User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Southeast Asia AAA Leagues > Southeast Asia AAA #2 > How the fuck did I lose the MVP trophy?
Page:
 
tobewon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ateam1026
Congrats to Smash and all other MVP's.


 
Sal Basss
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rellascout
Originally posted by Sal Basss

lol... I never understood this line. How can it NOT be disrespectful when you're saying the only possible way the other guy could have won is if the system was broken?


My guy did not win because we only played 6 games that did not trigger the blowout clause. 10 games triggered Borts bullshit which Borted my players stats.



That's kind of the point of the award, man. You have a great team; a team that may have gone 16-0 even without your guy (you said it yourself). Take away Smash and his team might not make the playoffs. That's the definition of MVP and the reason the calculation is set up like it is.

It's fine if you think the system is stupid and should be changed to go to the guy with the best stats - I somewhat agree even though we already have several trophies for that - but to say the system is broken because your guy didn't win is really coming off childish.
 
tobewon
offline
Link
 
The NFL covered this pretty well by having a league MVP and an Offensive Player of the Year award.

 
bacon13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tobewon
The NFL covered this pretty well by having a league MVP and an Offensive Player of the Year award.



Probably something that should be implemented here
 
TragicOne
offline
Link
 
I'll be the one to say it here, even our player Blaze Andromeda played better than smash. With half the runs he got nearly the same yards.

That said, stats should be factored in to some amount.
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sal Basss
That's kind of the point of the award, man. You have a great team; a team that may have gone 16-0 even without your guy (you said it yourself). Take away Smash and his team might not make the playoffs. That's the definition of MVP and the reason the calculation is set up like it is.

It's fine if you think the system is stupid and should be changed to go to the guy with the best stats - I somewhat agree even though we already have several trophies for that - but to say the system is broken because your guy didn't win is really coming off childish.


As I stated several times I could give a shit about the stupid little trophy what is at issue is that a fucked up formula is used to give out EQ which is worth more than a 3 seasons boost at this level.

The reality is this fucked up system encourages manipulation of the sim and rosters. I wonder if you are aware of the fact a USA Pro team manipulated the score of games to keep their guy in the MVP race. You and Bort are also encouraging people to not build the best team they can but instead build a team that is just good enough and manipulate the numbers to win awards and games.

I could also care less if you think its childish. To me its a flaw in the system that needs to be addressed. I think that if you cannot make a better formula then they need to remove the EQ bonus from it.
Edited by rellascout on Mar 12, 2010 14:10:35
Edited by rellascout on Mar 12, 2010 14:03:41
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TragicOne
I'll be the one to say it here, even our player Blaze Andromeda played better than smash. With half the runs he got nearly the same yards.

That said, stats should be factored in to some amount.


Right his production hurts the lead guy which IMHO makes no sense.
 
tobewon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rellascout
Originally posted by TragicOne

I'll be the one to say it here, even our player Blaze Andromeda played better than smash. With half the runs he got nearly the same yards.

That said, stats should be factored in to some amount.


Right his production hurts the lead guy which IMHO makes no sense.


From what I can see, both of you fail to realize that MVP =/= best stats. Or even best player for that matter.

No question that POSP had a much better season stat wise, as did Blaze. Take the offensive production from Smash and POSP and compare it to the total offensive output of their respective teams and I am sure it would make a little more sense.



 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tobewon
From what I can see, both of you fail to realize that MVP =/= best stats. Or even best player for that matter.

No question that POSP had a much better season stat wise, as did Blaze. Take the offensive production from Smash and POSP and compare it to the total offensive output of their respective teams and I am sure it would make a little more sense.





Smash accounted for 0.441680672% of his teams offensive yardage.

Pick Speed or power was only 0.399114906 of his teams offense yardage.

Smash was 0.590909091 of their scoring.

Speed was 0.439252336 of out scoring.

I understand that but what I think does not make sense is that anyone who plays on a dynamic team is going to have trouble winning the MVP.What this stupid formula encourages is you to have only one player in the backfield. It is ripe for exploit. If I had wanted to I could have cut down Blazes production to get the MVP. Teams did this. I know for a fact a Pro team allowed a games to stay close to keep the blow out rule from going into effect to win the MVP. Again I cannot say it enough times it would not matter if he did not give away huge EQ with this fucked up award.

In the end it does not matter. I am just venting. On the list of shit that is broken in GLB this is pretty low on the list.
Edited by rellascout on Mar 12, 2010 15:56:56
Edited by rellascout on Mar 12, 2010 15:53:51
Edited by rellascout on Mar 12, 2010 15:50:37
 
Sal Basss
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rellascout
As I stated several times I could give a shit about the stupid little trophy what is at issue is that a fucked up formula is used to give out EQ which is worth more than a 3 seasons boost at this level.

The reality is this fucked up system encourages manipulation of the sim and rosters. I wonder if you are aware of the fact a USA Pro team manipulated the score of games to keep their guy in the MVP race. You and Bort are also encouraging people to not build the best team they can but instead build a team that is just good enough and manipulate the numbers to win awards and games.

I could also care less if you think its childish. To me its a flaw in the system that needs to be addressed. I think that if you cannot make a better formula then they need to remove the EQ bonus from it.


I would be all about removing the EQ bonus. I think they should remove all endorsements, period.

EDIT for lol pet pet peeve: Also, if you could care less, then you do care to some degree.
Edited by Sal Basss on Mar 12, 2010 22:56:34
 
Link
 
I vaguely remember something about teams tanking on purpose to get the MVP awards but still won by just enough not to be blowout stats. That was the huge commotion back when bort started this whole mess and then removed the equation back to our regular conference stats. After everyone saw his math teams knew how to game the system but I'm not saying that's what's going down here but it's bort common sense. Ya should have won 16 games by 1pt. Would have lessen the blow to ASEs ego.
 
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1094003 He earned that damn trophy this game! I should have seen this coming with an all rush attack.
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sal Basss
I would be all about removing the EQ bonus. I think they should remove all endorsements, period.

EDIT for lol pet pet peeve: Also, if you could care less, then you do care to some degree.


Oh I do care....!!! It keeps me up at night wondering if you really think I am childish... LOL
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Javarius Blaze
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1094003 He earned that damn trophy this game! I should have seen this coming with an all rush attack.


What do you think POSPO would put up if I ran him 100% of the time at you. Oh never mind he did the same damage on 38 carries instead of 68. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1024530 LOL
Edited by rellascout on Mar 13, 2010 07:39:13
Edited by rellascout on Mar 13, 2010 07:38:19
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Javarius Blaze
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1094003 He earned that damn trophy this game! I should have seen this coming with an all rush attack.


Like I said before he is a great HB.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.