User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Alcoholism and obestiy
Page:
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RocketSlime
Yes, there are lots of people that think all diseases act the same. I mean, heart disease and the common cold are so god-damned similar.


well, they are way more similar than comparing any disorder to most any condition/infection/illness/defect.

frankly, the word 'disease' is just about meaningless at this point, other than as a catchall for the actual categories.
 
LT2501
offline
Link
 
I never said, it was or wasn't a disease in the same catchment of the common cold. the reason I posted this discussion was purely due to the fact I don't see either as a disease and wanted more information to why people consider them as diseases. for that I thank Catullus, as where i may not agree with you I see you raising some interesting points. (Oh and underactive thyroid, thanks for the correction).

again I still dont see an addiction as a disease, I was told at 14 I was an alcoholic by my doctor and now, while i still drink (i am now a student) I am by no means an alcoholic so i suppose i was more interested in the alcoholism being classified as a disease.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LT2501
I was told at 14 I was an alcoholic by my doctor


Wat

 
LT2501
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
Wat



My dad died when I was 13, I started getting drunk every night from the day after i found out, steeling alcohol, buying it with fake IDs when I could, drove my mum mad, but now have got through it, and have the greatest relationship with my mother I could ever wish for, after my doctor said the alcohol was the problem I cried for the first time, it had been 2 years.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LT2501
I never said, it was or wasn't a disease in the same catchment of the common cold.

(wasn't trying to imply that you did.)

Originally posted by LT2501
the reason I posted this discussion was purely due to the fact I don't see either as a disease and wanted more information to why people consider them as diseases. for that I thank Catullus, as where i may not agree with you I see you raising some interesting points. (Oh and underactive thyroid, thanks for the correction).

again I still dont see an addiction as a disease, I was told at 14 I was an alcoholic by my doctor and now, while i still drink (i am now a student) I am by no means an alcoholic so i suppose i was more interested in the alcoholism being classified as a disease.

most people don't see it as a disease, mostly because they're using a more common-sense understanding of the term.

however, addiction itself is a very neurobiological thing, so it's still somewhat disease-like. the truth is really in the middle, but for rehab purposes, it's always best to first thing of addiction as a symptom of what really prompted the initial behavior. the chronic side of it can't be treated as a disease until the underlying impetus is identified and dealt with first.

usually, alcoholics/etc need therapy or treatment for something else entirely -- past abuse is a frequent marker.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
or emotional trauma.

Originally posted by LT2501
My dad died when I was 13, I started getting drunk every night from the day after i found out, steeling alcohol, buying it with fake IDs when I could, drove my mum mad, but now have got through it, and have the greatest relationship with my mother I could ever wish for, after my doctor said the alcohol was the problem I cried for the first time, it had been 2 years.
 
LT2501
offline
Link
 
Exactly, theres no doubt the reason I had to deal with that issue was because of emotional trauma, fucj theres still times now I neeed a drink when something bothers me, however I have the people around me that I know I can deal with it. Of course many people who do become alcoholics etc do not ever get that help from friends, family or whoever else. However I still would not ever consider that a disease, but thats just me I suppose.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LT2501
Exactly, theres no doubt the reason I had to deal with that issue was because of emotional trauma, fucj theres still times now I neeed a drink when something bothers me, however I have the people around me that I know I can deal with it. Of course many people who do become alcoholics etc do not ever get that help from friends, family or whoever else. However I still would not ever consider that a disease, but thats just me I suppose.


indeed. and yeah, i don't consider it to be a disease either, except in the most technical/pedantic sense.

it's only the chronic aspect of addictive disorders that keeps them from being classified as injuries, so...
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
Obesity isnt a disease. Its just a bunch of lazy fuckers who cant put down the KFC. Id treat obesity with a shotgun to the face. Goddamn fat people wandering about uglying the pacle up.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek
Obesity isnt a disease. Its just a bunch of lazy fuckers who cant put down the KFC. Id treat obesity with a shotgun to the face. Goddamn fat people wandering about uglying the pacle up.


More examples why FFA needs to stay in FFA...
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
More examples why FFA needs to stay in FFA...


Im being serious. Over the winter I tend to put on weight (living in Northern Europe but not having ski slopes makes you put on weight) and I have the decency to wear looser clothes in March until Ive lost the excess weight (by excess weight I mean like 7 pounds and I never go above 180 but still). People who eat too much should be less selfish and think about what those of us who generally take care of ourselves have to look at when were trying to eat in restaurants.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FredEx
Originally posted by Catullus 16

well, they are only technically diseases because the AMA has filed them as addictive disorders, but anyone thinking that such disorders behave like the common cold is missing the entire point of the medical definition of 'disease'.

and that's without going into the politics of the AMA -- of course they call everything a disease. there's big money in that.


going into cdcollins mode here: THIS.


[X] Approves.
[X] Correct use of checkboxes.
 
Link
 
In Ireland its a disease if you aren't in this category "alcoholic" bah...
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek
Im being serious. Over the winter I tend to put on weight (living in Northern Europe but not having ski slopes makes you put on weight) and I have the decency to wear looser clothes in March until Ive lost the excess weight (by excess weight I mean like 7 pounds and I never go above 180 but still). People who eat too much should be less selfish and think about what those of us who generally take care of ourselves have to look at when were trying to eat in restaurants.


eating disorders have causes, you know.

and we're a fear-based culture. of course we consume more. give us your resources.
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
eating disorders have causes, you know.

and we're a fear-based culture. of course we consume more. give us your resources.


Yeah they have causes if you dont eat enough. If you eat too much youre just a lazy bastard. It actually takes thought and skill to lose weight (I was engaged to an anorexic so I know what Im talking about). It takes zero effort to be a fat fuck other than reaching for the next pie.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.