User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Stop the trophies for LOL GM's
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bamaplaya1
perhaps give the real GMs a badge or something, and the gms with no responsibilities get the trophy?


I lol'd at your avatar
 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by cosine4

This is why the text under the trophy is important, it states what your actual title is so that everyone knows if you are a winning DC/OC/CFO, etc or if you have friends that are winners.


Originally posted by Dub J

I show no respect for generic GM trophies. If "GM of ..." is under the trophy all I see is "loltrophy".




yeah I agree that to the ones that have been here for a while yes we know that. But what about the new players coming in they don't know what to look for and they end up getting screwed. just this season I offered to help 2 teams out and both ended up going with coordinators that talked a big game and had a bunch of trophies. well the newby owner went with the trophies and then around midway through the season I get PM's asking for help. It literally took me half the season to fix what the dumbass's screwed up. then I hear from the owner's this week "hey thanks for all your hard work but I am selling the team" when asked why they both said it was because the way things started out for them that they would rather just make Dots.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
I'd be in favor of just doing away with the lolGM spots. Now that we've got all the titles established, why even have them? I know I've got team members on the lolGM spot, but none of them do a damn thing lol
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
I'd be in favor of just doing away with the lolGM spots. Now that we've got all the titles established, why even have them? I know I've got team members on the lolGM spot, but none of them do a damn thing lol


This! 4 stars.
 
cosine4
Moderator
offline
Link
 
The problem with taking away all lolgm positions is there are some (granted a very small %) that are key to the team or have been in the past. For example if you have an OC who has run the offense for 5 seasons and built the AI who steps down due to RL issues or whatever, then someone else steps up as OC but still uses the existing AI and they win a championship. Guy1 is no longer the "OC" but since he developed the team's OAI he did play a part in the team's performance.

Maybe only allow a limited amount of lol spots???
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
-1

I love my LOL Trophies. I'd be sad if I didn't have any trophies.
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosine4
The problem with taking away all lolgm positions is there are some (granted a very small %) that are key to the team or have been in the past. For example if you have an OC who has run the offense for 5 seasons and built the AI who steps down due to RL issues or whatever, then someone else steps up as OC but still uses the existing AI and they win a championship. Guy1 is no longer the "OC" but since he developed the team's OAI he did play a part in the team's performance.

Maybe only allow a limited amount of lol spots???


Add 1 or 2 extra titles for those extremes.. but those are really a small percent as you stated. I have seen teams with more gm's than players it seems.... gets a bit ridiculous in my opinion.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosine4
The problem with taking away all lolgm positions is there are some (granted a very small %) that are key to the team or have been in the past. For example if you have an OC who has run the offense for 5 seasons and built the AI who steps down due to RL issues or whatever, then someone else steps up as OC but still uses the existing AI and they win a championship. Guy1 is no longer the "OC" but since he developed the team's OAI he did play a part in the team's performance.

Maybe only allow a limited amount of lol spots???


Assistant OC?

With all of the spots available, I'm sure you could easily find something for that.



I actually had support remove all of my lolgm trophies, and the only ones I have now are from my team
 
JDM998
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dub J
I show no respect for generic GM trophies. If "GM of ..." is under the trophy all I see is "loltrophy".


 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
beta trophies don't matter, get over it
 
Nuldaan
offline
Link
 
+1

Love this idea.

Although, I do have a question. I have one GM trophy from a team where 20% of the players (all starters) were mine. I felt that was a large enough contribution to warrant some sort of trophy even though I wasn't a coordinator. How would you address this? Instead of a trophy per player as suggested, what about a trophy that stated how many players you had on the team?
 
talmon
offline
Link
 
Edited by talmon on May 7, 2010 15:57:17
 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by talmon


man if you don't agree or have a valid opinion then move onto the next subject you do care about. you have to understand just because something doesn't matter to you doesn't mean that it isn't important to others.
 
OH-IO ~Cult~
offline
Link
 
No matter what happens, there will always be lolgms. If we take away the GM status from the titles, it'll only get worse. People like that will get scout or recruiter. I really don't mind lolgms.
 
hatchman
Goat Father
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OH-IO
No matter what happens, there will always be lolgms. If we take away the GM status from the titles, it'll only get worse. People like that will get scout or recruiter. I really don't mind lolgms.


It isn't exactly a LOL gm that bothers me. there are some guys on my team that are basically LOL GM's as they don't have a outlined job for the team or players on the team. but they help with build advise and they help the team in the forums with gameplan discussions and such. players like that I have no problem with. but the ones that burn my ass are the guys that PM a bunch of teams and get added as GM's just to pick up a trophy. they had no ties to the team during the season but boy they want to reap the rewards when the playoffs start.

I am all for anyone that has a player on a team getting a GM trophy, I am fine with guys that are associated with a team for the whole season getting GM trophies. I just don't think it is right to add players as GM's at the start of the playoffs just to get them a trophy. and this should be stopped.

Simple fix would be to say that if you haven't been associated with the team for atleast half the season you get no trophy. and this means either being in a GM spot or having a player on the team.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.