It is short sighted to not even consider it... of course that doesn't surprise me coming from the group of people that are discounting it so quickly.


Word of the wise, if you don't want threads to turn into flame fest or get derailed, comments like these should be avoided. What do you think caused the derailing of the other thread?
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
let's not derail this! back on topic...

I almost think the # of days should be increased, like 4 days for each boost. That's a little over 3 seasons of plateau added if you always boost. But make it so you couldn't boost past day 440 still. Instead add a (decline starts: day ____) on a player profile so people knew when a player would decline.

Also it doesn't allow for "additional boosting" although that might be something bort wants (more money)
 
cosine4
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00

thus leveling the playing field that we are talking about. Think outside the box and realize that a playing field is not a particular moment in time. I can't imagine how you guys could possibly be missing the fact that this would be good for Bort to offer in the long run.


The problem that this suggestion is trying to fix is the inequality of non-boosters v. boosters at the same level. While this suggestion does give those players extra time in compensation for those less competitive times, it doesn't really solve the problem IMO. I would much rather see some training points given out with each boost, not a full level's worth just something to pull the gap closer.
 
nomargfan661
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
let's not derail this! back on topic...

I almost think the # of days should be increased, like 4 days for each boost. That's a little over 3 seasons of plateau added if you always boost. But make it so you couldn't boost past day 440 still. Instead add a (decline starts: day ____) on a player profile so people knew when a player would decline.

Also it doesn't allow for "additional boosting" although that might be something bort wants (more money)


I don't see why Bort wouldn't allow additional boosting past day 440 as long as they're still in the plateau. For every player that does this, he'd get an extra few dollars in revenue each season, and this can add up. He's losing a lot of paying players because of the short plateau, it'd help create new paying players as well as keep the paying players in the game. It might hurt him short term, but the long-term (long term as in several seasons from now) effects would be substantially in his favor.

This would help GLB get even better players, raising the "limit" to around level 80, allowing the players to maintain World League status for more than the current 2 seasons of effectiveness system. With this proposed system, I can realistically see the higher leveled players stay competitive in the World League for up to seven seasons (including the start of decline, where the players are still effective enough to perform), which is a more realistic model (NFL players are drafted at 23 on average, and the best players last about 7 years in their best years before they start declining dramatically..of course there are exceptions, but GLB doesn't need to worry about these exceptions).
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosine4
The problem that this suggestion is trying to fix is the inequality of non-boosters v. boosters at the same level. While this suggestion does give those players extra time in compensation for those less competitive times, it doesn't really solve the problem IMO. I would much rather see some training points given out with each boost, not a full level's worth just something to pull the gap closer.


Hmmm is that really the problem he says he is trying to fix? He says there is a problem that a 32 booster can't compete with a 32 nonbooster which is a fact he goes on to say that giving the booster an extra few days would earn back the time that the player lost. You can often gain something back with time rather than making something equate.
 
nomargfan661
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosine4
The problem that this suggestion is trying to fix is the inequality of non-boosters v. boosters at the same level. While this suggestion does give those players extra time in compensation for those less competitive times, it doesn't really solve the problem IMO. I would much rather see some training points given out with each boost, not a full level's worth just something to pull the gap closer.


I don't think they're unequal. Non-boosters actually have a slight advantage over the boosters in the minor leagues, however the boosters are obviously the players that will make it to the upper tiers. I've seen overall, as an owner of a lv 38 team 2 seasons ago, which is where a player's career ends if they don't boost at all during their career, that they're just about as competitive as those players who boost and are 100+ days younger. These players just have a higher upside.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosine4
The problem that this suggestion is trying to fix is the inequality of non-boosters v. boosters at the same level. While this suggestion does give those players extra time in compensation for those less competitive times, it doesn't really solve the problem IMO. I would much rather see some training points given out with each boost, not a full level's worth just something to pull the gap closer.


actually this suggestion never says anything about fixing the inequality of non-boosters vs boosters at the same level

Originally posted by Loco Moco

My suggestion is to basically repay those boosting players that are forced to compete with nonboosters early on in their "lolminor" careers.


it's about giving the boosters something because the inequality really can't be fixed in a fair way
Edited by Chysil on May 13, 2010 15:45:17
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.