User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Scouting Messed Up - ARCHIVED #4
Page:
 
raiderdav
offline
Link
 
I understand the desire of the admins and bug mods for us to gather information for them, but I really don't see the need with this one - it isn't a random glitch that needs to be captured. I've looked at 3 or 4 games recently and NONE have been correct.

Click a team, analyze a single game and see if the numbers match up with the Box Score.

***************************************************************************************************
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=4770&m=offense&for_team_id=0
Offense Scout the Ninjas game
Rush Plays: 31 HB, 2 FB, 16 QB = 49 Total
Pass Calls (All): 31 Total

Box Score Comparison Totals: 52 Rushes, 28 Pass Attempts, 2 Sacks
***************************************************************************************************

***************************************************************************************************
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=1192&m=offense&for_team_id=0
Offense Scout the Stanleys game

Rush Plays: 15 HB, 5 FB, 0 QB = 20 Total
Pass Calls (All): 60 Total

Box Score Comparison Totals: 21 Rushes, 59 Pass Attempts, 1 Sack
***************************************************************************************************

***************************************************************************************************
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=5771&m=offense&for_team_id=0
Offense Scout the Village Dogs game

Rush Plays: 28 HB, 0 FB, 8 QB = 36 Total
Pass Calls (All): 33 Total

Box Score Comparison Totals: 39 Rushes, 30 Pass Attempts, 3 Sacks
***************************************************************************************************

If the play call totals in the scout tool don't match the box score totals, then something is being misreported.

Edited by raiderdav on Mar 2, 2010 21:33:32
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
the problem is we need to know what the scouting tool is doing wrong. People just post "it's broke, fix it" - well what's broke about it? What plays are in there that shouldn't be? What plays aren't in there that should be?
 
simpathia
offline
Link
 
The accuracy of the scouting tool has greatly improved since the early days, thanks!
Still, occasionally it get's it wrong. Here are my examples:

Game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1026353&mode=pbp
Djibouti Booties, TE Deep Curl from I-formation:
scout tool reports 4 plays, 2 completions, 26 yards
in fact it was 4 plays, 1 completion, 23 yards
possibly the fact that one of these plays resulted in a turn-over on downs causes the problem

Same game, same team, TE In N Out from the single-back formation
scout tool reports 1 play, completed for 7 yards
in fact it was an incomplete pass, which resulted in a turn-over on downs

I admit, small sample size, but incomplete passes which result in a turn-over on downs are suspect.
All other pass plays from the two games I checked were ok (long live MonsterKill)
 
simpathia
offline
Link
 
I found two other examples where the scouting tool seems to be off.

Game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1026355&mode=pbp
TE Medium Drag from the Weak-I by Charlotte Jets
Scouting report: 4 passes, 3 completions, total 21 yards
In fact it was: 4 passes, 2 completions, total 14 yards.

None of these plays resulted in a turn-over on downs, so there must be something else going wrong.

Same game, Charlotte Jets passes from 5WR formation
Scouting report: 2 passes, no completions.
In fact it was: 3 passes, no completions.
One of the incomplete passes from 5WR resulted in a turn-over on downs, with a time-out called on the play before.
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
LOL only thing the scout option is good for is tagging players and seeing which plays teams like to run
 
simpathia
offline
Link
 
Actually the scouting pages are about 90% accurate on passes, and as far as I can tell 100% accurate on runs.
Very usable in my opinion.

Still a few errors though:
Game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1075615&mode=pbp
Team: Seoul Red Devils
Play: Double Fly from ProSet
Scout report: 2 for 2, total 45.5 yards
In reality: 1 for 2, 22.5 yards
For the incomplete pass it seems to take the result of the previous play, rounded up by 0.5 yards. (I've seen this before)

Same game, same team
Play: TE Post from Single Back
Scout report: 1 for 1, 3 yards
In reality: 0 for 1

Same game, other team: Charleston Swamp Foxes
Play: HB screen Right from Strong I
Scout report: 1 for 1, 3 yards
In reality: 0 for 1
Again here it takes the result of the previous play, rounded up by 0.5 yards

Same game, again Charleston
Play: Double Slants from the Shotgun
Scout report: 2 for 2, 4 yards
In reality: 1 for 2, 3 yards
Again on the incomplete pass it takes the result of the preceding play.

