User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make weight not such a gigantic factor in realized speed
Page:
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Absolutely, 100% correct. Weight should not factor into a player's speed at a significant level until it gets into at least the ~230 lb range, and even then it shouldn't be a game breaker until you hit ~300+. Also, the impact should not be on weight alone, but on height/weight ratio - 5'11" 207 lbs isn't the same thing as 6'5" 207 lbs (the latter, BTW, is Usain Bolt).

The world's two fastest men in history - Tyson Gay and Usain Bolt - weigh in at 165 and 207 respectively (5'11" Vs. 6'5"). There's no reason why the same shouldn't true in GLB.
Edited by Crawly on Feb 2, 2010 04:26:55
 
danpenc918
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crawly
Absolutely, 100% correct. Weight should not factor into a player's speed at a significant level until it gets into at least the ~230 lb range, and even then it shouldn't be a game breaker until you hit ~300+. Also, the impact should not be on weight alone, but on height/weight ratio - 5'11" 207 lbs isn't the same thing as 6'5" 207 lbs (the latter, BTW, is Usain Bolt).

The world's two fastest men in history - Usain Bolt and Tyson Gay - weigh in at 165 and 207 respectively (5'11" Vs. 6'5"). There's no reason why the same shouldn't true in GLB.


Your 2 statements say the opposite of each other -- Is Bolt 207 or 165??
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
it's even best for power HBs as well since the increased speed from less weight more than makes up for the slight decrease in broken tackles. Does it make any sense that the best weight for a power HB is the minimum weight?


Jedi Knight confirms this (he's like 184 iirc)...and it makes no sense.
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by danpenc918
Your 2 statements say the opposite of each other -- Is Bolt 207 or 165??

Good catch. I typed it out with Gay first, and then changed the order to have Bolt first, since he's faster. Fixed.
 
mangelito
offline
Link
 
Totally agree with OP. The weights especially needs to be looked at. Shouldn't affect the speed and acceleration too much unless we are talking O-line sizes...
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
I support this suggestion.
 
Link
 
I have to disagree tbh. I remember way back when People wanted to know how much of a factor height and weight were and how seemingly everyone wanted it to be a bigger factor. But now, it is and now everyone regrets asking for it so they want it to disappear again. I like it. Keep it the way it is and move on to the next improvement to the sim.
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Riley
I have to disagree tbh. I remember way back when People wanted to know how much of a factor height and weight were and how seemingly everyone wanted it to be a bigger factor.

I don't think the issue being discussed here is how big of a factor they are - it's the way they're factored in. In real life, there's no inherent speed difference between someone at 165 lbs and someone at 205 lbs, yet in GLB, there's a huge difference. It might be enough to just re-bracket the weight classes (or bracket them, if they weren't bracketed in the first place), but this is a significant issue right now.

 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
bump
 
puubescent
offline
Link
 
The height/weight options in this game don't allow for height/weight to be a factor.

Spread out the height/weight options. Give the bonus/penalty for having tall/short/skinny/fat players. Also, put 'caps' on attributes depending on the height/weight chosen.

Big fatty lineman at 6'9" and 355 lbs is as strong as an ox at 'birth', but can't move very well when he peaks. He can't get above 48 speed or 61 agility naturally (equipment is needed to get them higher).

Or little RB at 5'7" and 165 lbs is so fast, but limited on his strength to only 48 naturally.

Obviously these are just examples and the real thing would be more thought out and have more penalties/bonuses. This way there is a big risk/reward for building a 'freak'.
 
Link
 
i've always assumed that some update in the game inadvertantly changed how weight affects the game, and bort never bothered to change the system back. i even had a conversation back in april 08 with DD (back when things like that were possible) asking him a few questions about how height would affect agility/balance, and got a pretty stern "dont be silly" response.

regardless, wont the new rolling system more or less make this pointless? in a year 99% of wr's will weight 180lbs... the rest will probably be playing in APL.


lolololololol.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Posted this in another thread. (And really, I've been saying since before I even knew height and weight actually were a factor, in response to someone who wanted them to be a factor) Originally posted by TrevJo
I'd really really really really like to see the function of height and weight change.
Instead of the sim modifying your strength, speed, agility, stamina on the fly depending on your height and weight, height and weight should simply affect your soft caps. More weight? Higher strength soft cap, lower speed soft cap. More height? More vision, less agility. And lots of other similar effects, some large, some small.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Also, kudos to w_alloy for a well-stated post.

Originally posted by kalkmanc
Agree completely.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ratphlegm
I support this suggestion.


 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Example 1: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=918835&pbp_id=7555051

Example 2: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1001579&pbp_id=1346505

Both players are the same speed (one is .36 faster). Both players have roughly the same agility (one has ~3 more). Both players are the same age and level of decline in the replays. Neither game is a blow-out at the point of their runs, so no cruise control. There's 29 lbs and 4 inches difference in player weight/height though.

The difference in max speed is 0.34 (i.e. ~1.3% difference from player 2 to player 1). So let's do a little math... 2 points at 80 speed is 2.5% (the visible player creation benefit of being lighter), thus the player in example 2 should be ~2.5% faster if the weight bonus to speed was proportional (or be running at 26.75 max speed). The funny thing is that the heavier player should be slower, no? Well he's actually faster, has better acceleration and has slightly worse attributes. X-factor? Changes to speed from S13 to S14? Speed script is faulty?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=919287&pbp_id=11952254 in S13 he was .48 faster than player 1 in the speed script (.82 faster than he is this season btw)... which is almost exactly what you would expect from a player that is 2.5% faster due to weight (more like 2%, but close enough).

I'm just throwing out some data, you guys make your own conclusions.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.