User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > New financial plan hurts starter teams
Page:
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Not trying to man (and didn't realize I was fighting)...I just got lumped into something I didn't want to be lumped into.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
40% reduction in ticket revenues was just announced.

Thats a new tweak to the financial system. I'd been mostly quiet on the changes and I'm hardly trying to rally troops. I don;t have any troops to rally.

I just agree that the changes to team revenue (dropping by 40%) is a big deal and will likely make building a stadium much more difficult for starting owners.

I can also see how in the transitional tiers where stadiums may or may not have been completed, this could lead to a bit of a disparity that is a bigger deal than it used to be.

I've NOT been saying scrap it all entirely. I've been relatively quiet since we accomplished some re-thinking in how the financial systems/salary caps would affect players (Changed to a bonus rather than startign as a penalty, etc).

I'm not shy about the fact I do think its a bad idea, but I've also not been shy about saying I'll see how it works out.

What I am most 'not shy' about is that we're continuing to address things that very few people were really concerned about or demanding changes in and our level of involvement in making the sim work and making the game more competitive across all levels of play appears to have a back burner position.

 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
I think it was an over-sight...but at the same time, is it a bad change?

Ignoring the teams that slipped through demotion with their full stadium (those will be weeded out with time), should new teams complete a stadium in 3-4 seasons?

You also have to realize, there will be no equipment expenses.
Edited by Deathblade on May 5, 2010 13:34:54
Edited by Deathblade on May 5, 2010 13:34:27
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Well, where it is an issue is the area Plankton has pointed out. It means new team owners in say, a 14 Cap with a fresh stadium, will be dealing with teams with a much more advanced stadium. It doesn't seem on the face, to be that big of a deal, but the long term financial implications could be very rough on the new teams. Especially with the talk of shortening the development period of careers and lengthening plateaus/peak ability portion of careers. To have equal competition and footing, we'd want it to be feasible that most all owners (a very significant majority) should be able to have their stadium completed by the time they are at 'peak performance' for their players.

Attrition may take care of it, but it is still a consideration. I'm just surprised that such a radical drop in ticket prices was made. Especially when prior announcements indicated ticket pricing would remain the same, etc.

Its worth looking into. And it may not be that big of a deal. But it is another instance of ownership getting more difficult without a clear benefit to the game from the change. Increases in difficulty should be accompanied by a corresponding increase/benefit to the game.

Also, the significant tightening of funds means that many of the new gewgaws and such can't be used by lower level teams. Which means its a useless feature addition. If we're going to add the morale enhancers/reserve morale stuff, it would be more fun for teams, if they actually could use them. Sure they can use them, but they'll blow their ability to build their stadium at a reasonable pace.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Well, where it is an issue is the area Plankton has pointed out. It means new team owners in say, a 14 Cap with a fresh stadium, will be dealing with teams with a much more advanced stadium. It doesn't seem on the face, to be that big of a deal, but the long term financial implications could be very rough on the new teams.


Long term, there should be no 14 capped teams with full stadiums.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Long term, there should be no 14 capped teams with full stadiums.


I agree, but there will be 14 capped stadiums with a full bottom bowl and other 14 capped teams with only the base stadium. It seems like a small deal, but it could be bigger over time as the initial boost can set thing sin motion, and that's what I think Plankton is getting at.

New ticket price Maximum is 1.5x expected.
Since that's the new maximum, I think it is reasonable to speculate that the new teams are going to be looking at closer to 1x expected for their pricing to sell seats.

What does this do to stadium construction/time to build a stadium? These teams can reasonable 'advance' up the tiers but then get themselves in trouble/stall out because their stadium's amount of seating wont support their players expected salaries and they'll be competing against folks who will not have had this handicap and so whose stadium is likely more complete if not complete. Etc.

I'd just like to see the numbers, to be reassured that this isn't going to add another onerous burden on the new owners and make it more difficult for them to compete over time.

Especially, as previously mentioned, with there being a possibility of the shift in the plateau/peak for players. Will it be possible for the greatest majority of teams to have a full stadium by the time they reach their peak of productivity/plateau seasons?
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade

You also have to realize, there will be no equipment expenses.


If you take the time to look at the data provided, you will see that I do not have EQ expenses anywhere in the "new system" examples.

And to PP, I wasn't really targetting you in particular. You just happened to be the last person that posted. However, from the initial complaint to several of the responses, it felt like the thread was derailing.
Edited by Plankton on May 5, 2010 14:33:45
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Long term, there should be no 14 capped teams with full stadiums.


Again, if you take the time to look at the information provided, you will see that I am comparing a season 15 demoted cap 4 team (thus got the cash and stadium reset) that will be in cap 18 and a new cap 18 team. This is not some team that abused an exploit in the system. Just one that was team focused in their financial decisions.
Edited by Plankton on May 5, 2010 14:34:37
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Yeah, thats another problem as well.

My apologies Plankton I missed that as well since it wasn't put quite so plainly before.

What would you suggest to fix that issue? Starting Cap 18 teams with more sections?

 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Again, if you take the time to look at the information provided, you will see that I am comparing a season 15 demoted cap 4 team (thus got the cash and stadium reset) that will be in cap 18 and a new cap 18 team. This is not some team that abused an exploit in the system. Just one that was team focused in their financial decisions.


Except, just like teams who abused the loophole...they will work themselves out eventually.

(assuming you are comparing a cap 4 team from this season, and a cap 18 team next season)
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Yeah, thats another problem as well.

My apologies Plankton I missed that as well since it wasn't put quite so plainly before.

What would you suggest to fix that issue? Starting Cap 18 teams with more sections?



I think a reduction in construction costs should be considered. Otherwise, I don't know for sure. I am just pointing out an issue that jumped out at me immediately.

I apologize if my posts were not overly clear. I wanted to provide enough data to support my claim, and I suppose I got long winded in the process.
Edited by Plankton on May 5, 2010 14:56:58
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
I think a reduction in construction costs should be considered. Otherwise, I don't know for sure. I am just pointing out an issue that jumped out at me immediately.

I apologize if my posts were not overly clear. I wanted to provide enough data to support my claim, and I suppose I got long winded in the process.


Join the club.
 
e1iterate
favorite prism
offline
Link
 
I strongly dislike the salary cap structure.
 
Soul Reaper
offline
Link
 
Since money doesn't matter anymore except for morale and cap purposes, why not just give everyone a full stadium and scale team cash/ticket revenue based on cap level? That would give everyone an even playing field and let new owners concentrate on putting a quality team together so they can play dotball. Since cash get's reset anyways to whatever your cap level is having to build a stadium makes no sense.

 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Soul Reaper
Since money doesn't matter anymore except for morale and cap purposes, why not just give everyone a full stadium and scale team cash/ticket revenue based on cap level? That would give everyone an even playing field and let new owners concentrate on putting a quality team together so they can play dotball. Since cash get's reset anyways to whatever your cap level is having to build a stadium makes no sense.



This certainly would level the field without taking anything away from the guys that put time into it. There was a time when I enjoyed planning and building, but, to be frank, that is long gone for me. Thus, I would not mind this at all.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.