Edited by simpathia on Mar 9, 2010 12:23:14
 
simpathia
offline
Link
 
Need more data Catch? Or is this enough for the moment?
 
enasty19
offline
Link
 
Yeah, talk about bad, this is 30 rushing plays off.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1065977

We ran the ball 76 times for 612.5 yards.

Scouting tool results: http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=7521&m=offense&for_team_id=0

Shows only 44 rushes for 422.5 yards.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by enasty19
Yeah, talk about bad, this is 30 rushing plays off.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1065977

We ran the ball 76 times for 612.5 yards.

Scouting tool results: http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=7521&m=offense&for_team_id=0

Shows only 44 rushes for 422.5 yards.


Not a good example --

That 44 for 422.5 yards is only the HB rushes, then click on the QB = 30 rushes for 199 yards == 74 rushes for 621.5. The other 2 rushes are probably the 2 sacks (?).
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by enasty19
Yeah, talk about bad, this is 30 rushing plays off.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1065977

We ran the ball 76 times for 612.5 yards.

Scouting tool results: http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=7521&m=offense&for_team_id=0

Shows only 44 rushes for 422.5 yards.


Shows 74 runs, 2 passes for me. Those 2 passes resulted in sacks, so that would equal 76 rushes. Double check your check boxes.
 
enasty19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Shows 74 runs, 2 passes for me. Those 2 passes resulted in sacks, so that would equal 76 rushes. Double check your check boxes.


Forgot about the two sacks, thanks! And I forgot to check QB
 
PING72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by raiderdav
***************************************************************************************************
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=4770&m=offense&for_team_id=0
Offense Scout the Ninjas game
Rush Plays: 31 HB, 2 FB, 16 QB = 49 Total
Pass Calls (All): 31 Total

Box Score Comparison Totals: 52 Rushes, 28 Pass Attempts, 2 Sacks
***************************************************************************************************

***************************************************************************************************
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=1192&m=offense&for_team_id=0
Offense Scout the Stanleys game

Rush Plays: 15 HB, 5 FB, 0 QB = 20 Total
Pass Calls (All): 60 Total

Box Score Comparison Totals: 21 Rushes, 59 Pass Attempts, 1 Sack
***************************************************************************************************

***************************************************************************************************
http://goallineblitz.com/game/scout_team.pl?team_id=5771&m=offense&for_team_id=0
Offense Scout the Village Dogs game

Rush Plays: 28 HB, 0 FB, 8 QB = 36 Total
Pass Calls (All): 33 Total

Box Score Comparison Totals: 39 Rushes, 30 Pass Attempts, 3 Sacks
***************************************************************************************************

If the play call totals in the scout tool don't match the box score totals, then something is being misreported.



The 2nd & 3rd games are correct. Keep in mind these are reporting different things. The scout is reporting plays CALLED, the stas are reporting RESULTS. So take your 3rd example. If there are 30 pass attemtps & 3 sacks then that is 33 pass CALLS...so that's correct. If there are 36 rushes called, plus 3 sacks (which count as a rush), then the data is correct.

The first one doesn't add up, but I have a suspicion that the QB may have scrambled a few times, meaning the play call is a rush, and the stats show it as a run.
 
simpathia
offline
Link
 
That leaves the 10 or so examples that I provided as the only true bugs, amirite?
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
I'll have Catch take another look at it.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Simp in your examples can you post the pbp links for all the plays (so I can back click to the previous play). Definitely helpful though. Looks like turnover on downs and turnovers are definitely the main culprits as well as it occasionally taking the previous play data.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.